Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor

Sheetz Inc.

Columbus (OH)

On-site

USD 23,000 - 33,000

Full time

14 days+

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Competitive pay
PTO
100% paid parental leave
401k match
Employee stock ownership
Medical, vision, and dental coverage
Snack discounts
Set schedules and every other weekend
4-day work weeks

Job summary

Sheetz is seeking a Multi-Store Supervisor to lead teams across multiple stores in the district. You will play a key role in creating a high-energy, customer-first atmosphere, rotating between locations to drive performance and growth.

This opportunity emphasizes fast-paced learning, career growth, and strong leadership presence. Expected shifts are evenings/overnight with a starting pay of $20.50 per hour.

Qualifications

  • Experience leading a team or coordinating staff to meet goals.
  • Willingness to commute up to 30 miles one way (mileage reimbursed beyond 30 miles).
  • Ability to multitask in a fast-paced environment and maintain service standards.

Responsibilities

  • Delegate tasks to team members to meet store standards.
  • Inspire and mentor colleagues and give feedback to the General Manager.
  • Work alongside staff to ensure smooth daily operations.
  • Promote a positive store culture aligned with Sheetz Performance Standards.
  • Deliver outstanding customer service with a customer-focused approach.
  • Uphold safety and regulatory compliance at all times.
  • Travel locally to support nearby stores as needed.

Skills

Team leadership
Multitasking
Customer service

Job description

Sheetz is seeking a Multi-Store Supervisor to lead teams across multiple stores in the district. You will play a key role in creating a high-energy, customer-first atmosphere, rotating between locations to drive performance and growth.

This opportunity emphasizes fast-paced learning, career growth, and strong leadership presence. Expected shifts are evenings/overnight with a starting pay of $20.50 per hour.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — Lead & Grow
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — Lead & Grow

Sheetz Inc. • Streetsboro (OH)

On-site
USD 23,000 - 33,000
PTO
Parental leave
401k match
+5
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — Lead & Elevate Teams
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — Lead & Elevate Teams

Sheetz Inc. • Monroeville

On-site
USD 25,000 - 30,000
PTO
Paid parental leave
401k match
+6
District Multi-Store Supervisor – Nights/Overnights
District Multi-Store Supervisor – Nights/Overnights

Sheetz Inc. • New Stanton

On-site
USD 23,000 - 32,000
PTO
Paid parental leave
401k match
+3
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor: Lead & Elevate Teams
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor: Lead & Elevate Teams

Sheetz Inc. • Powell (OH)

On-site
USD 23,000 - 33,000
PTO
Parental leave
401k match
+5
Multi-Store Supervisor (Evenings/Overnights)
Multi-Store Supervisor (Evenings/Overnights)

Sheetz Inc. • Grove City

On-site
USD 23,000 - 30,000
PTO
100% paid parental leave
401k match
+5
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — $1.50/hr Shift Premium
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — $1.50/hr Shift Premium

Sheetz Inc. • Granville (WV)

On-site
USD 22,000 - 31,000
Night-Shift Multi-Store Supervisor — Lead Teams & Growth
Night-Shift Multi-Store Supervisor — Lead Teams & Growth

Sheetz Inc. • Rostraver Township

On-site
USD 30,000 - 39,000
PTO
Parental leave
401k match
+8
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — $1.50 Extra
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — $1.50 Extra

Sheetz Inc. • Morgantown (WV)

On-site
USD 22,000 - 31,000
PTO
Parental leave
401k match
+6
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — $1.50/hr + Benefits
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor — $1.50/hr + Benefits

Sheetz Inc. • Greencastle

On-site
USD 22,000 - 32,000
Competitive pay
PTO
Paid parental leave
+7
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor (Traveling)
Overnight Multi-Store Supervisor (Traveling)

Sheetz Inc. • Sarversville (PA)

On-site
USD 22,000 - 32,000
Sign-on bonus
Night shift premium
PTO
+6