Senior Adjuster, Casualty Claims

Heartland Mutual Insurance Company; Kitchener; On-site; CAD 68,000 - 102,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Health benefits

Pension plan

Paid time off

Bonus

Job summary

Heartland Mutual Insurance in Ontario and Nova Scotia seeks a Senior Adjuster, Casualty Claims, to manage complex and high-severity liability claims across Auto, Property, Commercial, and Farm exposures. The role requires advanced liability evaluation, negotiation, and litigation support, with leadership in file reviews, reserve accuracy, and collaboration with legal counsel, brokers, and internal teams.

The successful candidate brings 7–10 years of liability claims experience, a CIP preferred,

Qualifications

• Minimum 7-10 years of liability claims handling experience.
• Experience with litigated and high-severity claims.
• CIP designation or CIP preference.

Responsibilities

• Manage a caseload of complex casualty claims across Auto, Property, Commercial, and Farm Liability.
• Conduct investigations, assess liability, and determine indemnity.
• Provide litigation support and collaborate with legal counsel.
• Maintain accurate claim files and regulatory compliance.
• Mentor junior adjusters and share best practices.

Skills

Liability claims handling

Litigated claims

Negotiation

Analytical skills

Communication skills

Education

Insurance or Law degree

CIP designation

Tools

Claims management systems

Job description

Job Description

Posted Wednesday, June 3, 2026 at 4:00 AM

At Heartland Mutual Insurance, we're more than just a company - we're a community.

Proudly rooted in Ontario and Nova Scotia, we're driven by a bold vision: to be the Best Mutual. Our team of passionate professionals doesn't just follow the norm - we challenge it. We think differently, aim high, and deliver on our promise with a personal touch.

Here, you'll be part of a culture that values authenticity, embraces change, and empowers you to make a meaningful impact every day. Together, we bring our purpose to life by living our values and putting people first.

The Senior Adjuster, Casualty Claims, is responsible for the management and resolution of complex and high-severity casualty claims, including Auto Liability, Personal Property Liability, Commercial General Liability, and Farm Liability. This role requires advanced technical expertise in liability evaluation, negotiation, and litigation support. The Senior Adjuster works closely with legal counsel, brokers, Agents, Direct Sales Center staff, and internal teams, contributing to the consistent delivery of fair, timely, and cost-effective claims outcomes. The position is critical to ensuring accurate reserving, effective customer communication, and alignment with regulatory and corporate standards.

A) Job Specific Accountabilities - Key Responsibility Areas (KRA's)

What you will do...

Complex Claims Management:

• Manage a caseload of complex and high-severity liability claims, with a focus on Auto, Property, Commercial, and Farm Liability exposures.
• Conduct thorough investigations, assess liability, and determine appropriate coverage and indemnity.
• Ensure timely and accurate reserve setting in alignment with organizational reserving guidelines and exposure assessments.
• Negotiate settlements directly with claimants, legal representatives, and insurers, ensuring fair and defensible outcomes.

Litigation Support and Legal Collaboration:

• Work closely with internal and external legal counsel on litigated claims, providing all necessary documentation, analysis, and case updates.
• Attend mediations, discoveries, and settlement conferences as required.
• Ensure proactive litigation management and strategy alignment with corporate interests.

Stakeholder Communication and Relationship Management:

• Maintain open and professional communication with Independent Brokers, Agents, Direct Sales Center staff, and customers throughout the life of the claim.
• Respond to escalations and inquiries promptly and effectively, ensuring transparency and customer satisfaction.
• Foster collaborative relationships with internal teams including Underwriting, Risk, and Corporate Claims.

Documentation, Compliance, and Reporting:

• Maintain accurate, detailed claim files in accordance with company standards and regulatory requirements.
• Ensure compliance with all legal, privacy, and financial guidelines.
• Provide regular updates and reporting to Claims Management on file status, trends, and risks.

Mentorship and Technical Development:

• Provide guidance and informal mentorship to junior and intermediate adjusters, supporting knowledge transfer and best practice adherence.
• Participate in QA reviews and support training initiatives in partnership with the QA Specialist and Training Lead.

Industry Awareness and Risk Insight:

• Monitor and report on emerging legal, regulatory, and industry trends impacting casualty claims.
• Collaborate with underwriting and actuarial teams to share insights from claims data that inform pricing, risk selection, and product development.

What you will bring...

Education & Experience:

• Minimum 7-10 years' experience in liability claims handling, including litigated and high-severity claims.
• Post-secondary education in Insurance, Law, or related field; CIP designation strongly preferred.

Technical Skills & Knowledge:

• Advanced understanding of liability claims processes, litigation procedures, policy interpretation, and reserving practices.
• Proficient in claims management systems, documentation, and analytics tools.
• Strong negotiation, analytical, and critical-thinking skills.
• Excellent verbal and written communication abilities.
• High attention to detail and strong organizational capabilities.
• Ability to manage complex files independently while contributing to a collaborative team environment.
• Professionalism, integrity, and a commitment to customer service excellence.

What's in it for You:

• A Supportive Team:We're not just a workplace, we're a community. We are small but mighty, we believe in the power of connection, purpose, and belonging.
• Comprehensive Total Rewards:Enjoy a competitive compensation package made up of base salary and bonus, health and wellness benefits, pension plan, paid time off, and so much more.
• Inclusive Culture:Work in an environment that embraces diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging.
• Career Growth & Development:Take advantage of continuous learning opportunities and stretch assignments.
• Make an Impact:Play a key role in helping customers navigate challenging situations with empathy and expertise.

The salary range for this role is $68,000 - $102,000. The salary for the successful candidate will be determined by various factors including but not limited to an individual’s relevant experience, knowledge, skills, along with internal equity, and market considerations.

This job posting is for an existing vacancy within Heartland.

Accommodation is available on request for candidates taking part in all aspects of the selection process.

We do not use artificial intelligence or automated decision-making tools in any part of our hiring process. All applications are reviewed by our Talent Acquisition team to ensure fairness and transparency.

At Heartland Mutual Insurance, you're empowered to thrive. Whether it's your career, your well-being, or your future, we've got you covered.