Insurance Service Representative

Allstate Insurance Agency - Jason McMahan

Virginia Beach (VA)

On-site

USD 45,760 - 70,000

Full time

14 days+

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Bonus based on performance
Health insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
Paid time off
Tuition assistance

Job summary

Allstate Insurance Agency - Jason McMahan in Virginia Beach is looking for a customer-focused individual to manage service requests, assist with policy inquiries, and ensure client satisfaction. The role emphasizes strong communication and organizational skills, with a base salary of $22/hr plus commission opportunities. Expected total earnings range from $55,000 to $70,000 annually. The position provides competitive benefits and opportunities for advancement.

Qualifications

  • Prior experience in customer service, insurance, or any relationship-based role is a plus.
  • You're warm, patient, and easy to trust.
  • You stay calm when customers are frustrated.

Responsibilities

  • Be the voice customers hear when they call for payments or policy changes.
  • Review customers' coverage at renewal.
  • Spot opportunities to enhance customer coverage.

Skills

Natural communication
Organization
Customer service
Reliability

Job description

Benefits

Bonus based on performance

Competitive salary

Dental insurance

Free food & snacks

Health insurance

Opportunity for advancement

Paid time off

Training & development

Tuition assistance

Vision insurance

About this role

The McMahan Group is a 47-year Allstate agency in Virginia Beach. We take care of thousands of households across Hampton Roads — and we’re looking for someone who takes that seriously.

This role is built for someone who is genuinely good with people. You’ll be a real point of contact for our customers — helping them understand their coverage, handling service needs, reviewing their policies at renewal, and being there when they have a problem. The customers who feel taken care of stay. That’s the job.

There’s also commission upside here. When you identify an opportunity to better protect a customer and they take it, you earn for that. We’re looking for someone relational who earns naturally through doing the service job well.

What you’ll do
  • Be the voice customers hear when they call — for payments, policy changes, coverage questions, and everything in between
  • Review customers’ coverage at renewal and make sure they’re properly protected
  • Spot natural opportunities to round out a customer’s coverage and have that conversation
  • Retain customers who are thinking about leaving — listen to what’s going on and find a solution
  • Keep accurate notes and follow‑ups in our agency management system so nothing falls through the cracks
  • Work alongside our outside sales team to support a smooth customer experience from quote to service
Who we’re looking for
  • You’re a natural communicator — warm, patient, and easy to trust
  • You’re organized and reliable — you follow through, log your work, and don’t let things slip
  • You stay calm when customers are frustrated and don’t take it personally
  • You’re comfortable working in a small office where everyone knows what you’re doing
  • Prior experience in customer service, insurance, or any relationship‑based role is a plus
Pay & Benefits

Base salary is $22/hr. ($45,760/year). On top of that, you earn commission when customers you serve add coverage, a monthly bonus tied to how well the agency retains its book, and a save bonus when a customer calls to cancel and you keep them. Solid performers in this role typically earn $55,000–$70,000 all in.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Sales Representative
Sales Representative

Allstate Insurance Agency - Jason McMahan • Virginia Beach (VA)

Hybrid
USD 40,000 - 60,000
Bonus based on performance
Paid time off
Training & development
+7
Insurance Customer Service Rep
Insurance Customer Service Rep

Insurance Protection Solutions, INC. • Williamsburg (VA)

On-site
USD 40,500 - 49,500
Paid time off
Health insurance
Dental insurance
+4
Insurance Customer Service Rep
Insurance Customer Service Rep

Insurance Protection Solutions, INC. • Richlands (VA)

On-site
USD 32,000 - 39,000
PTO
Flexible Schedule
Health Insurance
+23
Customer Service Representative
Customer Service Representative

Tyler Johnson Insurance - Allstate • Walnut Creek (CA)

On-site
USD 42,000 - 56,000
Simple IRA
Licensing paid by agency
Bonus based on performance
+7
Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent

The Atlantic District • Winchester (VA)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Annual base salary + commission
Bonus opportunities
Work from home
+11
Multi-line Insurance Agent
Multi-line Insurance Agent

The Atlantic District • Norfolk (VA)

On-site
USD 55,000 - 80,000
Annual base salary + commission +Bonus
Paid Time Off (PTO)
Work from Home
+11
Insurance Service Team Member
Insurance Service Team Member

Southeast Managing Partners • Monroe (MI)

On-site
USD 36,000 - 54,000
401(k)
Signing bonus
Training
+5
Insurance Sales Representative (copy)
Insurance Sales Representative (copy)

Secured assets • Williamsburg (VA)

On-site
USD 65,000 - 85,000
PTO
Health Insurance
Hands-on Training
+3
Insurance Services Pro - Commission & Growth Opportunities
Insurance Services Pro - Commission & Growth Opportunities

Allstate Insurance Agency - Jason McMahan • Virginia Beach (VA)

On-site
USD 45,760 - 70,000
Bonus based on performance
Health insurance
Dental insurance
+3
Insurance Customer Service Rep
Insurance Customer Service Rep

John Alderson Agency, Inc. • Daleville (VA)

On-site
USD 45,000 - 60,000
Paid Time Off (PTO)
Health Insurance
Life Insurance
+11