Property Manager

Evernest, LLC; Columbus (OH); On-site; USD 65,000 - 80,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Unlimited PTO

8 paid holidays

Health, dental, and vision coverage

Professional development opportunities

Weekly CEO/Q&A sessions

Job summary

Evernest, LLC is seeking a motivated Property Manager to oversee day-to-day operations of a residential portfolio in Columbus, OH. This role focuses on owner satisfaction, coordinating leasing, rents, maintenance, and vendor relations to deliver top-tier results.

The ideal candidate has a real estate background, strong leadership and communication skills, and a passion for exceptional service. You will work daily from the Evernest office within the market.

Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree preferred.
• Active Ohio Real Estate Sales License required; license to be transferred to Evernest brokerage at start of employment.
• Minimum of 2 years of experience in single family or multi-family property management.
• Daily work from the Evernest office in your market.

Responsibilities

• Oversee day-to-day operations of residential properties and ensure owner satisfaction.
• Coordinate leasing, rent collection, maintenance, and vendor relations with cross-functional teams.
• Ensure compliance with local, state, and federal regulations across the portfolio.
• Manage budgets and financial records; track KPIs and drive NOI.
• Dispatch field staff for inspections and manage property condition.
• Develop and implement policies to improve efficiency and tenant/owner experience.
• Prepare reports for Regional Manager and owners as required.

Education

Bachelor's degree (preferred)

Job description

Company Overview

Evernest is a full-service real estate and property management company with a national presence and an outstanding reputation. We operate in 50+ of the nation's most investable markets and manage over 12,000 homes. We are a high-performing team, and our culture is second to none. Built on core values that drive collaboration, innovation, and the relentless pursuit of excellence, we’re not just another property management company. Our dedicated people, proprietary technology, and commitment to continuous improvement are changing an industry.

Position Overview

Evernest is seeking a motivated, proactive and highly organized Property Manager to oversee the day-to-day operations of a residential portfolio. The Property Manager’s primary responsibility is owner satisfaction which requires excellent communication and impeccable coordination. The role touches marketing, leasing, collections, resident relations, retention, maintenance and renovations so you will partner with Resident Services, Accounting, Leasing and Property Services to deliver best in class results. The ideal candidate should have a background in real estate, strong leadership and communication skills, and a passion for providing exceptional service.

Responsibilities:

• Provide outstanding service to our property owners.
• Partner with cross functional teams and oversee day-to-day operations of residential properties including leasing, rent collection, and maintenance.
• Ensure that all properties are in compliance with local, state, and federal regulations.
• Partner with our Property Services team to coordinate with technicians, contractors and vendors for maintenance and repair work.
• Manage budgets and financial records for the properties.
• Execute portfolio level operations in line with company targets and KPIs.
• Dispatch field team members to conduct inspections of properties to ensure they are in good condition and well-maintained.
• Develop and implement policies and procedures to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of property management.
• Stay up-to-date on local market trends and competitor activity.
• Drive financial performance by maximizing NOI.
• Prepare additional reports as required by the Regional Manager, Executive Director, Partners, or Owners.

Requirements:

• Bachelor's degree is preferred.
• A minimum of an Active Ohio State Real Estate Sales License is required. You will be required to transfer your Real Estate License under the Evernest brokerage at the start of your employment.
• Minimum of 2 years of experience in single family or multi-family property management.
• You will work daily from the Evernest office in your market.

Compensation

Base salary + opportunity to earn additional incentives up to 20% of your base salary if KPIs are met.

$65,000 - $80,000 a year

What You Can Look Forward To

• Limitless Learning & Growth: Uncapped professional development opportunities, including weekly company-wide sessions focused on both personal and professional growth.
• Comprehensive Benefits Package: Substantial health, dental, and vision coverage to keep you and your family well taken care of.
• Time for yourself: Enjoy unlimited PTO, plus 8 paid company holidays — because balance matters.
• Culture That Prioritizes People: Weekly company-wide Q&A sessions with our CEO and leadership team — your chance to connect, be recognized, and have your voice heard.
• Innovation Starts Here: Weekly team meetings dedicated to process improvement, collaboration, and solving real challenges — your ideas. matter.
• Feedback-Driven Culture: Quarterly check-ins focused on growth, empowerment, and constructive feedback— because we want you to thrive, not just survive.

Core Values

To be considered for this position, you must connect deeply with Evernest’s company core values:

Win Together

Without sacrificing our core beliefs, we will always put the Team (our Owners, our Residents, and each other), first. Individually, we can only achieve so much; as a team, everyone can meet, and exceed their goals.

Do the Right Thing

We will always be honest with each other, our residents, and our owners. We operate a truth-based property management company with high levels of accountability, regardless of how it affects us individually or as a company.

Own the Outcome

We will continuously strive for the best way to serve our Owners by frequently updating our processes, pushing ourselves never to be stagnant and never accepting the status quo. We are determined to revolutionize this industry.

Embrace the Grind

Beginning with just 30 houses to now almost 15,000, it has taken an extreme amount of hustle and perseverance to grow Evernest. We believe this benefits our clients because we are committed to whatever it takes to lease your home to a well-qualified tenant, collect rent, communicate effectively, and manage the day-in and day-out processes that keep you happy.

Grow Daily

Our team of professionals commits themselves to daily disciplines both inside and outside the office. The positive habits we create in life impact our company and our clients. It´s not an easy business, and there´s no substitute for disciplined habits if you want to remain successful.

#IND123