Personal Injury Case Manager (Pre-Litigation)

Flanagan Law - Colorado

Commerce City (CO)

On-site

USD 63,000 - 77,000

Full time

4 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Health insurance
401k
Paid time off

Job summary

Flanagan Law in Commerce City, CO is seeking a Personal Injury Case Manager (Pre-Litigation) to own the day-to-day momentum of car-accident cases from initial representation through settlement disbursement. You will care for clients, coordinate with medical providers, draft demands, and ensure continuous progress toward favorable results.

Ideal candidates bring hands-on pre-litigation PI experience, skill in drafting demand letters, and strong organization.

Qualifications

  • Hands-on pre-litigation personal injury experience, ideally car accident cases.
  • Experience drafting demand letters and working with BI, UIM, and health insurance carriers.
  • Working knowledge of medical records, bills, and liens.
  • Excellent organization and follow-through; nothing slips through.
  • Warm, clear written and verbal communication with clients and providers.
  • Comfort with case management software (Clio a plus) and standard office tools.

Responsibilities

  • Open, review, and save incoming mail and faxes to the correct files.
  • Open new case files, obtain necessary documents from clients, and help coordinate medical treatment.
  • Send Letters of Representation BI, UIM, and health insurance carriers.
  • Follow up on acknowledgments and requested info until they’re in hand.
  • Respond to miscellaneous client service requests with warmth and plain language.
  • Answer daily case status app messages so clients always know where they stand.
  • Assist in scheduling and coordinating client appointments with our medical provider network.
  • Manage and track medical expenses throughout treatment.
  • Instruct our Medical Records Coordinator on which records and bills to order.
  • Follow up to make sure everything is completed on time.
  • Check in on balances owed to inform case strategy.
  • Redact medical records and bills as needed.
  • Draft demand letters that make insurance adjusters take notice.
  • Send demands and follow up on carrier responses.
  • Finalize settlement disbursements and send out checks.
  • Drive the team’s weekly KPIs: 2 demands and 2 settlements per week.

Skills

PI experience
Demand letters
Client communication
Case management software

Tools

Clio

Job description

Location: Commerce City, CO in-office Position Type: Full-Time

Compensation: $70,000 + performance bonus tied to KPIs

Your Good Luck Starts Here

Personal Injury Case Manager (Pre-Litigation) — Flanagan Law

Location: Commerce City, CO in-office Position Type: Full-Time

Compensation: $70,000 + performance bonus tied to KPIs

Your Good Luck Starts Here

At Flanagan Law, we like to say we’re our clients’ good luck charm. When a car accident turns someone’s life upside down, they don’t need a case number. They need a team that picks up the phone, takes the chaos off their plate, and puts their health first.

Now we’re looking to add another four-leaf clover of our legal team: a seasoned case manager who creates a great outcome by keeping the whole case moving.

We’re a Commerce City, Colorado-based boutique firm. Luck favors the prepared, and we’ve secured millions for our clients by being exactly that.

The Role

The Case Manager owns the day-to-day momentum of our pre-litigation car accident cases, from the first letter of representation through settlement disbursement. You’ll care for our clients, coordinate with medical providers, build and send demands, and make sure every case keeps moving toward a great result. If you thrive on settling cases efficiently, you’re exactly who we’re looking for.

What You’ll Do
Case Setup & Correspondence
  • Open, review, and save incoming mail and faxes to the correct files
  • Open new case files, obtain necessary documents from clients, and help coordinate medical treatment
  • Send Letters of Representation BI, UIM, and health insurance carriers
  • Follow up on acknowledgments and requested info until they’re in hand
Client Treatment Management
  • Respond to miscellaneous client service requests with warmth and plain language
  • Answer daily case status app messages so clients always know where they stand
Provider Management
  • Assist in scheduling and coordinating client appointments with our medical provider network
  • Manage and track medical expenses throughout treatment
Medical Records & Bills
  • Instruct our Medical Records Coordinator on which records and bills to order
  • Follow up to make sure everything is completed on time
  • Check in on balances owed to inform case strategy
  • Redact medical records and bills as needed
Demands & Settlements
  • Draft demand letters that make insurance adjusters take notice
  • Send demands and follow up on carrier responses
  • Finalize settlement disbursements and send out checks
Hitting the Numbers
  • Drive the team’s weekly KPIs: 2 demands and 2 settlements per week
What You Bring
Required
  • Hands‑on pre-litigation personal injury experience, ideally car accident cases
  • Experience drafting demand letters and working with BI, UIM, and health insurance carriers
  • Working knowledge of medical records, bills, and liens
  • Excellent organization and follow-through. Nothing slips through
  • Warm, clear written and verbal communication with clients and providers
  • Comfort with case management software (Clio a plus) and standard office tools
Preferred
  • Experience managing a caseload with minimal supervision
  • Business development experience (lead generation and intake)
Who You Are
  • Proactive. You see the next step before it’s asked for.
  • Empathetic. You can calm an overwhelmed client in the morning and press an adjuster in the afternoon.
  • Numbers-driven. Weekly KPIs motivate you rather than stress you out.
  • Dependable. Colleagues and clients count on you, and you deliver.
  • Aligned with our mission.
What You’ll Love Here
  • Boutique firm energy. You’re a person here, not a headcount.
  • Meaningful work. Every case you move helps a real person recover.
  • A team that has fun while doing it. We work hard and we hold ourselves to a high standard, but we don't take ourselves too seriously. Expect real laughs, celebrated wins, and people who have each other's backs.
  • A team that gives back. We donate a portion of every settlement to charity.
  • Room to grow as the firm grows.
Compensation & Benefits
  • Pay: $70,000
  • KPI bonus: varies quarterly
  • PTO: 3 weeks after 90‑day probation
  • Health & other benefits: Employee coverage after 90‑day probation; family options available
  • 401k: Eligible after 1 year

Could be luck. Could be fate. Either way, we’re glad you found us.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Lead Personal Injury Attorney
Lead Personal Injury Attorney

Ctlanet • Commerce City (CO)

On-site
USD 135,000 - 165,000
Health & Vision
401k
PTO after probation
Personal Injury Medical Records & Bills Specialist
Personal Injury Medical Records & Bills Specialist

Flanagan Law - Colorado • Commerce City (CO)

Hybrid
USD 26,000 - 37,000
Hybrid flexibility
In-office Mondays in Commerce City
Meaningful work
Pre-Litigation Personal Injury Case Manager — Boutique Firm
Pre-Litigation Personal Injury Case Manager — Boutique Firm

Flanagan Law - Colorado • Commerce City (CO)

On-site
USD 63,000 - 77,000
Health insurance
401k
Paid time off
Personal Injury Case Manager
Personal Injury Case Manager

Legal Management Group • Culver City (CA)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Competitive compensation
Bonus opportunities
Medical, dental, and vision benefits
+4
Personal Injury Associate Attorney
Personal Injury Associate Attorney

Orion Placement • Denver (CO)

On-site
USD 110,000 - 160,000
Health insurance
Paid time off
Retirement plan
+1
Personal Injury Pre-Suit Case Manager
Personal Injury Pre-Suit Case Manager

Ligori & Ligori PA • Tampa (FL)

On-site
USD 45,000 - 65,000
Health insurance
Dental and Vision insurance paid in00
Life insurance
+3
Paralegal
Paralegal

Tillmann Law LLC • Portland (OR)

On-site
USD 55,000 - 75,000
100% employer-paid medical, dental, and vision
Retirement: 401k
2 weeks accrued PTO
+2
Pre Litigation Paralegal
Pre Litigation Paralegal

Grove Gallery & Interiors • Tampa (FL)

On-site
USD 40,000 - 60,000
Group health insurance
401(k) with match
Performance bonuses
+2
Pre-Litigation Case Manager Team Lead, New York
Pre-Litigation Case Manager Team Lead, New York

Topdog Law, Llc • New York (NY)

Remote
USD 92,000 - 131,000
Case Manager
Case Manager

Jeffrey S. Glassman • Boston (MA)

Remote
USD 27,552 - 45,460
401(k) (no match)
Health insurance
Public transportation reimbursement
+2