Remote Recruiter (Insurance Agent Focus)

TRAINWELL

Tiffin (IA)

Remote

USD 75,000 - 90,000

Full time

4 days ago
Be an early applicant

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Base Salary
Health Insurance
401k with match & Roth 401k
PTO
Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
Commission per successful placement
Performance Bonuses

Job summary

trainwell is seeking a results-driven Recruiter to join our newly launched division, partnering with insurance agency clients across the country. You will own the full-cycle recruiting process for multiple roles, from sales producers to account managers, coordinating with agency owners to align on timelines and standards.

You’ll leverage data to track KPIs, optimize workflows, and help scale a fast-growing recruitment practice.

Qualifications

  • 2+ years of full-cycle recruiting experience, ideally in an agency setting or high-volume environment.
  • Experience recruiting for sales or insurance roles is a strong plus.

Responsibilities

  • Manage full-cycle recruitment: own end-to-end process for Insurance Sales Producers, Account Managers, and hybrid customer service roles.
  • Serve as the primary recruiting partner for agency owners, guiding them through hiring
  • Screen candidates for culture fit and role fit, coordinate interviews with agency owners.

Job description

About trainwell

trainwell is a national training company dedicated to empowering high-performing insurance agencies. We help agency owners scale their revenue through advanced sales systems, accountability structures, and performance training. As we’ve grown, our clients have consistently asked for one critical resource: help with hiring. We’ve launched a dedicated recruiting division to meet this need, and we are looking for a driven Recruiter to join our team.

The Opportunity

This is not an internal HR role. You will not be recruiting for trainwell. Instead, you will act as a strategic recruiting partner for a portfolio of insurance agency clients across the country. You are joining after our Founding Recruiting Lead has established the initial framework. Your mission is to execute and scale that foundation—managing a high volume of open roles, delivering top-tier talent to agency owners, and helping refine the processes that will define our division’s success.

What You’ll Do
  • Manage Full-Cycle Recruitment: Own the end-to-end recruiting process for a variety of roles, including Insurance Sales Producers, Account Managers, and hybrid customer service positions. You will not rely solely on job postings/inbound applications.
  • Client Partnership: Serve as the primary recruiting contact for agency owners. You will manage expectations, provide market insights, and guide them through the hiring process.
  • Candidate Evaluation: Screen candidates for cultural fit, sales aptitude, and technical insurance knowledge. Coordinate and help administer structured group interviews with agency owners.

Process Optimization: Work within and help improve our recruiting systems, documentation, and workflows. Track recruiting KPIs and placement metrics to ensure efficiency and quality.

Requirements

Who You Are

  • Experienced: You have 2+ years of full-cycle recruiting experience, ideally in an agency setting or a high-volume corporate environment. Experience recruiting for sales or insurance roles is a strong plus.
  • Process-Driven: You are organized and metrics-minded. You understand the recruiting funnel and how to move candidates efficiently without sacrificing quality.
  • Client-Facing: You are comfortable communicating with business owners and holding them accountable to timelines and hiring standards. You can push back professionally when necessary.
  • Autonomous: You thrive with minimal oversight. You are a self-starter who can manage multiple open roles across different time zones without needing daily direction.

A Builder: While the foundation is in place, you are excited by the prospect of helping to refine and scale a new division. You are always looking for ways to make the process better.

Benefits
  • Base Salary ($75,000-$90,000 depending on experience)
  • Commission per successful placement
  • Performance Bonuses
  • Health Insurance
  • 401k with match & Roth 401k
  • PTO, Life Insurance, Disability Insurance
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Founding Recruiting Lead - Insurance Agencies
Founding Recruiting Lead - Insurance Agencies

trainwell • Iowa City (IA)

Remote
USD 80,000 - 120,000
Health Insurance
401k with match
Roth 401k
+3
Talent Sourcer (Licensed Insurance Agent Focus)
Talent Sourcer (Licensed Insurance Agent Focus)

trainwell • Tiffin (IA)

On-site
USD 55,000 - 75,000
Base Salary
Commission per successful placement
Performance Bonuses
+5
Remote Insurance Recruitment Partner for Agencies
Remote Insurance Recruitment Partner for Agencies

TRAINWELL • Tiffin (IA)

Remote
USD 75,000 - 90,000
Base Salary
Health Insurance
401k with match & Roth 401k
+5
Life Insurance Recruiter / Talent Acquisition Specialist
Life Insurance Recruiter / Talent Acquisition Specialist

Your Family Haven & Co • United States

Remote
USD 25,000 - 30,000
Remote work
Bonuses
Recruiter
Recruiter

Real Gen Wealth • Carrollton (TX)

Hybrid
USD 50,000 - 100,000
Training and mentorship from industry leaders
Opportunities for advancement
Mentorship and training
Military Insurance Recruiter
Military Insurance Recruiter

VLD Group • Arizona

Remote
USD 50,000 - 100,000
Comprehensive training
Licensing education provided
Flexible schedule
+2
Remote Founding Recruiting Lead for Insurance Agencies
Remote Founding Recruiting Lead for Insurance Agencies

trainwell • Iowa City (IA)

Remote
USD 80,000 - 120,000
Health Insurance
401k with match
Roth 401k
+3
Senior Insurance Recruiter
Senior Insurance Recruiter

Jobgether • United States

Remote
USD 200,000 - 350,000
Remote work
Uncapped commission
Health insurance
+2
Lead Recruiter
Lead Recruiter

AT Talent - Rec2Rec • United States

On-site
USD 100,000 - 125,000
Commission up to 40% on billings
Structured career progression
Continuous professional development
Director of Recruitment and Selection
Director of Recruitment and Selection

Northwestern Mutual Group • Fairview Heights (IL)

On-site
USD 75,000 - 85,000
Medical insurance
Disability insurance
401k
+2