Senior Subrogation Adjuster – Hybrid Negotiation

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.; Chicago (IL); Hybrid; USD 70,000 - 95,000; Full time

Job summary

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. in Chicago is seeking a Property Subrogation Adjuster to conduct prompt, independent review of subrogation claims through coverage analysis, investigation, evaluation and negotiation.

This hybrid role requires collaboration with insureds, claimants, adverse parties and counsel across multiple jurisdictions, while upholding AmTrust’s standards and claims procedures. Responsibilities include documenting strategy, timely communication, and effective settlement

Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree or equivalent experience.
• 3–5 years of subrogation claims handling experience or a strong understanding of liability determinations.
• State licensure as required.
• Demonstrated proficiency with MS Office suites.
• Demonstrated skills in investigation, evaluation and negotiation.
• Strong knowledge of insurance theory and practices.

Responsibilities

• Investigates the claim or coverage by making timely and appropriate contact with involved or interested parties including but not limited to the insured or employer representatives, claimant or injured party, witnesses, producers and adverse parties.
• Documents strategy, action plan, and summary of correspondence in a clear, succinct and fact-based manner
• Verifies liability and negligence scenario for the jurisdiction. Reviews issues and scenarios are needed with some supervisor guidance. Typically utilizes standardized language to draft positions if needed.
• Notifies all potential parties, legal representative and insurance companies of our subrogation interest.
• Ensures quality and timeline service is provided to all internal and external customers, whether directly or indirectly.
• While working with internal or assigned Legal Counsel, will build strong relationships, and apply company principles and standards
• Effectively negotiates and resolves litigated and non-litigated subrogation claims, and leverages relationships to achieve optimal outcomes.
• Gains trust of other parties to negotiations and demonstrates good sense of timing.
• Manages and controls loss adjustment expenses
• Builds and leverages critical thinking and decision-making skills to gather, assess, analyze, question, verify, interpret and understand key or root issues.
• Manages time and diary entries effective and efficiently, prioritizing work in a fast-paced environment.
• Escalates claims decisions regarding settlement determination when appropriate to management.
• Performs other functional duties as assigned.

Skills

Investigation

Negotiation

Analytical thinking

MS Office

Education

Bachelor’s degree or equivalent experience

Tools

MS Office

Job description

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. in Chicago is seeking a Property Subrogation Adjuster to conduct prompt, independent review of subrogation claims through coverage analysis, investigation, evaluation and negotiation.

This hybrid role requires collaboration with insureds, claimants, adverse parties and counsel across multiple jurisdictions, while upholding AmTrust’s standards and claims procedures. Responsibilities include documenting strategy, timely communication, and effective settlement