Tax Supervisor: Lead End-to-End Engagements & Mentor Team

Agresta, Storms & O'Leary PC

Columbus (IN)

Hybrid

USD 70,000 - 90,000

Full time

14 days+

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Health and dental insurance
Competitive PTO package
Employer 401(k) match
Performance‑based bonus opportunity
Flexible offseason schedule

Job summary

Agresta, Storms & O'Leary PC is seeking a Tax Supervisor for its Columbus, Indiana office. The role bridges the Senior Associate and Manager levels, focusing on reviewing tax returns, running smaller tax engagements, and being a day-to-day client contact. Required qualifications include an active CPA license and 5–7 years of public accounting experience. The firm offers a hybrid work schedule, competitive salary, performance-based bonuses, and a family-friendly environment that values work-life balance.

Qualifications

  • Active CPA license (required).
  • 5–7 years of progressive public accounting experience with a broad tax background.
  • Strong technical knowledge across individual, corporate, partnership, trust, and nonprofit tax.
  • Demonstrated experience reviewing the work of less experienced staff and providing developmental feedback.
  • Excellent client‑facing communication skills and the judgment to know when to escalate to a Manager or Partner.
  • Track record of managing multiple concurrent engagements and meeting deadlines without sacrificing quality.
  • Prior experience at a firm of meaningful scale and complexity.

Responsibilities

  • Review tax returns prepared by Associates and Senior Associates across individual, corporate, partnership, trust, and nonprofit engagements.
  • Run smaller tax engagements end-to-end, including scoping, scheduling, execution, and client communication.
  • Serve as a primary day‑to‑day client contact on assigned engagements, building trusted relationships and resolving most technical questions directly.
  • Identify and research moderate to complex tax issues, including planning opportunities and exposure areas, and prepare clear written analysis.
  • Provide direct supervision, coaching, and real‑time feedback to 2–4 staff members.
  • Partner with Managers and Partners on engagement planning, budgeting, and risk assessment.

Job description

Agresta, Storms & O'Leary PC is seeking a Tax Supervisor for its Columbus, Indiana office. The role bridges the Senior Associate and Manager levels, focusing on reviewing tax returns, running smaller tax engagements, and being a day-to-day client contact. Required qualifications include an active CPA license and 5–7 years of public accounting experience. The firm offers a hybrid work schedule, competitive salary, performance-based bonuses, and a family-friendly environment that values work-life balance.
Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Tax Senior: Lead Tax Engagements & Mentoring Flexible PTO
Tax Senior: Lead Tax Engagements & Mentoring Flexible PTO

Jobot • Dublin (OH)

On-site
USD 85,000 - 110,000
4 weeks PTO
Paid holidays
401(k)
+3
Tax Associate: Mentorship & Growth in Public Accounting
Tax Associate: Mentorship & Growth in Public Accounting

Agresta, Storms & O’Leary, PC • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 78,000
Health insurance
Dental insurance
401(k) match
+1
Tax Manager — Lead Tax Engagements & Mentoring (Hybrid)
Tax Manager — Lead Tax Engagements & Mentoring (Hybrid)

Creative Financial Staffing • Avon (IN)

Hybrid
USD 90,000 - 140,000
Hybrid work environment
Bonus opportunities
Profit sharing
+2
Senior Tax Accountant — CPA-Led Tax Strategy & Compliance
Senior Tax Accountant — CPA-Led Tax Strategy & Compliance

Vaco • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 85,000 - 105,000
Tax Manager — CPA Leader in Tax & Compliance
Tax Manager — CPA Leader in Tax & Compliance

Vaco • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Tax Manager – Partnerships & S‑Corps Lead (CPA)
Tax Manager – Partnerships & S‑Corps Lead (CPA)

Staff Financial Group • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 130,000
Competitive compensation
Comprehensive benefits package
Professional development opportunities
Tax Senior: Lead Engagements & Mentor Talent
Tax Senior: Lead Engagements & Mentor Talent

Pile CPAs • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 55,000 - 75,000
Formal mentorship program
Career development resources
Collaborative work environment
Tax Supervisor — Client Advisory & Tax Strategy
Tax Supervisor — Client Advisory & Tax Strategy

Rea • New Philadelphia (OH)

On-site
USD 70,000 - 90,000
Health Care Plan (Medical, Dental & Vision)
Retirement Plan (401k)
Paid Time Off (Vacation, Sick & Public Holidays)
+1
On-Site Tax Manager (CPA) - Lead & Mentor in Columbus
On-Site Tax Manager (CPA) - Lead & Mentor in Columbus

Shift Pursuit (United States) • Columbus (OH)

Hybrid
USD 120,000 - 150,000
Tax Supervisor - Growth, Mentorship, Hybrid/Remote
Tax Supervisor - Growth, Mentorship, Hybrid/Remote

Jobot • Indianapolis (IN)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 105,000
Work-from-home flexibility