Subrogation Supervisor — Hybrid, Lead Recovery Team

Intact Insurance U.S.; Plymouth (MN); Hybrid; USD 86,000 - 121,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Bonus potential

Medical insurance

Dental insurance

Vision insurance

401(k) plan

Paid time off

Job summary

Intact Insurance U.S. is seeking a Subrogation Supervisor to lead the Specialty Recovery Claims team across multiple U.S. offices in a hybrid work model.

You will supervise subrogation staff, oversee claim strategies, and ensure quality outcomes while aligning with regulatory requirements. This role emphasizes leadership, collaboration with vendors, and effective training of direct reports. The ideal candidate will have 5–7 years in subrogation with 1–3 years of supervisory experience, plus

Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree or equivalent experience required.
• Minimum 5-7 years of subrogation experience, with 1-3 years of supervisory experience.
• Strong leadership, communication and analytical skills.

Responsibilities

• Supervises day-to-day activities and priorities of subrogation staff and assigns work.
• Monitors subrogation recoveries and analyzes trends to adjust strategies.
• Reviews recommendations for subrogated claims including negotiation and settlement.
• Manages vendor relationships and external partners to ensure service quality.
• Identifies training needs and develops programs to improve team performance.

Skills

Subrogation

Leadership

Team supervision

Strategic thinking

Vendor management

Education

Bachelor’s degree or equivalent experience

Tools

Claims systems

Legal knowledge

Job description

Intact Insurance U.S. is seeking a Subrogation Supervisor to lead the Specialty Recovery Claims team across multiple U.S. offices in a hybrid work model.

You will supervise subrogation staff, oversee claim strategies, and ensure quality outcomes while aligning with regulatory requirements. This role emphasizes leadership, collaboration with vendors, and effective training of direct reports. The ideal candidate will have 5–7 years in subrogation with 1–3 years of supervisory experience, plus