Claims Support Supervisor

Security First Insurance; Ormond Beach (FL); On-site; USD 55,000 - 75,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Fitness center

Complimentary chef-prepared lunches

Walking trail

Team member appreciation events

Food truck events

Professional development opportunities

Competitive benefits package (medical,

401(k) and more

Job summary

Security First Insurance in Florida seeks a Claims Support Supervisor to lead the Claims Support team, overseeing daily assignments, quality reviews, and vendor coordination. You will coach staff, monitor workloads, and drive process improvements to ensure accuracy, timeliness, and service excellence across the department.

You will escalate issues, manage vendor-related tasks, assist payroll and timekeeping, and partner with Claims leadership on initiatives.

Qualifications

• High school diploma or equivalent.
• Four years of relevant experience including one year in a supervisory role.
• Experience in administrative and operational support within a claims environment is a plus.

Responsibilities

• Directly supervise Claims Support Specialists and coordinate daily work.
• Monitor productivity, service levels, and workload distribution.
• Review work for accuracy and compliance with procedures.
• Escalate issues related to vendor management, invoicing, and onboarding.
• Coordinate vendor processes and maintain contact information.
• Support payroll administration, attendance, and timekeeping.
• Assist the Claim Support Manager with communications and reports.
• Identify process improvements to increase efficiency.
• Maintain performance metrics and reports on team activity.
• Collaborate with leadership and partners on initiatives and customer service.

Skills

Supervisory experience

Leadership

Team coordination

Vendor management

Education

High school diploma or equivalent

Job description

Summary Of Position

Performs supervisory and operational leadership responsibilities for the Claims Support team at Security First Insurance (Company). Responsible for the daily oversight, coordination, and quality review of Claim Support Specialists who provide administrative and operational support to the Claims Department. Ensures work is completed accurately, timely, and in accordance with company standards while serving as a resource for claims staff, vendors, and internal business partners. The position monitors workloads, assigns work, assists with process improvements, delivers coaching and feedback, and supports special projects and departmental initiatives. The Claims Support Supervisor serves as the primary point of escalation for administrative support functions and helps ensure consistency, efficiency, and service excellence across the team.

Essential Job Functions

• Directly supervises Claims Support Specialists and coordinates daily work assignments and priorities.
• Monitors team productivity, service levels, and workload distribution to ensure timely completion of assigned tasks.
• Reviews work for accuracy, completeness, and compliance with departmental procedures.
• Serves as the first point of escalation for issues involving vendor management, invoice processing, bulk payments, onboarding activities, and other administrative support functions.
• Assists with coordinating and monitoring vendor-related processes, including maintaining vendor contact information and ensuring proper documentation.
• Supports payroll administration, attendance monitoring, timekeeping, scheduling, and related administrative functions for direct reports.
• Assists the Claim Support Manager with communications, reporting, and special projects.
• Identifies process improvement opportunities and recommends changes to increase efficiency and effectiveness.
• Maintains performance metrics and prepares reports related to team activities and operational results.
• Collaborates with Claims leadership and business partners to support departmental initiatives and customer service objectives.

Minimum Requirements

• High school diploma or equivalent
• Four (4) years of directly related experience including one (1) year of supervisory

Experience

• OR an equivalent combination of education, certification, training, and/or experience

Why You'll Love Working Here

We're serious about our work but we also believe work should be enjoyable. Our offices were designed with our team members in mind and includes:

• State-of-the-art fitness center
• Complimentary chef-prepared lunches monthly
• Beautiful walking trail around our offices
• Team Member appreciation events throughout the year
• Food truck events featuring local favorites
• Professional development, mentoring, and continuing education
• Competitive benefits package including medical, dental, vision, paid time off, 401(k), and more

At Security First, you'll find a collaborative culture where people genuinely enjoy working together and where your expertise is valued.