Compensation: $70,000-$90,000 OTE via $50,000 base (either 1099 or W-2 with benefits) + $2,500-$4,000 per executive/mid level placement.
Position Summary
We are seeking a motivated Junior/Associate Recruiter with hands‑on experience in Property & Casualty (P&C) insurance recruiting and exposure to executive-level search. This role supports senior recruiters and hiring managers in sourcing, screening, and advancing talent across underwriting, claims, actuarial, risk management, brokerage, and leadership positions within the P&C sector. The ideal candidate combines strong insurance industry knowledge with the ability to contribute to confidential executive searches.
Key Responsibilities
- Source, identify, and engage passive and active candidates for Property & Casualty roles (underwriting, claims, loss control, actuarial, product, distribution, and related functions) using LinkedIn Recruiter, industry databases, associations, and targeted outreach.
- Support executive and senior-level searches by conducting research, building long lists/short lists, coordinating outreach, and managing candidate pipelines under the direction of senior recruiters or partners.
- Screen resumes and conduct initial phone/video interviews to assess technical fit, cultural alignment, and career motivations.
- Maintain accurate candidate records, pipeline status, and activity metrics in the applicant tracking system (ATS).
- Coordinate interview logistics, gather feedback from hiring managers, and help drive candidates through the process to offer stage.
- Develop and maintain knowledge of P&C market trends, compensation benchmarks, competitor landscapes, and talent availability.
- Build and nurture relationships with candidates and internal stakeholders; represent the firm professionally in all interactions.
- Assist with market mapping, competitive intelligence, and preparation of candidate presentation materials for executive searches.
- Contribute to process improvement, diversity sourcing efforts, and team best practices.
Required Qualifications
- 2+ years of recruiting experience, with meaningful exposure to Property & Casualty insurance talent (agency, carrier, MGA, brokerage, or related).
- Demonstrated experience supporting or participating in executive / senior-level searches (Director and above preferred).
- Strong proficiency with LinkedIn Recruiter and at least one major ATS.
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills; ability to engage senior professionals confidently.
- Highly organized, detail-oriented, and comfortable managing multiple concurrent searches in a fast-paced environment.
- Bachelor’s degree preferred or equivalent combination of education and relevant experience.
Preferred Qualifications
- Direct full-cycle recruiting experience within P&C insurance or insurance-adjacent industries.
- Prior agency or retained executive search experience.
- Knowledge of P&C functional areas (commercial lines, personal lines, specialty, claims, underwriting, actuarial, etc.).
- Experience with Boolean search, market mapping tools, and compensation research.
- Familiarity with diversity, equity, and inclusion sourcing strategies.
Core Competencies
- Insurance industry acumen (P&C focus)
- Candidate assessment and relationship management
- Research and sourcing excellence
- Organizational and process discipline
- Professional presence and discretion (especially on confidential executive work)
- Collaborative team orientation with a proactive mindset
What We Offer
- Competitive base salary + performance-based incentives
- Professional development and exposure to high-level executive search work
- Collaborative team environment with clear growth path toward full desk or senior recruiter responsibilities
This is an excellent opportunity for a recruiter who already understands the Property & Casualty talent landscape and wants to deepen their executive search skills in a supportive, high-impact environment.