PIP Claims Supervisor | New Jersey

King's Insurance Staffing

New Jersey

On-site

USD 85,000 - 105,000

Full time

14 days+

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance

Job summary

King's Insurance Staffing is seeking an experienced PIP Claims Supervisor to oversee a team of PIP Claims Adjusters in New Jersey. The role focuses on coverage, eligibility, and claim validity in line with NJ PIP regulations and fraud investigations with SIU.

You will lead coaching, performance evaluations, and workflow improvements to ensure timely, accurate investigations and compliant handling of complex claims.

Qualifications

  • 5–10+ years of experience handling PIP claims with supervisory responsibilities.
  • Thorough knowledge of New Jersey PIP laws, coverage requirements, and eligibility procedures.
  • Experience collaborating with SIU on fraud investigations.
  • Strong leadership, analytical, problem-solving, and decision-making skills.
  • Familiarity with regulatory compliance and claims systems.

Responsibilities

  • Supervise a team of PIP Claims Adjusters evaluating coverage, eligibility, and claim validity.
  • Oversee complex investigations ensuring accurate determinations and handling.
  • Collaborate with SIU to identify fraud and determine next steps.
  • Monitor productivity, quality, and performance; provide coaching and evaluations.
  • Review policy language to ensure accurate eligibility decisions.
  • Develop workflows to promote timely investigations and efficient resolution.
  • Guide escalated claims, disputes, and complex eligibility matters.
  • Partner with internal departments to maintain regulatory compliance.

Skills

PIP claims leadership
Supervisory experience
Analytical skills
Microsoft Excel

Tools

Claims management systems
Microsoft Word
Microsoft Excel

Job description

Our client is seeking an experienced PIP Claims Supervisor to join their New Jersey claims operations. This position is responsible for overseeing a team of PIP Claims Adjusters, ensuring accurate coverage and eligibility determinations, and supporting the investigation and resolution of complex Personal Injury Protection (PIP) claims. The ideal candidate will have a strong understanding of New Jersey PIP regulations, experience working closely with Special Investigations Units (SIU) on suspected fraudulent claims, and a proven ability to lead and develop claims professionals.

Key Responsibilities:
  • Supervise and support a team of PIP Claims Adjusters responsible for evaluating coverage, eligibility, and claim validity in accordance with New Jersey PIP regulations.
  • Oversee complex coverage and eligibility investigations, ensuring accurate determinations and appropriate claims handling.
  • Collaborate closely with Special Investigations Units (SIU) to identify potential fraud, investigate suspicious claims, and determine appropriate next steps.
  • Monitor team productivity, claim quality, and overall performance while providing ongoing coaching, mentorship, and performance evaluations.
  • Review policy language, coverage provisions, and supporting documentation to ensure accurate eligibility decisions.
  • Develop and improve workflows to promote timely investigations, consistent claims handling, and efficient resolution.
  • Provide guidance on escalated claims, coverage disputes, and complex eligibility matters.
  • Partner with internal departments to maintain compliance with applicable insurance laws, regulatory requirements, and company procedures.
Requirements:
  • 5 - 10+ years of experience handling PIP claims, with demonstrated supervisory or team lead responsibilities.
  • Thorough knowledge of New Jersey PIP laws, coverage requirements, and eligibility procedures.
  • Demonstrated experience collaborating with SIU on fraud investigations and suspicious claims.
  • Strong leadership, analytical, problem-solving, and decision-making skills.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Word and Excel, including the ability to monitor and report on team performance metrics.
  • Familiarity with claims management systems and regulatory compliance.
Salary/Benefits:
  • $85,000–$105,000 annual base salary, depending on experience
  • Competitive medical, dental, and vision insurance plans
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

PIP Claims Team Lead – NJ, SIU & Fraud Oversight
PIP Claims Team Lead – NJ, SIU & Fraud Oversight

King's Insurance Staffing • New Jersey

On-site
USD 85,000 - 105,000
Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
Claims Associate, PIP (IA Channel)
Claims Associate, PIP (IA Channel)

Plymouth Rock Assurance • Port Reading (NJ)

On-site
USD 50,000 - 65,000
PTO & holidays
Health coverage Day 1
401(k) match
+4
PIP Representative / PIP Litigation Examiner
PIP Representative / PIP Litigation Examiner

CWA Recruiting • New Jersey

Hybrid
USD 60,000 - 90,000
NJ PIP Claims Specialist - Fast-Paced & Service-Driven
NJ PIP Claims Specialist - Fast-Paced & Service-Driven

Plymouth Rock Assurance • Port Reading (NJ)

On-site
USD 50,000 - 65,000
PTO & holidays
Health coverage Day 1
401(k) match
+4
PIP Claims Examiner & Negotiation Expert
PIP Claims Examiner & Negotiation Expert

CWA Recruiting • New Jersey

Hybrid
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Claims Representative I, PIP (IA Channel)
Claims Representative I, PIP (IA Channel)

Plymouth Rock Assurance • Port Reading (NJ)

On-site
USD 57,000 - 76,000
4 weeks accrued paid time off + 9 paid
Health insurance from Day 1
Annual 401(k) employer contribution
+4
PIP Claims Specialist — Multi-State & Growth Opportunities
PIP Claims Specialist — Multi-State & Growth Opportunities

Plymouth Rock Assurance • Port Reading (NJ)

On-site
USD 57,000 - 76,000
4 weeks accrued paid time off + 9 paid
Health insurance from Day 1
Annual 401(k) employer contribution
+4
PIP Claims Training Specialist
PIP Claims Training Specialist

United Automobile Insurance Company • Miami (FL)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Remote Claims Specialist – PIP & Medical Pay
Remote Claims Specialist – PIP & Medical Pay

Sedgwick • Newark (NJ)

Remote
USD 55,000 - 60,000
Medical, dental, vision
401k with matching
PTO
+3
Claims PIP Adjuster
Claims PIP Adjuster

Wolverine Insurance Company • Dowagiac (MI)

Hybrid
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Health insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+1