Tax Supervisor: Lead End-to-End Engagements & Mentor Team

Agresta, Storms & O'Leary PC; Columbus (IN); Hybrid; USD 70,000 - 90,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Health and dental insurance

Competitive PTO package

Employer 401(k) match

Performance‑based bonus opportunity

Flexible offseason schedule

Job summary

Agresta, Storms & O'Leary PC is seeking a Tax Supervisor for its Columbus, Indiana office. The role bridges the Senior Associate and Manager levels, focusing on reviewing tax returns, running smaller tax engagements, and being a day-to-day client contact. Required qualifications include an active CPA license and 5–7 years of public accounting experience. The firm offers a hybrid work schedule, competitive salary, performance-based bonuses, and a family-friendly environment that values work-life balance.

Qualifications

• Active CPA license (required).
• 5–7 years of progressive public accounting experience with a broad tax background.
• Strong technical knowledge across individual, corporate, partnership, trust, and nonprofit tax.
• Demonstrated experience reviewing the work of less experienced staff and providing developmental feedback.
• Excellent client‑facing communication skills and the judgment to know when to escalate to a Manager or Partner.
• Track record of managing multiple concurrent engagements and meeting deadlines without sacrificing quality.
• Prior experience at a firm of meaningful scale and complexity.

Responsibilities

• Review tax returns prepared by Associates and Senior Associates across individual, corporate, partnership, trust, and nonprofit engagements.
• Run smaller tax engagements end-to-end, including scoping, scheduling, execution, and client communication.
• Serve as a primary day‑to‑day client contact on assigned engagements, building trusted relationships and resolving most technical questions directly.
• Identify and research moderate to complex tax issues, including planning opportunities and exposure areas, and prepare clear written analysis.
• Provide direct supervision, coaching, and real‑time feedback to 2–4 staff members.
• Partner with Managers and Partners on engagement planning, budgeting, and risk assessment.

Job description

Agresta, Storms & O'Leary PC is seeking a Tax Supervisor for its Columbus, Indiana office. The role bridges the Senior Associate and Manager levels, focusing on reviewing tax returns, running smaller tax engagements, and being a day-to-day client contact. Required qualifications include an active CPA license and 5–7 years of public accounting experience. The firm offers a hybrid work schedule, competitive salary, performance-based bonuses, and a family-friendly environment that values work-life balance.