Stand out for this role — generate a tailored resume and cover letter in about a minute.
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza in Wantagh, NY is seeking a Dining Room Supervisor to assist the General Manager with daily Front of House operations, guest service, and profitability. You will supervise hourly team members, coach staff, and ensure a welcoming, sanitary dining environment.
The role emphasizes leadership, scheduling, cash handling, and adherence to company standards. Nights, weekends and holidays are required; ServSafe Manager certification is preferred or obtainable.
At Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza, we are fired up—literally. Our signature coal-fired ovens and made from scratch recipes set us apart, but it is our people who make the difference. If you are looking for more than just a job and want to be part of a family that values passion, quality, and hospitality—this is the place for you. We don’t just talk about culture—we live it. A Dining Room Supervisor plays a key leadership role in supporting the General Manager with the daily operations of the Front of House.
This position is responsible for supervising hourly team members, ensuring a clean and welcoming environment, delivering exceptional guest service, and helping to drive restaurant profitability. Responsibilities include overseeing floor operations, maintaining sanitation standards, and completing administrative tasks in alignment with company policies. The Dining Room Supervisor leads by example—coaching and developing team members, providing clear direction, and consistently reinforcing Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza’s standards, values, and guest-first culture.
* Have a proven drive for quality guest service in the Restaurant Industry.
* Problem solve and handle high stress situations in a fast-paced environment.
* Have motivation with strong interpersonal, organizational, time management skills.
* Have excellent written and verbal communication skills.
* Have strong leadership and assessment skills.
* Be willing to work nights, weekends and Holidays.
* Have or obtain ServSafe Manager’s Certificate.
Prior experience as a general manager, manager, assistant manager, supervisor, shift lead positions are desirable.
We offer hands-on training, opportunities for career growth, and a supportive team environment.
3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA