Senior Premium Audit Leader — Complex Accounts & Training

Selective Insurance Company of America; Hamilton Township (NJ); On-site; USD 92,000 - 119,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Health care plans

Retirement plan with company match

Employee Stock Purchase Program

Tuition assistance

Paid time off

Job summary

Selective Insurance Company of America in New Jersey is seeking a Senior Premium Audit Supervisor to oversee regional premium audit operations and ensure timely, accurate audits across commercial lines.

You will mentor auditors, coordinate with claims, underwriting, and accounting, and drive process improvements while maintaining compliance with regulatory requirements. The role may require travel and strong communication skills are essential.

Qualifications

• Must be able to effectively communicate premium audit decisions to agents and insureds.
• Maintains familiarity with all insurance manuals, premium audit manuals, handbooks, guides and related materials.
• Ability to work independently without direct supervision.
• Intermediate to advanced computer skills required including auditing software and Microsoft Office.
• Possesses strong interpersonal skills.
• Able to climb stairs and occasionally carry 20 pounds.
• May require overnight travel.
• Must have valid state-issued driver’s license in good standing.

Responsibilities

• Recommend procedural changes and implement department guidelines and initiatives.
• Supervise team regarding service standards.
• Organize training plans for premium audit staff; provide progress updates to Sr Premium Audit Manager.
• Develop and distribute administrative reports as needed.
• Act as liaison with claims, underwriting, accounting, and safety management; provide guidance to agents.
• Reconcile audit discrepancies and decide disputed audits and rule applications.
• Ensure compliance with state regulations and maintain documentation.
• Review audits for quality and compliance; perform QA.
• Oversee audits for complex commercial lines and visit insureds to audit records.

Skills

Audit expertise

Communication

Interpersonal skills

MS Office

Auditing software

Education

College degree

APA certification

Tools

Auditing software

Microsoft Office

Job description

Selective Insurance Company of America in New Jersey is seeking a Senior Premium Audit Supervisor to oversee regional premium audit operations and ensure timely, accurate audits across commercial lines.

You will mentor auditors, coordinate with claims, underwriting, and accounting, and drive process improvements while maintaining compliance with regulatory requirements. The role may require travel and strong communication skills are essential.