Personal Lines Client Service Manager II

Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. (AJG); Cape Coral (FL); Hybrid; USD 70,000 - 100,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Career development

Ongoing learning

Collaborative culture

Global reach

Job summary

Gallagher is seeking a Senior Personal Lines Client Service Manager II to lead complex client relationships, shape strategy, and drive smarter coverage solutions. You will work in a collaborative environment, using data-driven insights to identify gaps, growth opportunities, and elevate the client experience with a consultative approach.

This full-time role offers hybrid/remote flexibility, with remote arrangements for those living beyond 50 miles from the Cape Coral, Florida office, and

Qualifications

• Progressive experience in insurance client service or account management.
• Active P&C license with knowledge of coverage and endorsements.
• Ability to manage moderately complex Personal Lines accounts independently.
• Strong communication and consultative approach.

Responsibilities

• Own and grow a Personal Lines portfolio with high-quality client service.
• Lead renewals end-to-end, aligning coverage with risk and timelines.
• Build client relationships through proactive engagement to drive retention.
• Identify policy gaps and provide coverage solutions to support cross-sell and growth.
• Provide expert guidance on complex coverage decisions and resolve service challenges.
• Ensure accuracy, compliance, and continuous process improvement.
• Act as a team leader, sharing expertise to support a high-performance culture.
• Leverage data and digital tools to deliver efficient, modern client service.

Skills

Client relationship management

P&C license

Account management

Communication skills

Team leadership

Data-driven decisions

Job description

Introduction

At Gallagher, we help clients face risk with confidence because we believe that when businesses are protected, they're free to grow, lead, and innovate. You'll be backed by our digital ecosystem: a client-centric suite of consulting tools making it easier for you to meet your clients where they want to be met. Advanced data and analytics providing a comprehensive overview of the risk landscape is at your fingertips. Here, you're not just improving clients' risk profiles, you're building trust. You'll find a culture grounded in teamwork, guided by integrity, and fueled by a shared commitment to do the right thing. We value curiosity, celebrate new ideas, and empower you to take ownership of your career while making a meaningful impact for the businesses we serve. If you're ready to bring your unique perspective to a place where your work truly matters; think of Gallagher.

Overview

Take your expertise to the next level. As a Senior Personal Lines Client Service Manager II, you'll lead complex client relationships with confidence, shaping strategy, influencing decisions, and driving smarter coverage solutions. You'll operate in a collaborative environment, using your insight to identify gaps, unlock growth opportunities, and elevate the client experience through a more consultative, forward-thinking approach. Powered by innovation and supported by accessible leadership, this is your opportunity to lead from the front and make a measurable impact.

This full-time position offers flexibility for both hybrid and remote work arrangements. Candidates seeking a remote arrangement must live more than 50 miles from our Cape Coral, Florida office.

How you'll make an impact

• Own and grow a Personal Lines portfolio, delivering a high-quality, relationship-driven client experience.

• Lead complex renewals end-to-end, aligning coverage with risk and managing timelines effectively.

• Build strong client relationships through proactive engagement, anticipating needs and driving retention.

• Take a consultative approach, identifying policy gaps and provide coverage solutions supporting cross-sell and account growth goals.

• Provide expert guidance on complex coverage decisions and resolve service challenges independently.

• Ensure operational excellence through accuracy, compliance, and continuous process improvement.

• Act as a team leader, sharing expertise and supporting a high-performance, collaborative culture.

• Leverage data and digital tools to deliver efficient, modern client service.

• Drive retention, satisfaction, and portfolio growth through consistent, insight-led delivery.

About You

• Bring progressive experience in insurance client service or account management, managing moderately complex Personal Lines accounts independently.

• Hold an active P&C license with strong knowledge of coverage, policy terms, endorsements, and service processes.

• Provide expert support on complex client inquiries, delivering clear, coverage-focused guidance.

• Communicate effectively with a consultative approach, building trust and simplifying complexity.

• Demonstrate strong judgment and ownership, confidently resolving complex issues and navigating ambiguity.

• Stay highly organized and detail-oriented, managing competing priorities and renewal timelines effectively.

• Apply a continuous improvement mindset, identifying inefficiencies and enhancing service delivery.

• Collaborate and influence through expertise, supporting team performance without formal authority.

• Act as a relationship builder, problem solver, focused on strong client outcomes and career progression.

#LI-TW1

#LI-HYBRID

Compensation and benefits

At Gallagher, we believe supporting our colleagues goes far beyond the role itself. For more information, visit our Benefits page.

• Competitive compensation

• Comprehensive benefits programs designed to support your well-being

• Career development opportunities and ongoing learning

• A collaborative, people-first culture with accessible leadership

• The opportunity to do meaningful work with global reach and local impact

At Gallagher, we are dedicated to building an inclusive and authentic workplace. If your past experience doesn't align perfectly, we encourage you to join our Talent Community to stay connected to additional career opportunities. At times, we will consider transferable skills from previous roles.

Gallagher is an affirmative action/equal opportunity employer (Minorities/Females/Veterans/Disabled)