Personal Lines Property and Casualty Underwriting Supervisor

Portage Mutual Insurance; Edmonton; Hybrid; CAD 77,000 - 95,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Hybrid work arrangement

Competitive salary

Incentive plan

Health benefits

Pension plan

Paid time off (personal days)

Tuition reimbursement

Bonuses

Job summary

Portage Mutual Insurance in Edmonton seeks an experienced Personal Lines P&C Underwriting Supervisor to lead a team of underwriters and ensure quality decisions within risk appetite. You will guide complex cases, coach staff, and strengthen broker partnerships in a collaborative environment.

The role requires a strong background in personal lines underwriting, leadership abilities, and strategic thinking, with a hybrid work arrangement in Edmonton and a salary range of CAD 76,600–95,000.

Qualifications

• Experienced in personal lines underwriting with leadership or supervisory background.
• Strong knowledge of underwriting principles, risk analysis, pricing, and product development.
• Proven ability to coach, mentor and build broker relationships.
• Excellent written and verbal communication with internal and external stakeholders.

Responsibilities

• Oversee underwriting policies, procedures and service standards across the team.
• Provide technical guidance on complex risks and sound decision-making.
• Conduct post-loss reviews to identify trends and improvement opportunities.
• Develop and implement underwriting guidelines and best practices.
• Maintain relationships with brokers and collaborate with cross-functional teams.
• Lead recruitment, onboarding and ongoing development for team members.
• Contribute to strategic underwriting initiatives and market insights.

Skills

Leadership

Underwriting Expertise

Communication Skills

Analytical Thinking

Relationship Building

Strategic Thinking

Adaptability

Team Coaching

Education

Bachelor’s degree in finance, business, or related field

CIP designation

CRM or FCIP designation

Tools

Guidewire

MS Office

Job description

About Portage Mutual: Where Your Talent Makes a Difference

Imagine a workplace where your contributions are not only valued but also directly impact the lives of Canadians. At Portage Mutual Insurance, we’re more than just a trusted national property and casualty insurer—we’re a community of passionate individuals dedicated to serving our policyholders since 1884. Owned by our policyholders, we proudly offer competitive home, auto, commercial, and farm insurance products 100% through our broker network across Canada. Join a company rooted in tradition, driven by innovation, and powered by a people-first culture.

Why Portage Mutual?

At Portage Mutual, we believe that our people are our greatest asset. Here, you’ll find:

• Total Rewards: We care about your well-being and financial security. That’s why we offer a competitive salary, incentive plan, comprehensive health benefits, a pension plan and generous paid time off, including personal days.
• Career Growth & Development: Propel your career forward with access to diverse learning resources, tuition reimbursement for relevant programs, and bonuses recognizing your achievements in pursuing insurance designations.
• Flexibility: We support work-life integration by offering a flexible environment where you can choose to live wherever you prefer in Canada. Enjoy the freedom to select remote, in-office, and hybrid work arrangements that best suit your lifestyle.
• Inclusivity and Belonging: Be a part of a supportive and diverse team that embraces your unique perspective and empowers you to succeed. We’re dedicated to creating a workplace where every employee feels welcomed, valued and respected.
• Making a Difference: Find purpose in your career by aligning with an organization that shares your values and is committed to making a difference in the communities we serve.

The Opportunity: Personal Lines Property & Casualty Underwriting Supervisor

As a Personal Lines Property & Casualty Underwriting Supervisor, you’ll play a key role in leading your underwriting team by:

• Overseeing underwriting quality and ensuring alignment with Portage Mutual’s risk appetite and service standards.
• Providing guidance and expertise on complex cases to support sound decision-making.
• Fostering team development through coaching, mentoring, and knowledge sharing.
• Building and strengthening relationships with brokers to drive profitable growth.
• Collaborating with cross-functional teams to support continuous improvement initiatives and uphold a culture of excellence in underwriting practices.

We’re looking for a strategic, collaborative leader who demonstrates strong underwriting expertise, champions team growth, and is committed to delivering outstanding service to our broker partners.

What You’ll Do

• Oversee and ensure the accurate and consistent application of underwriting policies, procedures, and service standards across the team, adhering to all applicable laws and regulations.
• Provide technical expertise and guidance to underwriters on complex or unique risks, ensuring sound underwriting decisions.
• Conduct post-loss underwriting reviews to identify trends, areas for improvement, and opportunities to enhance risk management practices.
• Maintain a thorough understanding of market trends and competitive landscape to inform underwriting strategies.
• Participate in the development and implementation of underwriting guidelines and best practices.
• Develop and maintain strong relationships with key brokers.
• Communicate underwriting business rules, guidelines, and risk appetite effectively to brokers.
• Collaborate with brokers to develop and maintain a profitable book of business, identifying opportunities for growth and retention.
• Address and resolve broker concerns or issues promptly and professionally.
• Conduct regular check-ins and performance reviews and provide constructive feedback to support individual and team performance.
• Promote a collaborative and supportive team environment, encouraging knowledge sharing and problem-solving.
• Champion employee development by creating and implementing individual development plans and provide ongoing coaching, mentorship, and access to training opportunities to enhance team capabilities and promote career advancement.
• Lead the recruitment and onboarding process for new team members ensuring a comprehensive onboarding experience that equips new hires with the knowledge, skills and resources needed to succeed in their roles.
• Contribute to the development and implementation of strategic initiatives to improve underwriting processes and outcomes.
• Provide input and recommendations on market trends, competitive landscape, and emerging risks.

What You’ll Bring

• Minimum of 7 years’ experience in personal lines underwriting or related field, with demonstrated leadership or supervisory experience.
• In-depth knowledge of underwriting principles, practices and regulations, risk analysis, pricing strategies, and product development across key segments such as personal and casualty insurance.
• Proven ability to lead, coach and mentor a team, fostering a positive and productive work environment.
• Deep familiarity with underwriting philosophies, statutory constraints, technical manuals, and rating programs.
• Excellent written and verbal communication skills with the ability to effectively communicate with underwriters, brokers and internal stakeholders.
• Strong analytical and problem-solving capabilities, with the ability to identify and address complex underwriting issues.
• Proven ability to establish and maintain professional, long-term relationships with brokers and internal partners.
• Ability to think strategically and contribute to the development of underwriting strategies and initiatives.
• Ability to adapt to changing market conditions and company priorities.
• Proficient in Microsoft Office Suite and relevant underwriting systems (e.g., Guidewire), with the ability to adapt to new technologies.
• Skilled at working with internal teams and brokers to deliver excellent service and optimal underwriting outcomes.
• Ability to work independently while effectively collaborating within a team environment.
• Open to change, with a focus on continuous improvement and personal development.
• Bachelor’s degree in finance, business, or a related field or an equivalent combination of education and experience
• CIP, CRM or FCIP designation or actively working towards.

Job Title: Personal Lines Property & Casualty Underwriting Supervisor

Reports To: Personal Lines Property & Casualty Underwriting Manager

Location: Hybrid - Edmonton

Salary Range: $76,600 - $95,000

This hybrid position is based in Edmonton, Alberta in-office 2–3 days per week.

Our pay ranges reflect the minimum and maximum target for new hire pay for the full-time position determined by role and level. The pay range shown is based on our compensation structure in place at the time of posting and may be updated periodically based on business needs. Individual pay is based on additional factors including job-related skills, experience, and relevant education and/or training.

Portage Mutual uses artificial intelligence and automations in its recruitment practices for activities that may include searching for qualified candidates, screening applications, preparing interview questions, recording interviews, drafting transcripts and other administrative tasks. AI is never used for decision making purposes.

Ready to Make an Impact?

We value diversity in backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives because the communities we serve are diverse. Rooted in a long-standing commitment to trust, community, and mutual support, Portage Mutual Insurance is proud to foster an inclusive workplace where employees are encouraged to collaborate, learn from one another, and grow together. We are looking for individuals who bring both professional expertise and a genuine commitment to supporting their teammates as we continue to protect what matters most for Canadians.

If you're looking for an opportunity to grow your career with a company that values people, community, and collaboration, we'd love to hear from you!

Portage Mutual Insurance is committed to creating an inclusive and accessible workplace. Accommodations are available throughout the recruitment process upon request. If you require accommodation, we will work with you to ensure a fair and positive candidate experience.

To be considered for this opportunity, candidates must have the legal right to work in Canada. Any employment offer will be conditional upon the successful completion of applicable pre-employment screening requirements.

We thank you for your interest in Portage Mutual Insurance, however, only those selected for an interview will be contacted. (No agencies please).