Property Claims Specialist - Financial Institution Services

gaig; Cincinnati (OH); Hybrid; USD 90,000 - 120,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Medical, dental, and vision coverage

401(k) with company match

Paid time off and holidays

Tuition reimbursement

Commuter benefits

Job summary

Great American Insurance Group is seeking a seasoned Property Claims Specialist in Cincinnati to manage complex claims and lead investigations while negotiating settlements. The role combines on-site collaboration four days a week with one remote day, focusing on coverage determinations, reserving, and strategic defense coordination with local counsel.

The candidate will have 7+ years in property and casualty claims, a Bachelor’s in a related field, and an active multi-state adjuster license;

Qualifications

• Education and licensing as required for complex property claims handling.
• 7+ years of property and casualty claims experience, litigation preferred.
• Strong knowledge of insurance policies, coverage, and claims procedures.
• Ability to negotiate settlements and manage high-stakes cases.

Responsibilities

• Manages a large inventory of complex claims and evaluates compensability.
• Plans and conducts investigations to confirm coverage and damages.
• Negotiates settlements and reserves within authority.
• May attend arbitrations, mediations, or trials.
• Coordinates with local outside counsel and communicates with insureds and partners.
• Ensures timely payments and maintains detailed claim files.
• Ensures compliance with statutes, regulations, and company policies.

Skills

Analytical skills

Negotiation

Communication

Leadership

Problem solving

Education

Bachelor's Degree in Business Administration, Risk Management and Insurance, Finance, or related field

Active adjuster license in multiple states

Progress toward AIC or similar designation

Tools

AI tools (Copilot/Nomad)

Job description

Be Here. Be Great. Working for a leader in the insurance industry means opportunity for you. Great American Insurance Group's member companies are subsidiaries of American Financial Group. We combine a \"small company\" culture where your ideas will be heard with \"big company\" expertise to help you succeed. With over 30 specialty and property and casualty operations, there are always opportunities here to learn and grow.

At Great American, we value and recognize the benefits derived when people with different backgrounds and experiences work together to achieve business results. Our goal is to create a workplace where all employees feel included, empowered, and enabled to perform at their best.

Great American Financial Institution Services specializes in providing risk management and product enhancement programs to mortgage lenders, commercial banks, credit unions, finance companies, mortgage servicers, and real estate investors throughout the United States. This division insures all forms of collateral securing mortgages, retail installment contracts and loans. This includes but is not limited to residential and commercial real property, commercial vehicles, commercial contents and equipment.

Coupled with advanced document processing, software applications, state of the art AI tools – along with rigorous security and governance practices, Great American delivers fully integrated property insurance programs to some of the largest lenders and investors in the country. While we are large enough to handle volume, we are also nimble enough to address the specific and complex needs of smaller customers as well. For clients of all sizes and types, we pride ourselves on responsive support and proactive claims handling.

https://www.greatamericaninsurancegroup.com/about-us/business-operations/division/financial-institutionservices

We are looking for a Property Claims Specialist to join our team! Great American’s culture is built on connection, shared learning, and strong relationships. To support this, employees in this role are expected to be on-site four days a week, with the flexibility to work one day remotely. Core in‑office days are Tuesday–Thursday, with the fourth day determined by business needs.

Essential Job Functions and Responsibilities

• Manages a large inventory of complex claims to evaluate compensability per the terms of the appliable hazard policy.

• Plans and conducts claim investigations to confirm coverage and to determine compensability and damages.

• Determines and negotiates appropriate claim settlements/reserves within prescribed authority.

• May attend arbitrations, mediations, depositions, or trials.

• Assigns local outside counsel, as appropriate, to represent and defend Great American in litigation. Will then communicate and strategize with local defense counsel to achieve the best outcome. Will review and evaluate local counsel’s work product and provide instruction to counsel throughout the life cycle of the litigation.

• Conveys complex information regarding coverage and settlements to insureds, claimants, and external partners.

• Authorizes payments in accordance with assigned authority limit and ensures payments are made in a timely manner.

• Maintains accurate and detailed claim files, including all correspondence, reports, and settlement agreements.

• Ensures that claims handling is conducted in compliance with applicable statutes, regulations and other legal requirements, and that all applicable company procedures and policies are followed.

• Performs other duties as assigned.

Job Requirements

• Education: Bachelor’s Degree in Business Administration, Risk Management and Insurance, Finance, or a related field or equivalent experience.

• Experience: Generally, 7 or more years of experience in property and casualty claims handling. Experience handling first-party property claims in litigation is preferred. Completion of or continuing progress toward a professional designation preferred, such as Associate in Claims (AIC). Holds an active adjusters license in multiple states.

• Scope of Job/Qualifications: Works within broad limits and authority on assignments of the highest technical complexity, requiring specialized knowledge. Demonstrates excellent analytical, negotiation, and problem-solving skills. Maintains strong knowledge of insurance policies, coverage, and claims handling procedures. Maintains knowledge of industry laws and regulations. Advanced ability to organize and prioritize caseloads, ensuring timely resolution of claims. Excellent interpersonal and communication skills with the ability to build relationships and lead negotiations. Proven ability to handle confidential information with discretion. Viewed as a senior resource within the Claims department and/or organization.

• Other Desirable Background:

  • A law degree is a significant plus

  • AI experience is a plus (preferably with Co-Pilot or Nomad)

Business Unit:

Financial Institution Services

Benefits:

We offer competitive benefits packages for full-time and part-time employees*. Full-time employees have access to medical, dental, and vision coverage, wellness plans, parental leave, adoption assistance, and tuition reimbursement. Full-time and eligible part-time employees also enjoy Paid Time Off and paid holidays, a 401(k) plan with company match, an employee stock purchase plan, and commuter benefits.

Compensation varies by role, level, and location and is influenced by skills, experience, and business needs. Your recruiter will provide details about benefits and specific compensation ranges during the hiring process. Learn more at http://www.gaig.com/careers.

*Excludes seasonal employees and interns.