Underwriting Supervisor

CompSource Mutual Insurance Company; Tulsa (OK); Hybrid; USD 70,000 - 90,000; Full time

Job summary

CompSource Mutual is seeking an Underwriting Supervisor in Tulsa, OK. This full-time position involves managing a team, ensuring alignment of underwriting practices with company goals, and fostering collaboration. The ideal candidate will possess strong analytical skills and significant experience in property and casualty insurance, contributing to a community-focused workplace.

Benefits

Free employee medical/dental/vision/life/ad&d insurance

Company match 401k with immediate vesting

Generous paid time off and wellness leave

Floating holiday and voluntary benefits

Qualifications

• 5+ years’ experience underwriting property and casualty insurance.
• Oklahoma issued Insurance Agent/Producer license preferred.
• Familiarity with workers comp, commercial auto, and/or property underwriting processes is a plus.

Responsibilities

• Manage a team of underwriters and assistants.
• Ensure underwriting decisions align with company guidelines.
• Contribute to strategic initiatives and operational efficiency.

Skills

Analytical thinking

Risk assessment

Conflict resolution

Education

High school diploma or GED

Bachelor’s degree or CPCU

Tools

Underwriting platforms (e.g., Guidewire, PolicyCenter)

Microsoft Office Suite

Salesforce or CRM systems

Job description

Job Details

Job Location: Tulsa Location - Tulsa, OK

Position Type: Full Time

Education Level: High School Diploma/GED

Salary Range: Undisclosed

Job Category: Underwriting

Description

Are you an experienced Underwriter in the Tulsa area? Looking for the next step in your career in a collaborative and fast-paced environment? Let me introduce you to CompSource Mutual!CompSource has been proudly serving Oklahoma workers since 1933, providing workers’ comp protection and support in good times and bad. We are passionate about providing a great place to work and are consistently awarded as a “best” and “top” place to work in Oklahoma!

What we’re offering:

A full-time Underwriting Supervisor position in Tulsa with a hybrid work schedule. Competitive base salary dependent on experience and internal equity. Benefit package includes: free employee medical/dental/vision/life/ad&d insurance, company match 401k with immediate vesting, generous paid time off and wellness leave, floating holiday, and voluntary benefits.

The Role:

As an Underwriting Supervisor, you will directly manage a team of underwriters and underwriting assistants, providing coaching, guidance, and regular performance feedback. You’ll ensure underwriting decisions and workflows align with company guidelines and support profitability goals. In addition to overseeing daily operations, you’ll contribute to strategic initiatives such as system enhancements, training implementation, and cross-functional collaboration to drive continuous improvement and operational efficiency. Strong communication and relationship-building with staff, internal teams, and external partners are key to success in this role.

Who we’re looking for:

• High school diploma or GED required; Bachelor’s degree or CPCU preferred
• 5+ years’ experience underwriting property and casualty insurance
  • Familiarity with workers comp, commercial auto, and/or property underwriting processes is a plus
• Oklahoma issued Insurance Agent/Producer license preferred
• Analytical thinking and sound judgment in risk assessment
• Ability to prioritize, delegate, and resolve conflicts calmly and efficiently
• Preferred experience with:
  • Underwriting platforms (e.g., Guidewire, PolicyCenter, or similar)
  • Microsoft Office Suite, proficiency with Excel
  • Salesforce or CRM systems for tracking lead or submission activity

Qualifications