Insurance Account Manager - Customer Service & Sales

Farmers Insurance Group

Greeley (CO)

On-site

USD 102,000 - 122,000

Full time

8 days ago

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Full-time position
Multiple carriers
Team environment
Professional development
Performance-based pay

Job summary

Katie Gale Agency in Colorado is seeking a motivated Insurance Specialist to balance excellent customer service with proactive sales growth. You will manage existing client relationships, handle policy changes, and identify opportunities to provide additional coverage.

The role targets a minimum of $10,000 in new written premium each month, with a supportive, team-oriented office environment and opportunities for professional development and advancement.

Qualifications

  • Active Property & Casualty license strongly preferred.
  • Previous insurance agency experience in personal lines customer service, account management, or sales.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills.
  • Ability to multitask in a fast-paced office environment.
  • Sales-minded with proven goal achievement.

Responsibilities

  • Provide outstanding customer service to existing and prospective clients.
  • Answer calls, emails, and inquiries promptly and professionally.
  • Process policy changes, renewals, endorsements, and coverage updates.
  • Assist clients with billing questions and claims guidance.
  • Build and maintain strong, lasting client relationships.
  • Proactively contact clients regarding renewals and coverage needs.
  • Quote and sell home, auto, renters, umbrella, and other insurance products.
  • Meet activity, follow-up, and production expectations.

Skills

Customer service
Sales motivation
Relationship building
Organization

Tools

Agency management system
Insurance quoting platforms

Job description

Job Description

The Katie Gale Agency is a growing insurance agency looking for a motivated, dependable, and outgoing individual to join our team!

Our ideal candidate is already Property & Casualty licensed and has previous experience working in the insurance industry. We're looking for someone who understands insurance policies, enjoys building client relationships, and can confidently balance customer service responsibilities with sales production.

We're not looking for someone who simply answers phones and processes paperwork. We're looking for a relationship builder, problem solver, and self-starter who genuinely enjoys helping people while identifying opportunities to grow our business.

This position combines exceptional customer service with sales responsibilities. You'll help manage existing client relationships, assist with policy changes and questions, and proactively identify opportunities to provide additional coverage.

This is a performance-driven position with a minimum sales expectation of $10,000 in new written premium per month.

The ideal candidate is organized, confident, personable, and comfortable balancing daily service responsibilities with measurable sales goals.

What We Offer

  • Full-time position with an established, growing independent insurance agency.
  • Opportunity to work with multiple insurance carriers and products.
  • Supportive, team-oriented office environment.
  • Opportunity for professional development and advancement.
  • A role that rewards initiative, accountability, and strong performance.
  • Compensation and incentive opportunities discussed during the interview process.

What Success Looks Like

Success in this role means providing an exceptional client experience while consistently contributing to agency growth.

You’ll be expected to manage your daily service responsibilities efficiently, follow through on client needs, identify new sales opportunities, and maintain a minimum of $10,000 in new written premium each month.

If you're someone who enjoys helping people, takes pride in your work, and loves the satisfaction of hitting a goal, we'd love to meet you!

Benefits

Hands on Training###Mon-Fri Schedule###

Responsibilities

Customer Service & Account Management

  • Provide outstanding customer service to existing and prospective clients.
  • Answer incoming calls, emails, and client inquiries promptly and professionally.
  • Process policy changes, renewals, endorsements, and coverage updates.
  • Assist clients with billing questions, claims guidance, and general policy information.
  • Build strong, lasting relationships with clients.
  • Maintain accurate client records and documentation in agency management systems.
  • Proactively contact clients regarding renewals, coverage reviews, and account needs.

Sales & Business Development

  • Generate a minimum of $10,000 in new written insurance premium each month.
  • Identify cross-selling opportunities within our existing book of business.
  • Quote and sell home, auto, renters, umbrella, and other insurance products.
  • Follow up consistently on quotes, leads, and potential sales opportunities.
  • Conduct coverage reviews to identify gaps and recommend appropriate solutions.
  • Educate clients on insurance options and help them make informed decisions.
  • Meet established activity, follow-up, and production expectations.
  • Contribute to overall agency growth and retention goals.
Requirements

We're looking for someone who:

  • Has insurance experience: Already understands the insurance industry, policy servicing, quoting, and client relationships.
  • Takes initiative: Doesn't wait to be told what needs to be done.
  • Is sales-minded: Enjoys meeting goals and understands that selling is part of great customer service.
  • Is genuinely personable: Builds relationships easily and makes clients feel valued.
  • Is highly organized: Can manage multiple tasks without letting things fall through the cracks.
  • Is accountable: Takes ownership of responsibilities, performance, and results.
  • Is proactive: Recognizes opportunities and takes action without constant supervision.
  • Is coachable: Welcomes feedback and is motivated to improve.
  • Is detail-oriented: Understands that accuracy matters in insurance.
  • Has a positive attitude: Brings energy, professionalism, and a solutions-focused mindset to the office.
  • Is a team player: Willing to jump in and help wherever needed.

Requirements:

  • Active Property & Casualty insurance license strongly preferred.
  • Previous insurance agency experience strongly preferred, particularly in personal lines customer service, account management, or sales.
  • Previous customer service experience required.
  • Sales experience strongly preferred.Familiarity with insurance quoting platforms and agency management systems is a plus.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills.
  • Comfortable discussing insurance coverage, pricing, and sales opportunities.
  • Ability to multitask and prioritize in a fast-paced office environment.
  • Strong computer skills and ability to learn new software systems.
  • Ability to work independently while contributing to team goals.
  • Dependable attendance and strong work ethic.
  • Willingness and ability to consistently meet monthly sales expectations.
  • Candidates who are not currently licensed must be willing to obtain the required licensing.
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Insurance Account Manager
Insurance Account Manager

Marnette Bromberg - Allstate Insurance • Providence (RI)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 85,000
Performance bonus
Competitive salary
Advancement opportunities
+2
Insurance Account Manager
Insurance Account Manager

Emil Rummel Insurance Agency • Caro (MI)

On-site
USD 52,000 - 78,000
401(k)
Bonus based on performance
Competitive salary
+7
Insurance Account Manager
Insurance Account Manager

Lake Barkley Insurance • Cadiz (KY)

On-site
USD 40,000 - 70,000
Paid Vacation
Bonuses & Commissions
401K Plan
+6
Account Manager
Account Manager

Mason Insurance Agency Inc • Michigan

On-site
USD 50,000 - 70,000
401(k)
401(k) matching
Competitive salary
+3
Account Manager
Account Manager

Mason Insurance Agency, Inc • Michigan

On-site
USD 50,000 - 75,000
401(k)
401(k) matching
Dental insurance
+2
Insurance Customer Service Rep
Insurance Customer Service Rep

COUNTRY Financial • Warrenton (OR)

On-site
USD 36,000 - 60,000
Paid Time Off (PTO)
Hands on Training
Bonus Opportunities
+5
Personal Lines Account Manager
Personal Lines Account Manager

Farmers Insurance Group • San Ramon (CA)

On-site
USD 55,000 - 75,000
Medical and Dental
Bonus Opportunities
Weekends Off
+5
Customer Service Representative
Customer Service Representative

BARBERA INSURANCE AGENCY INC • Boston (MA)

On-site
USD 42,000 - 64,000
Competitive salary
Advancement opportunities
Paid time off
+4
Insurance Sales Producer
Insurance Sales Producer

RELIABLE FAMILY INSURANCE - Allstate Insurance • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 100,000 - 150,000
Bonus based on performance
Competitive salary
Paid time off
+1
Personal Lines Account Manager
Personal Lines Account Manager

CoVerica • Dallas (TX)

Hybrid
USD 55,000 - 75,000
Positive Work Culture
401(k) matching
Bonus based on performance
+7