HR Recruiting Manager

Fortuity; Columbus (OH); On-site; USD 70,000 - 86,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Annual bonus 10–20%

Job summary

Fortuity, a Columbus-based contact center and BPO, seeks an HR Recruiting Manager to lead talent acquisition, build scalable processes, and partner with operations. You will manage the recruiting team, develop sourcing strategies, and drive high-volume hiring campaigns to support client launches.

The role measures success by quality hires, time-to-fill, and show rates, with a salary of $70,000–$86,000 annually plus a 10%–20% annual bonus. This is a full-time Columbus, Ohio position.

Qualifications

• 5+ years of recruiting or talent acquisition experience.
• 2+ years leading recruiters or a talent acquisition function.
• Experience managing high-volume recruiting.
• Experience developing sourcing strategies and candidate pipelines.
• Strong understanding of recruiting funnels, metrics, and hiring analytics.
• Experience with applicant tracking systems and recruiting technology.
• Strong leadership, communication, organization, and problem-solving skills.
• Ability to manage multiple hiring priorities and deadlines simultaneously.
• Comfortable working in an environment where staffing needs and priorities can change quickly.

Responsibilities

• Own recruiting strategy and execution for Fortuity’s hourly and salaried positions.
• Develop hiring plans to meet aggressive staffing targets and client launch dates.
• Build and maintain candidate pipelines before hiring needs become urgent.
• Monitor recruiting funnels from application through offer, onboarding, and start date.
• Identify bottlenecks and make adjustments quickly when hiring results are falling behind.
• Recruit directly for key positions and high-priority hiring needs.
• Lead, coach, and develop Fortuity’s Talent Acquisition team.
• Establish clear expectations, workloads, goals, and recruiting priorities.
• Monitor recruiter performance and provide ongoing coaching and feedback.
• Create consistent recruiting practices, interview standards, and candidate communication.
• Ensure the team delivers a professional and responsive candidate experience.
• Develop sourcing strategies across job boards, social media, community partnerships, employee referrals, recruiting events, and other channels.
• Determine which recruiting sources produce the strongest candidates and best hiring outcomes.
• Build relationships with workforce organizations, community partners, schools, and other talent sources.
• Develop creative approaches to reaching candidates who may not be actively applying for jobs.
• Maintain pipelines for frequently hired positions.
• Coordinate external staffing and recruiting agencies when additional hiring capacity is needed.
• Establish clear submission processes and expectations for recruiting partners.
• Monitor agency performance, candidate quality, hiring results, and costs.
• Help ensure multiple recruiting partners can work effectively without creating duplicate candidate submissions or confusion.
• Own the Candidate Experience
• Ensure candidates receive timely, accurate communication throughout the hiring process.
• Oversee interviewing, candidate selection, offers, and pre-employment activities.
• Partner with HR Operations to create a smooth transition from candidate to new employee.
• Monitor offer acceptance, pre-employment completion, Day 1 attendance, and early attrition.
• Identify why candidates are dropping out of the process and develop solutions.
• Use Data to Drive Results
• Recruiting at Fortuity should be measurable. You'll establish and monitor metrics such as:
• Applicants and qualified candidates
• Interview and selection rates
• Time-to-fill and time-to-hire
• Offer acceptance rate
• Recruiting source effectiveness
• Cost-per-hire
• New-hire show rate
• Early employee retention
• Recruiting partner performance
• You’ll use this information to determine what's working, what isn't, and where we need to change our approach.

Skills

Recruiting experience

Leadership

High-volume recruiting

Sourcing strategies

Hiring analytics

ATS experience

Communication skills

Multitasking

Adaptability

Education

Bachelor's degree or equivalent

Tools

Paycor

ATS systems

Job description

At Fortuity, we don’t just offer jobs—we build careers. From day one, we focus on your personal growth, professional development, and long-term success.

Join a team that values your potential and helps you achieve your goals.

Open Positions:

Location: Columbus, OH

Job Id:223

# of Openings:1

Location:775 W. Broad St., Columbus, Ohio
Department: Human Resources
Employment Type: Full-Time
Salary Range: $70,000–$86,000 annually
Bonus Opportunity: 10%–20% annual performance bonus

About Fortuity

Fortuity is a Columbus-based contact center and business process outsourcing company that partners with organizations to build and manage high-performing customer service teams. Our staffing needs can move quickly—from steady-state hiring to launching large groups of employees on aggressive timelines.

We are looking for an HR Recruiting Manager who knows how to build recruiting processes that can keep up.

The Opportunity

The HR Recruiting Manager will lead Fortuity’s talent acquisition function and be accountable for delivering the people we need, when we need them.

This is a hands-on leadership role. You’ll manage the recruiting team, develop sourcing strategies, oversee high-volume hiring campaigns, improve recruiting processes, manage external recruiting partners, and personally jump into recruiting when needed.

Success in this position isn’t measured by activity. It’s measured by results: qualified candidates, filled classes, strong show rates, efficient hiring processes, and employees who are a good fit for Fortuity and our clients.

What You'll Do

• Own recruiting strategy and execution for Fortuity’s hourly and salaried positions.
• Develop hiring plans to meet aggressive staffing targets and client launch dates.
• Build and maintain candidate pipelines before hiring needs become urgent.
• Monitor recruiting funnels from application through offer, onboarding, and start date.
• Identify bottlenecks and make adjustments quickly when hiring results are falling behind.
• Recruit directly for key positions and high-priority hiring needs.

Manage & Develop the Recruiting Team

• Lead, coach, and develop Fortuity’s Talent Acquisition team.
• Establish clear expectations, workloads, goals, and recruiting priorities.
• Monitor recruiter performance and provide ongoing coaching and feedback.
• Create consistent recruiting practices, interview standards, and candidate communication.
• Ensure the team delivers a professional and responsive candidate experience.

Build Strong Sourcing Strategies

• Develop sourcing strategies across job boards, social media, community partnerships, employee referrals, recruiting events, and other channels.
• Determine which recruiting sources produce the strongest candidates and best hiring outcomes.
• Build relationships with workforce organizations, community partners, schools, and other talent sources.
• Develop creative approaches to reaching candidates who may not be actively applying for jobs.
• Maintain pipelines for frequently hired positions.
• Coordinate external staffing and recruiting agencies when additional hiring capacity is needed.
• Establish clear submission processes and expectations for recruiting partners.
• Monitor agency performance, candidate quality, hiring results, and costs.
• Help ensure multiple recruiting partners can work effectively without creating duplicate candidate submissions or confusion.

Own the Candidate Experience

• Ensure candidates receive timely, accurate communication throughout the hiring process.
• Oversee interviewing, candidate selection, offers, and pre-employment activities.
• Partner with HR Operations to create a smooth transition from candidate to new employee.
• Monitor offer acceptance, pre-employment completion, Day 1 attendance, and early attrition.
• Identify why candidates are dropping out of the process and develop solutions.

Use Data to Drive Results

Recruiting at Fortuity should be measurable. You'll establish and monitor metrics such as:

• Applicants and qualified candidates
• Interview and selection rates
• Time-to-fill and time-to-hire
• Offer acceptance rate
• Recruiting source effectiveness
• Cost-per-hire
• New-hire show rate
• Early employee retention
• Recruiting partner performance

You’ll use this information to determine what's working, what isn't, and where we need to change our approach.

Partner With the Business

• Work closely with HR and Operations leadership to forecast hiring needs.
• Translate client staffing requirements into actionable recruiting plans.
• Provide leadership with clear updates on hiring progress, risks, and projected staffing.
• Understand the skills and behaviors that make employees successful in Fortuity's contact center environment.
• Help hiring managers make effective, consistent, and timely selection decisions.

What We're Looking For

Required Qualifications

• 5+ years of recruiting or talent acquisition experience.
• 2+ years of experience leading recruiters or a talent acquisition function.
• Demonstrated experience managing high-volume recruiting.
• Experience developing sourcing strategies and candidate pipelines.
• Strong understanding of recruiting funnels, metrics, and hiring analytics.
• Experience with applicant tracking systems and recruiting technology.
• Strong leadership, communication, organization, and problem-solving skills.
• Ability to manage multiple hiring priorities and deadlines simultaneously.
• Comfortable working in an environment where staffing needs and priorities can change quickly.

Preferred Qualifications

• Recruiting experience within a contact center, BPO, staffing, customer service, hospitality, retail, healthcare, or other high-volume hourly environment.
• Experience managing large hiring classes or rapid workforce expansions.
• Experience working with external recruiting and staffing agencies.
• Experience with Paycor or similar HR/recruiting platforms.
• Experience recruiting for government contracts or positions with significant pre-employment screening requirements.
• Bachelor's degree in Human Resources, Business, or a related field, or equivalent professional experience.

Who Will Thrive in This Role

You'll likely be successful here if you're someone who:

• Loves recruiting but also loves building better recruiting systems.
• Can move between strategy and execution without hesitation.
• Doesn't wait until a hiring deadline is in trouble to raise a concern.
• Uses numbers to understand recruiting performance rather than relying solely on intuition.
• Holds yourself and your team accountable for results.
• Can create structure in a fast-moving environment.
• Builds strong relationships with candidates, recruiters, hiring managers, and community partners.
• Understands that filling a position isn't enough—the person also needs to show up and succeed.

Compensation

The salary range for this position is $70,000–$86,000 annually, depending on experience, qualifications, and demonstrated recruiting leadership capabilities.

The position is also eligible for a 10%–20% annual performance bonus, based on individual and company performance and achievement of established goals.

Why Fortuity?

This is an opportunity to have a meaningful impact on both our company and our community. You'll have the ability to shape how Fortuity attracts talent, builds candidate pipelines, develops recruiting partnerships, and scales our workforce as new client programs launch.

We're looking for someone who wants to own the recruiting function, not simply maintain it.

Fortuity is an Equal Opportunity Employer.

At Fortuity, we are vigilant in creating an environment where every individual feels valued, respected and empowered.

We acknowledge the unique perspectives and experiences that each team member brings to our contact center and encourage everyone to bring their full authentic selves to work every day

From supporting local charities and donation drives for schools, to hosting holiday events for our families, our Community Engagement efforts are dedicated to making a positive impact beyond our office walls

Investing in Untapped Local Talent

Recognizing the individuality of each person’s journey, we are committed to understanding, supporting, and championing the unique paths our team members tread

Benefit from an extensive spectrum of training opportunities, including continuous skills reinforcement and advanced leadership programs

By investing in the quality of our workforce employees, we are investing in the quality of our work, ensuring we consistently deliver excellence to our clients

Whether your advancement journey takes you to a higher position within Fortuity, or on a pathways program to a larger corporate partner’s company, we are here to support, celebrate and offer guidance

Hear from our Employees

“Fortuity isn’t just an office- it’s a community of people who go above and beyond to uphold our core values that we strive for. I have had many opportunities for advancement, which shows my dedication and focus mean something here- that is why I am happy to work at Fortuity.”

Tammy, TRAINING SUPERVISOR

“Fortuity walks the talk and actually cares about you personally. It feels like family! I have developed and grown so much… that's why I love working here! The inclusivity is felt through every aspect, especially in the way that employees are valued and cared for.”

“Fortuity is a start thats going to make my future so bright! I'm so glad to call this my work home. I truly cant express how lovely the job has been honestly.”

"Fortuity is the only place of business that I have witnessed that stands by its missions, and those missions are rooted in doing good for our employees."\

Mari, MANAGER

"Just want to say thank you to everyone for making this place feel like a second home. Every laugh, smile and minute here has been so enjoyable. Coming here to work has been so enjoyable because I feel like this is more of a family and the support from the leaders here is beyond amazing."\

"Being entrusted to help support the our agents has been one of the most rewarding parts of this journey. Watching them learn, develop new skills, gain confidence, and grow into their roles has been incredibly fulfilling, and I feel fortunate to have played even a small part in that process."\

We go the extra mile to connect our team with resources to alleviate their overall stress, enabling them to maximize their performance.