Litigation Attorney

EverStaff; Dayton (OH); On-site; USD 80,000 - 120,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

401(k) with company match

Positive, team-oriented culture with a

Job summary

EverStaff, LLC in Dayton, OH is seeking a Litigation Attorney to join its high-performing personal injury team. The attorney will manage a robust caseload, negotiate settlements, mentor staff, and serve as a primary contact for clients and opposing counsel.

Requirements include active Ohio Bar status and 2–5 years PI experience, with proficiency in Microsoft Office and familiarity with Needles. This in-office role offers growth in a recognized Ohio PI firm.

Qualifications

• Licensed attorney in good standing with the Ohio State Bar.
• 2–5 years of experience handling personal injury matters (plaintiff or defense).
• Strong communication skills and a persuasive negotiation style.
• Familiarity with litigation software - Needles is a plus.
• Prior insurance defense or claims handling experience is highly valued.

Responsibilities

• Negotiate favorable settlements for clients, including lien resolution.
• Supervise and mentor legal support staff for efficient case handling.
• Serve as primary contact for clients, adjusters, opposing counsel, and court personnel.
• Build damages narratives through detailed investigation and documentation.
• Collaborate with colleagues across offices to meet firm-wide litigation goals.

Skills

Negotiation

Client communication

Legal research

Needles

Microsoft Office

Tools

Needles (litigation software)

Microsoft Office

Job description

Litigation Attorney - Personal Injury (Dayton, OH)

A high-performing, statewide personal injury law firm is seeking a driven Attorney to join its growing litigation team in Dayton. We’re looking for someone who thrives in a results-oriented environment and has the confidence to manage a robust caseload while delivering exceptional client service.

What You’ll Do:

• Negotiate favorable settlements for clients, including addressing liens and finalizing resolution terms
• Supervise and mentor legal support staff to ensure efficiency and consistency in case handling
• Serve as a key point of contact for clients, adjusters, opposing counsel, and court personnel
• Build compelling damages narratives through detailed investigation and documentation
• Work collaboratively with colleagues across offices to achieve firm-wide litigation goals

What We’re Looking For:

• Licensed and in good standing with the Ohio State Bar
• 2-5 years of experience handling personal injury matters (plaintiff or defense)
• Strong communication skills and a persuasive negotiation style
• Familiarity with litigation software - experience with Needles is a plus
• Prior insurance defense or claims handling experience is highly valued
• Must be proficient with Microsoft Office and comfortable with digital workflows
• Ability to manage pressure and prioritize tasks in a fast-paced setting

Why Join Us:

• Competitive base salary with potential for bonuses tied to performance
• 401(k) with company match
• Positive, team-oriented culture with strong administrative support
• Opportunity to grow within one of the most recognized personal injury firms in Ohio
• Location: Dayton, OH (in-office role)

All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, ethnicity, national origin, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, disability status, protected veteran status or any other protected status under the law. EverStaff is an equal opportunity employer (M/F/D/V/SO/GI).