Case Qualification Supervisor

Topdog Law, Llc

United States

Remote

USD 70,000 - 120,000

Full time

4 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

TopDog Law is seeking a Case Qualification Specialist Supervisor for our remote Intake Operations. You will lead and develop Case Qualification Specialists, review complex opportunities, and ensure timely, well-supported recommendations to sign, refer, or decline.

You will partner with Intake, Legal, QA, Learning & Development, Analytics, and other teams to improve qualification accuracy, reduce escalations, and strengthen case identification, while maintaining compassionate client communication.

Qualifications

  • Strong experience in personal injury intake, claims, case evaluation, paralegal work, legal operations, or a related field.
  • Demonstrated understanding of personal injury liability, injury severity, case-value indicators, and common case qualification considerations.
  • Previous supervisory, team-lead, coaching, or leadership experience strongly preferred.
  • Strong investigative and critical-thinking skills with the ability to work through incomplete, conflicting, or ambiguous information.
  • Ability to make sound, defensible recommendations while recognizing when additional investigation or attorney guidance is appropriate.
  • Analytical mindset with the ability to use case and performance data to identify trends, root causes, and improvement opportunities.
  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to summarize complex case facts and recommendations clearly and concisely.
  • Strong organizational skills and the ability to manage multiple high-priority cases, competing deadlines, and sensitive client situations.
  • Experience with CRM, case-management, or contact-center systems; Salesforce and Filevine experience preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Lead, coach, and develop Case Qualification Specialists through regular one-on-ones, case reviews, performance discussions, and ongoing feedback.
  • Serve as the first escalation point for complex or unclear case opportunities and personally review cases involving ambiguous liability, significant injuries, commercial involvement, government entities, conflicting facts, or other exceptions.
  • Ensure specialists gather and validate the information needed to make a well-supported recommendation to sign, refer, or decline, and determine when attorney guidance is required.
  • Monitor case volume, turnaround time, aging, follow-up activity, decision quality, documentation, productivity, and client experience; take action when performance falls outside expectations.
  • Analyze qualification outcomes, attorney overrides, decline and referral trends, missed opportunities, and case-level data to identify root causes and opportunities for improvement.
  • Review Intake calls, questionnaires, and documentation to identify upstream gaps and recommend improvements to questions, workflows, criteria, scripts, job aids, training, and escalation rules.
  • Partner with Intake Operations, Legal, QA, Learning & Development, Analytics, and other stakeholders to improve qualification accuracy, reduce unnecessary escalations, and strengthen case identification.
  • Ensure prospective clients with escalated cases receive timely, professional, and empathetic communication and that cases do not stall because of unclear ownership or insufficient follow-up.
  • Build a culture of curiosity, accountability, critical thinking, and sound judgment so specialists can evaluate the facts of each opportunity rather than relying solely on scripts or checklists.

Skills

Leadership
Coaching
Case evaluation
Legal operations
Analytical mindset
Written and verbal communication
Organizational skills
CRM experience
Team leadership

Tools

Salesforce
Filevine
Case-management systems

Job description

TopDog Law is a nationally scaling personal injury firm that owns the client experience end to end, from marketing and intake through litigation. We've grown 2-3x year over year for three years running, and we're now building the operations, systems, and teams to scale without sacrificing quality or culture. We're fully remote, and we value ownership, open communication, and speed. If you want to help build something exceptional, you'll feel at home here.

What You Will Own
What You Bring
Required:
Preferred (Nice to Have):
Who Thrives Here (Core Values)
  • Embrace Change: Open to feedback, embracing change, and always asking what's next?
  • Committed: You care deeply, have your teammates' backs, and show up to build something lasting.
  • No-Ego Energy: Positive, professional, and solutions-oriented. Drama stays at the door.
  • Ownership: You do what you say, follow through, and treat the business like it's yours.
  • Fast & Hungry: You move with urgency, thrive under high expectations, and are motivated by growth and impact.
What We Offer
  • Base Salary: [$Min} - [$Max], commensurate with experience
  • ***[Eligible for performance-based bonus]
  • Our job postings reflect the compensation range for the specific market and location of each role. Ranges vary by geography based on local market rates and cost of labor.
  • Benefits include: Medical, dental, and vision insurance, 401(k) with company match, HSA, life insurance, disability coverage, paid time off, and parental leave.

We are an equal opportunity employer. Employment selection and related decisions are made without regard to age, race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability, sexual orientation, gender identification, or being a qualified disabled veteran or qualified veteran of the Vietnam era or any other category protected by Federal or State law.

DISCLAIMER: This is a full-time employee position. It is not open to independent contractor or consulting arrangements. Compensation is determined by the location where the work is performed and is subject to applicable local law.

All adverse decisions affecting your candidacy are reviewed by a human member of our Talent Acquisition team before being finalized. AI does not make the final decision on your candidacy.

CASE QUALIFICATION SPECIALIST SUPERVISOR

Location: Remote

Department: Intake Operations

Reports To: Director of Intake Operations

Direct Reports: Case Qualification Specialists

JOB OVERVIEW:

The Case Qualification Specialist Supervisor leads the team responsible for reviewing complex, escalated, and exception-based personal injury opportunities that require additional investigation and judgment before a final case decision is made. This role serves as the first level of expert case review and is accountable for the quality, consistency, and speed of qualification decisions. The Supervisor is a hands-on leader who develops specialist judgment, analyzes case and funnel trends, and partners across Intake, Legal, QA, Learning & Development, and Analytics to improve how TopDog Law identifies, evaluates, and advances viable cases.

RESPONSIBILITIES:
  • Lead, coach, and develop Case Qualification Specialists through regular one-on-ones, case reviews, performance discussions, and ongoing feedback.
  • Serve as the first escalation point for complex or unclear case opportunities and personally review cases involving ambiguous liability, significant injuries, commercial involvement, government entities, conflicting facts, or other exceptions.
  • Ensure specialists gather and validate the information needed to make a well-supported recommendation to sign, refer, or decline, and determine when attorney guidance is required.
  • Monitor case volume, turnaround time, aging, follow-up activity, decision quality, documentation, productivity, and client experience; take action when performance falls outside expectations.
  • Analyze qualification outcomes, attorney overrides, decline and referral trends, missed opportunities, and case-level data to identify root causes and opportunities for improvement.
  • Review Intake calls, questionnaires, and documentation to identify upstream gaps and recommend improvements to questions, workflows, criteria, scripts, job aids, training, and escalation rules.
  • Partner with Intake Operations, Legal, QA, Learning & Development, Analytics, and other stakeholders to improve qualification accuracy, reduce unnecessary escalations, and strengthen case identification.
  • Ensure prospective clients with escalated cases receive timely, professional, and empathetic communication and that cases do not stall because of unclear ownership or insufficient follow-up.
  • Build a culture of curiosity, accountability, critical thinking, and sound judgment so specialists can evaluate the facts of each opportunity rather than relying solely on scripts or checklists.
QUALIFICATIONS:
  • Strong experience in personal injury intake, claims, case evaluation, paralegal work, legal operations, or a related field.
  • Demonstrated understanding of personal injury liability, injury severity, case-value indicators, and common case qualification considerations.
  • Previous supervisory, team-lead, coaching, or leadership experience strongly preferred.
  • Strong investigative and critical-thinking skills with the ability to work through incomplete, conflicting, or ambiguous information.
  • Ability to make sound, defensible recommendations while recognizing when additional investigation or attorney guidance is appropriate.
  • Analytical mindset with the ability to use case and performance data to identify trends, root causes, and improvement opportunities.
  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to summarize complex case facts and recommendations clearly and concisely.
  • Strong organizational skills and the ability to manage multiple high-priority cases, competing deadlines, and sensitive client situations.
  • Experience with CRM, case-management, or contact-center systems; Salesforce and Filevine experience preferred.
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Case Qualification Specialist, Illinois
Case Qualification Specialist, Illinois

TopDog Law • Illinois

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical Insurance
Dental Insurance
Vision Insurance
+6
Case Qualification Specialist, Tennessee
Case Qualification Specialist, Tennessee

TopDog Law • Tennessee

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+6
Case Qualification Specialist, Mississippi
Case Qualification Specialist, Mississippi

Topdog Law, Llc • Mississippi

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical benefits
401(k) with company match
HSA
+4
Case Qualification Specialist, North Carolina
Case Qualification Specialist, North Carolina

Topdog Law, Llc • North Carolina

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical, dental, and vision insurance
401(k) with company match
HSA
+4
Case Qualification Specialist, Illinois
Case Qualification Specialist, Illinois

TopDog Law LLC • Illinois

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical, dental, and vision insurance
401(k) with company match
HSA
+4
Case Qualification Specialist, Georgia
Case Qualification Specialist, Georgia

Topdog Law, Llc • Georgia

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+6
Case Qualification Specialist, New York
Case Qualification Specialist, New York

Topdog Law, Llc • New York (NY)

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+6
Case Qualification Specialist, Tennessee
Case Qualification Specialist, Tennessee

Topdog Law, Llc • Nashville (TN)

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical, dental, and vision insurance
401(k) with company match
HSA
+4
Pre-Litigation Case Manager Team Lead, Float
Pre-Litigation Case Manager Team Lead, Float

TopDog Law LLC • United States

Remote
USD 82,000 - 116,000
Medical/Dental/Vision
401(k) Match
HSA
+5
Case Qualification Specialist, New York
Case Qualification Specialist, New York

TopDog Law LLC • New York (NY)

Remote
USD 60,000 - 80,000
Medical,dental,vision insurance
401(k) with company match
HSA
+4