Evening & Overnight Behavioral Health Shift Supervisors

Henry Street; New York (NY); On-site; USD 41,000 - 50,000; Full time

Job summary

Henry Street Settlement in New York City seeks a Shift Supervisor to oversee the Third Street Women’s Residence on evenings, nights, and weekends. The role requires crisis management, staff supervision, and coordination with interdisciplinary teams to uphold standards and support residents toward permanent housing.

Responsibilities include supervision, client intake and assessments, service planning, safety, reporting, and collaboration with partners.

Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree preferred or at least three years in human services.
• Flexibility to cover additional shifts as needed.
• Crisis intervention experience.
• Excellent written and verbal communication skills.
• Bilingual (English/Spanish) preferred.
• Strong computer proficiency.

Responsibilities

• Train, coaching, and conduct performance evaluations for assigned staff.
• Provide guidance to ensure staff follow policies and Henry Street values.
• Interview prospective residents and complete intake documentation.
• Conduct client assessments and document changes in condition or service needs.
• Develop practical service plans to support stability and housing goals.
• Provide crisis intervention and appropriate support during emergencies.
• Maintain safety and security within the residence and conduct fire drills.
• Maintain accurate client records and program documentation.
• Prepare daily, weekly, and monthly reports; document incidents and follow up.
• Collaborate with interdisciplinary teams and internal/external partners.
• Maintain meal sign-in logs, track expenditures, and support staff as needed.

Skills

Crisis intervention

Strong communication

Bilingual English/Spanish

Computer proficiency

Crisis management

Education

Bachelor's degree preferred or 3+ years in human services

CPR/First Aid certification

Fire Safety Director certification

Job description

Introduction

Henry Street Settlement is like no other organization, and our positions are not ordinary jobs. Every day Henry Street’s dedicated team carries out a 130-year blueprint of service to our community established by our founder, Lillian Wald, in 1893.

Overview

Job Overview:

• Division/Department: Transitional and supportive housing/ Third Street Women’s Residence
• Location: Fully Onsite – Lower East Side, NYC
• Pay: $45,500 Annually + full benefits package non-exempt
• Position Type: Regular, Full-Time
• Schedule: 35 hours per week (Shift-based schedule)

Available Shifts (7 days per week) including Holidays:

• 5:30 PM – 1:30 AM
• 1:30 AM – 9:30 AM

Relief Coverage Requirement:

This position requires flexibility to cover additional shifts as needed in the event of staff callouts or no-shows (face-to-face relief coverage).

Organizational Overview

Henry Street Settlement opens doors of opportunity to enrich lives and expand human progress for Lower East Side residents and other New Yorkers through social services, arts, and health care programs. Building on its 130+ year legacy of innovation and effective programming, Henry Street offers more than 50 programs and is one of New York City’s largest social service organizations.

Program Overview

The Third Street Women’s Residence is a transitional shelter program serving 79 Unhoused women who are living with Behavioral health conditions and are seeking permanent housing. The program provides transitional housing and comprehensive supportive services designed to help residents stabilize, develop life management skills, and successfully transition to permanent housing. Staff provide social services and housing placement assistance while supporting residents in managing their mental health and achieving greater independence. When appropriate, residents are referred to community-based resources and partner organizations.

Job Summary

The Shift Supervisor is responsible for the day-to-day operational management of the residence during assigned shifts, including evenings, weekends, holidays and overnight coverage as scheduled. The Shift Supervisor provides direct supervision to program staff and ensures that residents receive services that meet regulatory, contractual, and agency standards, including housing placement outcomes. This role requires strong crisis management, operational oversight, and coordination with interdisciplinary teams to support residents and improve their quality of life and progress toward permanent housing.

Responsibilities

Staff Supervision

• Train, coaching, and conduct performance evaluations for assigned staff
• Provide guidance and support to ensure staff follow program policies and Henry Street Settlement Values

Client Services

• Utilizing a client strength base and trauma informed approach and interview prospective residents and complete intake documentation
• Conduct client assessments and document changes in condition or service needs
• Develop practical service plans to support resident stability and housing goals
• Provide crisis intervention and appropriate support during emergencies

Program Operations

• Maintain safety and security within the residence
• Conduct scheduled fire drills and ensure compliance with safety procedures
• Perform regular facility walkthroughs and rounds to ensure compliance with fire safety and Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance (OTDA) standards
• Maintain accurate client records, census logs, and program documentation

Reporting and Documentation

• Prepare daily, weekly, and monthly reports
• Document incidents and ensure timely follow-up
• Maintain accurate program records and client data

  Collaboration

  • Participate in interdisciplinary team meetings to review resident cases and service plans
  • Maintain effective communication across program units and staff teams
  • Build collaborative working relationships with internal staff and external partners

  Administrative Duties

  • Maintain daily meal sign-in logs for residents
  • Track and maintain expenditure records
  • Support security, maintenance and kitchen staff as needed
  • Perform other duties as assigned by the supervisor

  Essential Physical Requirements

  • Ability to stand for extended periods and walk stairs throughout the facility
  • Ability to work fully onsite in the Lower East Side

  Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree is preferred, or a minimum of three (3) years of relevant experience in human services, behavioral health Shelter, or a related field
  • flexibility to cover additional shifts as needed in the event of staff callouts or no-shows
  • Ability to obtain the following certifications within the first three (3) months of employment:
    • CPR/First Aid
    • Fire Safety Director / Fire Safety and Alarm Systems (F-80) certification
  • Experience providing crisis intervention
  • Strong computer proficiency
  • Strong clinical assessment and documentation skills
  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills
  • Bilingual (English/Spanish) preferred

  Additional Information

  • FLSA Status: Non-Exempt
  • Worker Type: Regular (Benefits Eligible)
  • References Required?: Yes
  • Background Check Required?: Yes
  • Proof of Education Required?: Yes