Pet Store Shift Supervisor: Lead Team & Neighborly Service

Pet Supplies Plus

Cincinnati (OH)

On-site

USD 22,000 - 30,000

Full time

2 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Employee Discounts
Flexible Schedules
Pay Increases & Pet Care Training
Promotion From Within Culture
Medical, Dental & Vision Plans (Full‑T

Job summary

Pet Supplies Plus is seeking a Store Shift Supervisor in Cincinnati, OH to lead a team and ensure exceptional neighborly service. You will assist customers, oversee store operations, and reinforce standard procedures throughout shifts.

The role requires 2+ years in retail, strong sales and customer service skills, and the ability to operate equipment including a forklift. The position offers flexible schedules and growth opportunities.

Qualifications

  • High school diploma or GED required.
  • Minimum 2 years of retail experience.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Office.
  • Strong sales and customer service skills.
  • Ability to operate equipment, including a forklift, and lift up to 50 pounds.
  • Flexible schedules and reliable transportation; must be 18+ and pass drug screening.

Responsibilities

  • Provide neighborly, exceptional service to customers throughout the shift.
  • Greet customers, assist in product selection, and support store operations.
  • Lead and reinforce PSP standards and daily management routines.
  • Provide leadership coverage up to four times a week when supervisors are offsite.
  • Assist with recruiting, onboarding, and team development.

Skills

Customer service
Sales
Forklift operation
Team leadership

Education

High School Diploma or GED

Tools

Microsoft Office

Job description

Pet Supplies Plus is seeking a Store Shift Supervisor in Cincinnati, OH to lead a team and ensure exceptional neighborly service. You will assist customers, oversee store operations, and reinforce standard procedures throughout shifts.

The role requires 2+ years in retail, strong sales and customer service skills, and the ability to operate equipment including a forklift. The position offers flexible schedules and growth opportunities.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Pet-First Store Shift Supervisor
Pet-First Store Shift Supervisor

Pet Supplies Plus 4007 • Cincinnati (OH)

On-site
USD 35,000 - 45,000
Career Growth & Advancement Opportunities
Competitive Pay
Community-focused team environment
Pet Store Shift Supervisor: Flexible Hours & Leadership
Pet Store Shift Supervisor: Flexible Hours & Leadership

Pet Supplies Plus • Findlay (OH)

On-site
USD 38,000 - 54,000
Employee discounts
Flexible schedules
Training programs
+4
Pet Store Shift Leader: Service, Ops & Growth
Pet Store Shift Leader: Service, Ops & Growth

Pet Supplies Plus • Cleveland (TN)

On-site
USD 19,000 - 28,000
Employee Discounts
Flexible Schedules
Pay Increases & Pet Care Training
+4
Pet Store Shift Supervisor - Hands-On Team Leader
Pet Store Shift Supervisor - Hands-On Team Leader

Pet Supplies Plus • Ashtabula (OH)

On-site
USD 15,000 - 20,000
Be part of a neighborly, community-?or
Career Growth & Advancement Opport...
Competitive Pay
+1
Pet-First Store Shift Supervisor | Flexible Schedule
Pet-First Store Shift Supervisor | Flexible Schedule

Pet Supplies Plus • Newport (KY)

On-site
USD 32,000 - 42,000
401(k) matching
Health insurance
Paid time off
+5
Pet Store Shift Lead - Customer Care & Ops
Pet Store Shift Lead - Customer Care & Ops

Pet Supplies Plus 247 • Manitowoc (WI)

On-site
USD 21,000 - 30,000
Neighborly team culture
Career Growth & Advancement
Competitive Pay
+1
Pet Store Shift Leader - Flexible Hours & Growth
Pet Store Shift Leader - Flexible Hours & Growth

Pet Supplies Plus • Vienna (WV)

On-site
USD 32,000 - 42,000
Employee Discounts
Flexible Schedules
Pay Increases
+1
Shift Supervisor — Lead, Serve & Grow in a Pet Store
Shift Supervisor — Lead, Serve & Grow in a Pet Store

Pet Supplies Plus • Springfield (OH)

On-site
USD 34,000 - 45,000
Employee Discounts
Flexible Schedules
Pay Increases & Pet Care Training
+4
Pet Store Shift Leader: Flexible, Neighborly Service
Pet Store Shift Leader: Flexible, Neighborly Service

Pet Supplies Plus 4074 • Millcreek Township (PA)

On-site
USD 38,000 - 52,000
Bonus based on performance
Health insurance
Dental insurance
+1
Pet Store Shift Supervisor — Flexible Schedules & Growth
Pet Store Shift Supervisor — Flexible Schedules & Growth

Pet Supplies Plus • Racine (WI)

On-site
USD 21,000 - 28,000
Employee Discounts
Flexible Schedules
Pay Increases & Pet Care Training
+4