Care Management Supervisor

New Horizon Counseling Center; Town of Hempstead (NY); On-site; USD 65,000 - 70,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Medical, dental, and vision benefits

Paid vacation, sick time, and holidays

Professional development and training

Flexible scheduling

Opportunity for professional growth

Job summary

New Horizon Counseling Center in Nassau County, NY is seeking a Care Management Supervisor to lead a team of Health Home Care Managers serving clients across Nassau and Suffolk Counties. This is a full-time, salaried role that blends leadership with direct client engagement to improve care outcomes.

You will supervise and mentor staff, conduct case reviews, ensure quality documentation in the EHR, manage schedules and caseloads, and build partnerships with shelters, hospitals, and community

Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree in Social Work, Psychology, Sociology, Education, Nursing, Human Services, Healthcare Management, or a related field. Master’s degree strongly preferred.
• At least 3 years of experience in case management, care coordination, or a related field.
• Experience with individuals with SMI and/or housing instability.
• Strong communication, organization, leadership, and problem-solving skills.
• Ability to work independently while collaborating with a team.

Responsibilities

• Lead and mentor a team of Care Managers.
• Provide regular individual and team supervision.
• Coach staff through challenging cases and professional situations.
• Conduct case reviews and help staff develop effective interventions and care plans.
• Support staff development, training, and performance.
• Navigate high-risk situations, safety planning, and incident reporting.
• Participate in community-based client visits across Nassau and Suffolk.
• Visit clients in homes, shelters, hospitals, and other settings.
• Help ensure follow-up after ER visits and hospitalizations.
• Advocate for clients and address barriers to care.
• Monitor client satisfaction and ensure services meet needs.
• Review progress notes, assessments, and care plans.
• Maintain quality documentation in the EHR.
• Manage staff schedules, caseloads, and reporting.
• Ensure compliance with Health Home policies and clinical standards.
• Use Outlook, Word, Excel for communication and reporting.
• Collaborate with shelters, hospitals, providers, and community organizations.
• Strengthen relationships with community partners.
• Assist with crisis intervention and client advocacy when needed.

Skills

Leadership

Team supervision

Communication skills

Case management

Community outreach

Travel to Nassau/Suffolk

Education

Bachelor's degree in Social Work or related field

Master's degree preferred

Tools

Outlook

Word

Excel

Job description

Care Management Supervisor

New Horizon Counseling Center | Nassau County, NY
Full-Time | $65,000–$70,000 per year

Lead a Team. Support Your Staff. Make a Difference in the Community.

Are you an experienced care manager or supervisor who wants to make a meaningful impact while helping other professionals grow?

New Horizon Counseling Center is looking for a Unit Supervisor to lead a team of Health Home Care Managers serving clients throughout Nassau and Suffolk Counties.

This is an opportunity for someone who enjoys both leadership and direct client engagement. You’ll supervise and mentor care managers, provide guidance on complex cases, and remain connected to the clients and communities we serve.

Our clients include individuals living with Serious Mental Illness (SMI), Substance Use Disorders, frequent hospitalizations, and housing instability, including individuals residing in shelters.

If you are a strong communicator, a supportive leader, and someone who is comfortable getting out into the community—not just sitting behind a desk we’d like to hear from you.

What You'll Do

Lead & Mentor a Team

• Supervise and support a team of Care Managers.
• Provide regular individual and team supervision.
• Coach staff through challenging cases and professional situations.
• Conduct case reviews and help staff develop effective interventions and care plans.
• Support staff development, training, and performance.
• Help staff navigate high-risk situations, safety planning, and incident reporting.

Stay Connected to Clients

• Participate in community-based client visits throughout Nassau and Suffolk.
• Visit clients in homes, shelters, hospitals, and other community settings.
• Help ensure clients receive appropriate follow-up after ER visits and hospitalizations.
• Advocate for clients and help address barriers to care.
• Monitor client satisfaction and ensure services are meeting client needs.

Keep the Team Organized & Accountable

• Review progress notes, assessments, and care plans.
• Maintain quality documentation in the EHR.
• Manage staff schedules, caseload assignments, and documentation.
• Ensure compliance with Health Home policies and clinical standards.
• Use Outlook, Word, Excel, and other systems for communication and reporting.

Build Community Partnerships

• Collaborate with shelters, hospitals, healthcare providers, and social service organizations.
• Strengthen relationships with community partners.
• Assist with crisis intervention and client advocacy when needed.

What We're Looking For

Required:

• Bachelor's degree in Social Work, Psychology, Sociology, Education, Nursing, Human Services, Healthcare Management, or a related field. Master's degree strongly preferred.
• At least 3 years of experience in case management, care coordination, or a related field.
• Experience working with individuals with SMI and/or individuals experiencing homelessness or housing instability.
• Strong communication, organization, leadership, and problem-solving skills.
• Ability to work independently while collaborating effectively with a team.
• Comfortable traveling throughout Nassau and Suffolk for client and staff support.

Preferred:

• Experience with Health Home Care Management.
• Experience working with shelters, hospitals, behavioral health providers, or community-based organizations.

Why Join New Horizon?

You won't be stuck behind a desk all day.

This position gives you the opportunity to combine leadership, clinical support, and meaningful community work. You'll have the ability to influence the quality of care clients receive while helping a team of care managers become stronger professionals.

We Offer:

• $65,000-$ 70,000 annual salary
• Full-time, salaried position
• Medical, dental, and vision benefits
• Paid vacation, sick time, and holidays
• Supportive and collaborative work environment
• Professional development and training opportunities
• Flexible scheduling within the needs of the program
• Opportunity for professional growth

This Role May Be a Great Fit If You…

• Are ready to take the next step from Care Manager to Supervisor.
• Already supervise staff and want a more hands-on leadership role.
• Enjoy mentoring and developing other professionals.
• Have strong experience with complex behavioral health or high-need populations.
• Don't mind getting into the community and meeting clients where they are.
• Want your work to have a direct impact on vulnerable New Yorkers.

Ready to Make an Impact?

If you're a compassionate leader who knows care management and wants to help both clients and staff succeed, we'd love to hear from you.

Come join a team where your leadership can make a difference—one client, one care manager, and one community at a time.