VP, Underwriting - Small Business & Digital

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company

United States

On-site

USD 180,000 - 280,000

Full time

14 days+

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Comprehensive benefits package (health
401(k) employer match
Paid time off and holidays
Tuition reimbursement

Job summary

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company seeks an experienced Vice President, Underwriting – Small Business and Digital to lead the strategy, performance, and growth of our Small Business and Digital businesses, including the Agent Portal and Digital brokerage channel.

This is a highly visible leadership role for an accomplished E&S casualty underwriting leader who combines strong technical underwriting expertise, commercial judgment, and an entrepreneurial approach to building and scaling a

Qualifications

  • Minimum of 10 years of commercial insurance underwriting experience with advanced knowledge of E&S casualty products.
  • Demonstrated track record of building and managing profitable underwriting portfolios and achieving growth, profitability, diversification, and objectives.
  • Strong relationships with wholesale brokers, binding agents, and other E&S distribution partners.
  • Experience building, growing, or scaling a business unit, underwriting platform, or portfolio preferred.
  • Strong analytical judgment and a data-driven approach to portfolio management and decision-making.
  • Executive presence and excellent communication, negotiation, collaboration, and relationship-management skills.
  • Willingness to travel approximately 25% to develop distribution relationships.
  • Competitive salary commensurate with experience and comprehensive benefits package.

Responsibilities

  • Own and execute the Small Business & Digital underwriting strategy and growth, including Agent Portal and Digital brokerage channel.
  • Set underwriting appetite, risk criteria, pricing expectations, terms, authorities, and industry/geography priorities.
  • Define annual operating objectives across premium, profitability, retention, rate, new business, and productivity.
  • Identify market segments and expand Agent Portal adoption and broker relationships.
  • Translate portfolio performance and market intelligence into actionable underwriting and growth plans.
  • Maintain alignment across growth, rate adequacy, diversification, and operational efficiency.

Skills

Underwriting
Leadership
Strategic thinking
Relationship management

Education

Bachelor’s degree
CPCU/AU/CIC designation

Job description

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company specializes in property, casualty, management liability and professional liability insurance, with a strong emphasis on the excess and surplus (E&S) lines market, partnering with brokers and wholesale agents throughout the U.S. to provide insurance solutions for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). Our aim is to establish ourselves as the premier E&S carrier, leveraging robust technical underwriting, intelligent operational efficiencies, sound risk management, dynamic claims team, and intensive specialization to excel in the marketplace.

About the Role

Ategrity is seeking an experienced Vice President, Underwriting – Small Business and Digital to lead the strategy, performance, and growth of our Small Business and Digital businesses, including business transacted through Ategrity’s Agent Portal and Digital brokerage channel. This is a highly visible leadership role for an accomplished E&S casualty underwriting leader who combines strong technical underwriting expertise, commercial judgment, operational discipline, and an entrepreneurial approach to building and scaling a differentiated Small Business franchise.

Own and Execute the Small Business & Digital Strategy
  • Own and execute Ategrity’s underwriting and growth strategy for Small Business and Digital, with the Agent Portal serving as a primary platform for delivering E&S solutions to targeted SME segments.
  • Establish clear underwriting appetite, risk selection criteria, pricing expectations, terms and conditions, underwriting authorities, industry priorities, and geographic strategies.
  • Set annual operating objectives across premium, profitability, retention, rate, new business, conversion, diversification, productivity, turnaround time, and service.
  • Identify attractive market segments and opportunities to expand Agent Portal adoption, deepen productive distribution relationships, and build differentiated Small Business capabilities.
  • Translate portfolio performance, market intelligence, competitor activity, loss trends, and emerging exposures into actionable underwriting and growth strategies.
  • Maintain disciplined alignment across growth, rate adequacy, diversification, operational efficiency, underwriting profitability, and ease of doing business.
Drive Underwriting and Portfolio Performance
  • Own overall portfolio performance for Small Business and Digital, including premium growth, profitability, rate, retention, new business, conversion, portfolio mix, and productivity.
  • Monitor submission flow, quote and bind activity, referrals, declines, turnaround time, retention, concentrations, and emerging performance trends, and take timely action where results are not meeting expectations.
  • Establish portfolio actions and growth targets by industry, geography, distribution partner, and other relevant segments.
  • Develop practical underwriting standards and guidance that support consistent execution and make Ategrity’s appetite clear and easy to navigate.
  • Partner across underwriting, product, technology, analytics, and operations to automate appropriate decisions, reduce unnecessary referrals and touches, strengthen portfolio analytics, and improve the Agent Portal experience.
Lead Distribution and Agent Experience
  • Build and deepen relationships with wholesale brokers, binding agents, and other distribution partners to generate high-quality new and renewal business.
  • Drive adoption and utilization of the Agent Portal with agents whose business aligns with Ategrity’s underwriting appetite and growth priorities.
  • Clearly communicate Ategrity’s Small Business appetite, capabilities, and value proposition so agents understand where we can win and how to transact efficiently.
  • Maintain a strong market presence through broker outreach, agent engagement, and market visits, using firsthand feedback to improve the customer experience and service model.
  • Establish clear expectations for responsiveness, turnaround time, communication, and issue resolution, and use agent feedback and performance data to continuously improve ease of doing business.
Qualifications
  • Minimum of 10 years of commercial insurance underwriting experience with advanced knowledge of E&S casualty products, underwriting concepts, processes, procedures, and relevant laws and regulations.
  • Demonstrated track record of building and managing profitable underwriting portfolios and achieving growth, profitability, diversification, and operational objectives.
  • Strong relationships with wholesale brokers, binding agents, and other relevant E&S distribution partners, with an understanding of what drives agent adoption, engagement, and ease of doing business.
  • Experience building, growing, or scaling a business unit, underwriting platform, or portfolio strongly preferred.
  • Strong analytical judgment and a data-driven approach to portfolio management, risk selection, conversion, customer experience, and decision-making.
  • Executive presence and excellent communication, negotiation, collaboration, and relationship-management skills.
  • Bachelor’s degree from an accredited college or university; CPCU, AU, CIC, or other relevant professional designation preferred.
  • Willingness to travel approximately 25% to develop distribution relationships and represent Ategrity in the marketplace.
  • Competitive salary commensurate with experience
  • Comprehensive benefits package including medical, dental, and vision coverage
  • 401(k) retirement savings plan with employer match
  • Paid time off and company holidays
  • Professional development opportunities and tuition reimbursement
  • Collaborative and inclusive work environment with opportunities for career growth and advancement
Equal Opportunity Employer:

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company is an equal opportunity employer and values diversity in the workplace. We encourage candidates from all backgrounds to apply.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Underwriter - Small Business
Underwriter - Small Business

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company • Atlanta (GA)

On-site
USD 70,000 - 90,000
Comprehensive benefits package including medical, dental, and vision
401(k) retirement savings plan with employer match
Paid time off and company holidays
+4
VP, Underwriting - Small Business & Digital Growth
VP, Underwriting - Small Business & Digital Growth

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company • United States

On-site
USD 180,000 - 280,000
Comprehensive benefits package (health
401(k) employer match
Paid time off and holidays
+1
Middle Market Property Underwriter - Eastern Region
Middle Market Property Underwriter - Eastern Region

Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company • Virginia (MN)

Hybrid
USD 80,000 - 110,000
Comprehensive benefits package
401(k) retirement savings plan with employer match
Paid time off and company holidays
+5
Underwriter, E&S Casualty
Underwriter, E&S Casualty

Ascot Group • Atlanta (GA)

Hybrid
USD 80,000 - 120,000
Medical, Dental, and Vision Insurance
401k Contributory Savings Plan
Paid Time Off and Holidays
AVP/VP Underwriter, Small Commercial
AVP/VP Underwriter, Small Commercial

Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Company • Boston (MA)

On-site
USD 135,000 - 180,000
Health, Dental and Vision benefits
Disability Insurance
Life Insurance
+2
Executive Underwriter - Primary Casualty
Executive Underwriter - Primary Casualty

AmTrust Financial Services Inc. • Chicago (IL)

Hybrid
USD 115,000 - 170,000
Medical & Dental Plans
Life Insurance
401k Savings Plan
+1
Underwriter - Small Commercial E&S
Underwriter - Small Commercial E&S

MGT Insurance • Denver (CO)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 120,000
Underwriting Consultant - E&S Casualty (Hybrid or Remote)
Underwriting Consultant - E&S Casualty (Hybrid or Remote)

Intact Insurance U.S. • United States

Remote
USD 151,000 - 206,000
Bonus potential
Health insurance
401(k)
+2
Senior Underwriter, E&S Casualty – Complex Risk
Senior Underwriter, E&S Casualty – Complex Risk

Ascot Group • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 115,000 - 145,000
Health and welfare benefits
Paid holidays & PTO
Contributory 401k
Senior Vice President - Connecticut and Vermont
Senior Vice President - Connecticut and Vermont

OneDigital • Hartford (CT)

On-site
USD 180,000 - 280,000