Licensed Insurance Customer Service Representative (P&C)

Hittle Insurance Personal & Business Solutions

Carmel (IN)

On-site

USD 25,000 - 39,000

Full time

2 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

PTO
Health Insurance
Dental Insurance
Vision Insurance
Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
Hands-on Training
Mon-Fri Schedule
Career Growth Opportunities
Retirement Plan

Job summary

Hittle Insurance in Carmel, Indiana is seeking an experienced Property & Casualty Customer Service Representative to support daily client service operations and assist licensed agents. The ideal candidate has 3+ years in insurance, works well with multiple carriers, and handles in-person, phone, and email inquiries with professionalism.

This role emphasizes routine service requests, policy changes, billing questions, accurate record‑keeping, and collaboration within a small team at an on-site

Qualifications

  • Active Property & Casualty license in Indiana.
  • 3+ years in insurance customer service, preferably with an independent agency.
  • Experience with multiple carriers and their online service platforms.

Responsibilities

  • Handle inbound and outbound calls.
  • Respond to client emails and texts promptly.
  • Welcome walk‑in clients with policy questions, payments, and general needs.
  • Assist existing clients with billing inquiries and routine policy service requests.
  • Process routine policy changes such as vehicle, driver, address, and mortgagee updates.
  • Assist with quotes, requotes, cancellations, reinstatements, and renewal requests as directed.
  • Prepare and send insurance ID cards, declarations pages, and other policy documents.
  • Contact carriers to verify policy information and billing status.
  • Follow up on missing information, signatures, payments, and underwriting requests.
  • Maintain accurate client records and activity notes in the system.
  • Support daily office operations and tasks for agents and account managers.
  • Handle mail, scanning, and filing.

Skills

Communication
Organization
Detail-oriented
Multitasking
Phone etiquette

Tools

Carrier platforms

Job description

Job Description

Hittle Insurance, an independent insurance agency located in Carmel, Indiana, is seeking an experienced, licensed Property & Casualty Customer Service Representative (CSR) to assist with daily customer service operations.

The ideal candidate has at least 3 years of experience in the insurance industry, preferably with an independent agency familiar with multiple carriers. We are looking for someone who is organized, dependable, detail-oriented, and comfortable assisting clients in person, over the phone, and via email.

This position focuses on handling routine insurance service requests, processing policy changes, assisting with billing questions, maintaining accurate records, and supporting our licensed agents and account managers.


Benefits

  • Paid Time Off (PTO)
  • Health Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Vision Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Disability Insurance
  • Hands on Training
  • Mon-Fri Schedule
  • Career Growth Opportunities
  • Retirement Plan

Responsibilities

  • Inbound/Outbound calls handling
  • Respond to client emails and texts professionally and promptly.
  • Welcome and assist walk-in clients with policy questions, payments, documentation, and general insurance needs.
  • Assist existing clients with billing inquiries, late payments, and routine policy service requests.
  • Process routine policy changes, including vehicle replacements, driver changes, address updates, and mortgagee changes.
  • Assist with quotes, requotes, cancellations, reinstatements, and renewal-related requests as directed.
  • Prepare and send insurance ID cards, declaration pages, evidence of insurance, and other policy documents.
  • Contact insurance carriers via phone or portal to verify policy information, billing status, and pending service requests.
  • Follow up with clients regarding missing information, outstanding documents, signature, payments, and underwriting/carrier requests.
  • Maintain accurate client records and activity notes in the management system.
  • Assist with daily office operations, agents and account managers with assigned tasks as needed.
  • Mail management, scanning and filing.

Requirements

  • Active Property & Casualty insurance license.
  • Minimum 3 years of insurance customer service experience, preferably in an independent insurance agency.
  • Familiarity with multiple insurance carriers and their online service platforms.
  • Excellent communication skills and professional phone etiquette.
  • Strong organizational skills, attention to detail, and ability to multitask.
  • Comfortable assisting clients in person and handling a high volume of incoming calls.
  • Dependable, punctual, and able to work effectively in a team environment.
  • Must be available to work on-site at our Carmel, Indiana office, Monday through Friday, from 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM.
  • Bilingual is preferred but not required.
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Licensed Insurance CSR — Client Care & Policy Service
Licensed Insurance CSR — Client Care & Policy Service

Hittle Insurance Personal & Business Solutions • Carmel (IN)

On-site
USD 25,000 - 39,000
PTO
Health Insurance
Dental Insurance
+7
Customer Service Representative Auto and Home Insurance
Customer Service Representative Auto and Home Insurance

Scott Goodman Insurance • Nevada

On-site
USD 25,000 - 36,000
Competitive Pay
Professional Development
Job Stability
Customer Service Representative- Insurance office
Customer Service Representative- Insurance office

CHARLES E OSBURN II • Tomball (TX)

On-site
USD 35,000 - 50,000
Paid time off
401(k) matching
Bonus based on performance
+1
Insurance Customer Service Rep
Insurance Customer Service Rep

Pachis Agency LLC • Evanston (IL)

On-site
USD 28,000 - 36,000
PTO
Flexible Schedule
Health Insurance
+9
Insurance - Licensed Customer Service Representative
Insurance - Licensed Customer Service Representative

Blaeser Insurance Agency • Bristol (RI)

On-site
USD 42,000 - 52,000
Paid Time Off (PTO)
Career Growth Opportunities
Mon-Fri Schedule
+2
Licensed Insurance Customer Service Representative (P&C)
Licensed Insurance Customer Service Representative (P&C)

Pavago • United States

Remote
USD 52,000 - 68,000
Account Manager
Account Manager

Mason Insurance Agency, Inc • Michigan

On-site
USD 50,000 - 75,000
401(k)
401(k) matching
Dental insurance
+2
Licensed Insurance Customer Service Representative
Licensed Insurance Customer Service Representative

American Family Insurance - Vargas-Soto Agency • Las Vegas (NV)

On-site
USD 25,000 - 39,000
Flexible Schedule
Career Growth Opportunities
Hands on Training
Insurance Customer Service
Insurance Customer Service

Associated Insurance Agencies, Inc. • Westerville (OH)

On-site
USD 34,000 - 52,000
Paid time off
Competitive salary
Dental insurance
+8
Insurance Customer Service RepresentativeSales
Insurance Customer Service RepresentativeSales

Augustyniak Insurance Group • Jacksonville (FL)

On-site
USD 25,000 - 28,000
Performance bonuses
Training provided