Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader

Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc.

Jacksonville (FL)

On-site

USD 120,000 - 180,000

Full time

14 days+

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc. in Jacksonville, FL, seeks a Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader to steer complex insurance litigation, advise Claims Leadership and Legal, and oversee strategy, budget, and outside counsel relationships from inception through resolution.

The role demands strong negotiation, analytical, and leadership skills, with experience guiding teams, managing high‑exposure claims, and ensuring regulatory and internal controls compliance.

Qualifications

  • JD degree and active license to practice law preferred.
  • Certifications such as CLM or CLMP preferred.
  • 5–7 years of progressive experience in corporate legal departments, litigation firms, or insurance claims.
  • Experience leading complex litigation lifecycles and managing outside counsel.
  • In-depth knowledge of personal property and casualty insurance laws and Florida civil litigation rules.
  • Ability to interface with executives and opposing counsel to translate legal issues into business strategy.
  • Excellent negotiation, communication, and analytical skills.

Responsibilities

  • Lead and oversee complex insurance litigation matters across the organization.
  • Manage litigation process and outside counsel relationships.
  • Document litigation strategy, budget, investigations, and decisions.
  • Evaluate exposure and provide settlement recommendations to senior claims and GC.
  • Coordinate with counsel to ensure effective representation and cost control.
  • Develop and enforce litigation management best practices and training.

Skills

Negotiation
Analytical
Communication
Leadership
Stakeholder management

Education

Juris Doctor (JD)
Active law license
Certifications: CLM/CLMP

Tools

Microsoft Office Suite

Job description

If you are unable to complete this application due to a disability, contact this employer to ask for an accommodation or an alternative application process.

Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader

Claims Department Full Time Professional Jacksonville, FL, US

20 days ago Requisition ID: 1898

POSITION SUMMARY:

This position willlead and oversee complex insurance litigation matters across our organization. This role serves as a key advisor to Claims Leadership and Legal, managing litigation strategy, outside counsel relationships, legal spending, and high exposure claims from inception through resolution.

PRINCIPAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES:

  • Manages litigation to include serious injury or property damage, questionable damage, questionable liability, and questionable coverage issues.
  • Oversee the litigation process for both coverage and defense matters, including litigation counsel selection, pleadings, discovery, depositions, mediations, and trial preparation.
  • Documents litigation strategy, litigation budget, investigation, evaluation, negotiation, settlement, and trial decisions.
  • Evaluate case exposure, liability, and damages to make well-supported settlement recommendations to senior claims management and general counsel.
  • Coordinate with litigation counsel to ensure effective representation and cost control.
  • Recommend settlement target(s).
  • Audit and evaluate litigation counsel performance to ensure compliance with legal and ethical obligations as well as company requirements.
  • Establish and maintain a litigation counsel file audit program.
  • Work in coordination with senior claims management to identify, evaluate, and recommend coverage and defense counsel for engagement across all states as needed.
  • Develop, implement, and enforce litigation management best practices and process improvements, including legal counsel billing guidelines.
  • Analyze litigation trends to identify risk patterns and propose mitigation strategies.
  • Collaborate with claims leadership on policy interpretation, coverage opinions, and training initiatives.
  • Ensure consistent application of company standards and regulatory compliance.
  • Provide guidance to adjusters on complex injury evaluations, medical causation, and negotiation tactics.
  • Review medical records, expert reports, and legal documentation to assess case value and claim exposure.
  • Identify litigation trends and emerging risks, recommending procedural or policy improvements.
  • Partner with leadership to develop and refine litigation best practices and training programs.
  • Identify litigation trends and emerging risks, recommending process improvements or policy changes as needed.
  • Conduct quality audits of claims, litigation files, and operational processes.
  • Develop and maintain quality assurance standards, scorecards, and performance metrics.
  • Analyze audit findings and prepare reports for management.
  • Ensure compliance with internal controls, company policies, and industry regulations.
  • Identify process deficiencies and recommend corrective actions.
  • Monitor implementation of quality improvement initiatives and measure effectiveness.
  • Analyze key litigation and quality metrics, including cycle times, indemnity leakage, legal expenses, and compliance scores. Present findings and recommendations to leadership teams.
  • Assist Develop and deliver training programs focused on litigation management, quality standards, and best practices.
  • Support change management initiatives and process improvement projects.

MINIMUM JOB REQUIREMENTS:

  • Juris Doctor (JD) degree and active license to practice law preferred.
  • Specialized certifications are preferred, I.e., Certified Legal Manager (CLM) or the Certified Litigation Management Professional (CLMP) preferred.
  • Minimum 5-7 yearsof progressive experience working within corporate legal departments, litigation law firms, or insurance claims departments.
  • Proven experience overseeing complex litigation lifecycles, leading legal teams (paralegals, secretaries, and junior attorneys), and managing outside counsel.
  • In-depth knowledge of laws applicable to personal private insurance, insurance coverage and defense litigation, and Florida civil litigation rules and procedures.
  • Proven ability to manage high-severity and complex property and casualty claim exposures.
  • Ability to interface with executives, external law firms, and opposing counsel to translate complex legal issues into clear business strategies.
  • Excellent negotiation, communication, and analytical skills.
  • Knowledge of P&C policies state laws.
  • Strong judgment and decision‑making ability.
  • Proficiency in claims management systems and Microsoft Office Suite.

The above statements are intended to describe the general nature and level of work being performed. They are not intended to be construed as an exhaustive list of all responsibilities, duties, and skills required of personnel so classified. The incumbent must have the abilities or aptitudes to perform each essential function proficiently with or without reasonable accommodation. Our organization has a dynamic work environment where positions evolve and change. Therefore, the Company reserves the right to modify, delete, or add job duties, responsibilities and skills that are stated in this job description at any time.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader - Jacksonville, FL
Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader - Jacksonville, FL

Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc. • Jacksonville (FL)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 170,000
Competitive compensation
Benefits package
Career growth opportunities
Director of Litigation Strategies and Outcomes
Director of Litigation Strategies and Outcomes

Security First Insurance • Ormond Beach (FL)

On-site
USD 180,000 - 280,000
Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader - Jacksonville, FL
Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader - Jacksonville, FL

Stillwater Insurance • Jacksonville (FL)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 170,000
Competitive compensation
Career development
Collaborative culture
+2
Litigation Specialist Commercial Auto, Professional and General Liability NY FL TX Licenses
Litigation Specialist Commercial Auto, Professional and General Liability NY FL TX Licenses

Lodestar Claims & Risk Services • Tampa (FL)

Remote
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Litigation Specialist Commercial Auto, Professional and General Liability NY FL TX Licenses
Litigation Specialist Commercial Auto, Professional and General Liability NY FL TX Licenses

PMA Companies • Tampa (FL)

Remote
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Senior Litigation Specialist
Senior Litigation Specialist

Argo Group • Chicago (IL)

On-site
USD 73,800 - 117,000
Health insurance
401(k) with company match
Paid time off
Sr CGL Claims Technical Consultant (Litigation)
Sr CGL Claims Technical Consultant (Litigation)

Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. • Illinois

Hybrid
USD 110,000 - 160,000
Insurance Coverage Litigation Attorney
Insurance Coverage Litigation Attorney

Orion Placement • Naples (FL)

Hybrid
USD 160,000 - 250,000
Dental insurance
Paid time off
Retirement plan
+2
Senior Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader
Senior Litigation & Quality Assurance Leader

Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc. • Jacksonville (FL)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 180,000
Sr CGL Claims Technical Consultant (Litigation)
Sr CGL Claims Technical Consultant (Litigation)

Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. • Itasca (IL)

Hybrid
USD 110,000 - 150,000