Insurance Service Manager

AAA Hoosier Motor Club

Indianapolis (IN)

Remote

USD 70,000 - 100,000

Full time

9 days ago

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Health / Dental / Vision benefits
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
Corporate Incentive Plan (CIP)
401k with company match
Company provided LTD & Basic Life Ins.
HSA dollars
Free AAA Plus Membership

Job summary

AAA Hoosier is seeking an experienced Insurance Team Leader to coach a remote group of licensed service and retention agents. You will drive service performance, retention, cross-selling, and team goals while ensuring compliant SOPs and high-quality customer experiences.

You will develop staff through ongoing training on products, systems, and service skills, manage schedules, and report progress to leadership. A proactive, problem-solving mindset is essential.

Qualifications

  • 6+ years of insurance experience, including cross-selling.
  • 3+ years of leadership or management experience.
  • High School Diploma required; Associate’s Degree or higher preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Lead and coach a team of licensed service and retention insurance agents.
  • Conduct regular one-on-ones, side-by-side coaching, and performance evaluations.
  • Motivate the team and recognize achievements to sustain a high-performing culture.
  • Hire, onboard, train, mentor, and develop new team members.
  • Develop staff through ongoing product, systems, and service skills training.
  • Monitor schedules, coverage, and timekeeping to meet goals.
  • Ensure SOP compliance in alignment with Operations Leadership.
  • Support call audits, quality scorecards, and feedback implementation.
  • Track projects and initiatives with Sales Leadership alignment.
  • Drive service performance, cross-selling, and team goals.
  • Analyze metrics and identify retention, quality, and service improvements.
  • Report performance to leadership and share priorities with the team.
  • Handle escalations and promote an outstanding client experience.
  • Identify root causes and implement timely solutions with carriers.
  • Stay current on products, carriers, and industry trends.
  • Enforce quoting, binding, and policy issuance procedures.
  • Maintain licensing, appointments, and continuing education requirements.

Skills

Leadership
Coaching
Team management
Communication
Problem solving
Cross-selling

Education

High School Diploma
Associate’s Degree or higher preferred

Job description

ABOUT AAA HOOSIER:

Since its creation in 1902, AAA has become one of North America’s largest membership organizations. Today, AAA Hoosier provides roadside assistance, travel services, exclusive member discounts and benefits, and trusted financial and insurance services to nearly 400,000 Hoosiers. To learn more about AAA Hoosier offers, visit www.hoosier.aaa.com.

Here’s What is in it for YOU:
  • A company culture that provides training and learning opportunities.
  • A brand that you can be proud to be part of.
  • A culture that will challenge you to be your best.
  • Health / Dental / Vision benefits.
  • Paid Time Off.
  • Paid Holidays.
  • Corporate Incentive Plan (CIP)
  • Company provided LTD & Basic Life Insurance.
  • Service Anniversary Recognition.
  • Free AAA Plus Membership.
  • Generous 401k w/ company match.
  • Company provided HSA dollars.
Position Summary:

As a membership organization first, you are responsible for leading and coaching a team of licensed service and retention insurance agents to deliver an outstanding experience while driving service performance, retention, cross-selling, and team goals. Accountable for the quality and consistency of service through call audits, coaching, and feedback implementation. You will develop and maintain standard operating procedures; reporting on team performance and sharing updates with leadership and the team Must be able to work side by side with agents in a positive coaching and problem-solving approach, building a motivated, accountable, service culture.

Duties and Responsibilities:
1. Coaching & People Leadership
  • Lead and coach a team of licensed service and retention insurance agents.
  • Work side by side with agents through regular one-on-ones, side-by-side call coaching, and formal performance evaluations; counsel and discipline as needed.
  • Motivate the team and recognize individual and team achievements to sustain a high-performing service culture.
  • Hire, onboard, train, mentor, and develop new team members.
  • Take initiative for staff development and career pathing, including ongoing training on products, systems, and service skills.
  • Manage schedules, coverage, and timekeeping to meet service level and call-answer goals.
  • Ensure the staff comply with the SOP process in alignment with Operations Leadership.
3. Project Management (Call Audit & Feedback Implementation)
  • Support the call audit program: maintain a quality scorecard, audit a regular sample of each agent’s calls and interactions, and calibrate scoring for consistency.
  • Turn call audit findings into individual and team feedback, coaching plans, and process changes, and track implementation and results over time.
  • Support and manage department projects and initiatives in alignment with the Sales Leadership.
4. Performance Reporting & Communication
  • Drive service performance, cross-selling, and team goals.
  • Analyze metrics and identify opportunities for improvement (such as retention rate, quality scores, cross-sell results, service levels, and handle time).
  • Report on team and individual performance to the Vice President of Insurance and share updates, priorities, and results with the team and leadership.
5. Problem Solving & Member Experience
  • Handle customer escalations and promote an outstanding client experience.
  • Identify root causes of recurring service issues and implement practical solutions in a timely manner, partnering with carriers and other departments as needed.
  • Act as liaison to insurance companies with which the agency is appointed on service matters.
6. Compliance & Procedures
  • Enforce proper quoting, binding, and policy issuance procedures.
  • Ensure compliance with insurance regulations and AAA, agency, and insurance company guidelines, policies, and procedures.
  • Monitor team licensing, appointments, and continuing education requirements so all agents remain properly licensed.
  • Stay current on products, carrier updates, and industry trends.
7. Other duties as assigned by the Vice President of Insurance or other company executives.
Education and/or Experience Requirements:
  • High School Diploma required; Associate’s Degree or higher preferred.
  • 6+ years of successful insurance experience, including cross-selling.
  • 3+ years of leadership or management experience.
Certificates & Licenses
  • Active Personal Lines or Property & Casualty License required upon hire
  • Life & Health License preferred
  • Valid Driver’s License
  • Other certifications as necessary per agency portfolio
Other Requirements
  • Proven ability to lead a remote team and drive results.
  • Work towards or attainment of advanced insurance education as signified by industry designations (CIC, CPCU, CLU, etc.)
Connect with AAA Hoosier:

Facebook: www.facebook.com/aaahoosier

Company Website: www.hoosier.aaa.com

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent

AAA Hoosier • Muncie (IN)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Health / Dental / Vision benefits
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+6
Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent

AAA Hoosier Motor Club • Terre Haute (IN)

On-site
USD 40,000 - 70,000
Health / Dental / Vision benefits
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+6
Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent

AAA Hoosier Motor Club • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 45,000 - 75,000
Training opportunities
Brand pride
LTD & Life Insurance
+4
Compliance and Audit Coordinator
Compliance and Audit Coordinator

AAA Hoosier Motor Club • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 55,000 - 75,000
Health benefits
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+3
Travel Sales Agent
Travel Sales Agent

AAA Hoosier • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 42,000 - 66,000
Health benefits
Paid Time Off
Free AAA Plus Membership
+3
Travel Advisor
Travel Advisor

AAA Hoosier • Carmel (IN)

On-site
USD 36,000 - 60,000
Health / Dental / Vision benefits
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+4
Travel Advisor
Travel Advisor

AAA Hoosier • Avon (IN)

On-site
USD 21,000 - 30,000
Health / Dental / Vision benefits
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+3
Travel Advisor
Travel Advisor

AAA Hoosier Motor Club • Carmel (IN)

On-site
USD 36,000 - 48,000
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
Company provided LTD & Life Insurance
+4
Dispatcher
Dispatcher

AAA Hoosier • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 36,000 - 48,000
Health / Dental / Vision benefits
401k with company match
Paid Time Off
Insurance Customer Service Agent with AAA
Insurance Customer Service Agent with AAA

Aaa Central Penn • Harrisburg

On-site
USD 22,000 - 30,000
Generous PTO
Personal Day
Company Holidays
+10