Night-Shift Store Supervisor — Bonus Eligible & Lead a Team

Sheetz; Lancaster (OH); On-site; USD 25,000 - 32,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Quarterly bonuses

PTO

Parental leave

401k match

Employee stock ownership

Tuition reimbursement

Medical, Vision, Dental coverage

Snack discounts

Job summary

Sheetz is seeking a Supervisor to lead a store team with high energy and a customer-first mindset. You will oversee daily operations, mentor teammates, and ensure exceptional hospitality across all customer touchpoints.

The role includes an evening shift premium of $1.50/hr for working 10pm–6am, plus potential quarterly bonuses and strong benefits. Join a company that values growth, development, and teamwork.

Qualifications

• Must be 18 years of age or older (VA state law requires Supervisor’s to be 21 years of age or older for certain tasks).
• Ability to multi-task, stand, bend, reach, and lift up to 20 pounds; may assist lifting up to 40 pounds.

Responsibilities

• Welcome customers to our stores with greetings and top-tier customer service
• Make magic happen by serving up quality food and beverages made to exact customer specifications in a safe, fast and friendly manner
• Mentor and coach your work fam to prioritize tasks and rock it as a Team Member
• Keep an eye on the goodz in-store to make sure that products are ordered, merchandised, rotated and readily-available for our customers
• Keep thingz clean in the store, kitchen, and dining areas

Skills

Multitasking

Physical stamina

Team leadership

Job description

Sheetz is seeking a Supervisor to lead a store team with high energy and a customer-first mindset. You will oversee daily operations, mentor teammates, and ensure exceptional hospitality across all customer touchpoints.

The role includes an evening shift premium of $1.50/hr for working 10pm–6am, plus potential quarterly bonuses and strong benefits. Join a company that values growth, development, and teamwork.