Property Claims Examiner

Vanguard Claims Administration

Woodbury (NJ)

On-site

USD 65,000 - 90,000

Full time

37 hours ago
Be an early applicant

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Vanguard Claims Administration is seeking an experienced Property Claims Examiner to join our growing team in New Jersey. This role focuses on investigating, evaluating, managing, and resolving property claims with attention to policy provisions, client requirements, and compliance standards.

Ideal candidates will hold a Property & Casualty license, have 3–5 years of property claims experience, and demonstrate strong investigative, analytical, and negotiation skills while delivering

Qualifications

  • High school diploma or equivalent; bachelor's degree preferred.
  • Property & Casualty Insurance License required.
  • 3-5 years of property claims handling experience.
  • AIC designation and additional state licensing preferred.
  • Familiarity with Lloyd's of London claims is preferred, but not required.
  • Strong knowledge of insurance coverage, claims management, and regulatory requirements.
  • Excellent investigative, analytical, negotiation, and problem-solving skills.
  • Ability to manage a high-volume caseload, prioritize deadlines, and work independently.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills with a commitment to customer service.

Responsibilities

  • Manage an active diary of property claims, ensuring files are current and well documented.
  • Review coverage, evaluate exposures, and negotiate settlements within authority.
  • Prepare reports for large losses and for claims requiring additional approvals.
  • Identify subrogation opportunities and coordinate recoveries.
  • Assign and oversee Independent Adjusters, experts, legal counsel, and other vendors.
  • Escalate significant claim developments to supervisors and underwriters.
  • Provide support during catastrophe (CAT) responses as needed.
  • Establish and review reserves to ensure accurate financial exposure.
  • Oversee vendor payments, settlements, and billing with supervisory approval.
  • Support billing activities and reporting.

Skills

Investigative skills
Negotiation
Communication
Prioritization
Independent work

Education

High school diploma or equivalent
Bachelor's degree preferred

Tools

Microsoft Office
Claims management systems

Job description

Vanguard Claims Administration is seeking an experienced Property Claims Examiner to join our growing team!

At Vanguard, EVERY CLAIM COUNTS. We are committed to delivering exceptional claims management services through technical expertise, responsive service, and a dedication to fair, timely, and accurate claim resolutions.

The Property Claims Examiner will be responsible for investigating, evaluating, managing, and resolving property claims in accordance with policy provisions, client requirements, company guidelines, and assigned authority levels. This position requires strong technical claims knowledge, sound judgment, excellent communication skills, and a commitment to protecting confidential information and maintaining SOC 2 compliance standards.

Key Responsibilities
  • Manage an active diary of property claims, ensuring files are current, organized, and thoroughly documented.
  • Review and verify coverage, evaluate exposures, and negotiate settlements within assigned authority.
  • Prepare reports for large losses and claims requiring additional authority or approval.
  • Identify potential subrogation opportunities and coordinate referrals to maximize recoveries.
  • Assign and oversee Independent Adjusters, experts, legal counsel, and other vendors.
  • Escalate significant claim developments and matters exceeding assigned authority to supervisors and underwriters.
  • Provide additional support during catastrophe (CAT) responses as needed.
  • Establish and regularly review reserves to ensure accurate financial exposure.
  • Oversee vendor payments, settlement drafts, and collection of required funds from underwriters.
  • Support billing activities, including invoice preparation and reporting, in coordination with supervisory approval and company billing objectives.
Documentation, Compliance & Reporting
  • Maintain accurate and complete claim documentation, including notes, correspondence, diaries, reminders, management information, and status updates.
  • Prepare coverage correspondence, including withdrawal, below-deductible, and denial letters, along with required client and TPA reports.
  • Ensure all claim activities meet applicable client requirements, company procedures, and regulatory standards.
  • Communicate significant claim developments to supervisors and underwriters.
  • Provide technical guidance to adjusters and other claims personnel.
  • Deliver exceptional service to underwriters, agents, brokers, policyholders, and other stakeholders.
  • Participate in departmental initiatives and process improvement projects.
Security & SOC 2 Compliance
  • Protect confidential client, policyholder, claimant, and company information.
  • Follow established security policies, role-based access controls, and data handling procedures.
  • Maintain accurate and complete information across company systems and reporting platforms.
  • Promptly report potential security incidents or compliance concerns.
  • Participate in required security training and support audit-readiness activities.
Qualifications & Experience
  • High school diploma or equivalent required; bachelor's degree preferred.
  • Property & Casualty Insurance License required.
  • 3-5 years of property claims handling experience.
  • AIC designation and additional state licensing preferred.
  • Familiarity with Lloyd's of London claims is preferred, but not required.
  • Strong knowledge of insurance coverage, claims management, and applicable legal and regulatory requirements.
  • Excellent investigative, analytical, negotiation, and problem-solving skills.
  • Ability to manage a high-volume caseload, prioritize competing deadlines, and work independently.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills with a commitment to exceptional customer service.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Office and claims management systems.
  • Understanding of information security, confidentiality, and SOC 2 compliance practices.

Occasional travel may be required for depositions, mediations, trials, training, or other business needs. Additional licensing may be required based on business needs.

Why Vanguard?

Join a team that values technical expertise, collaboration, accountability, and exceptional client service. At Vanguard, you will have the opportunity to contribute to a growing organization where your experience and attention to detail make a difference.

Interested in joining our team?

We'd love to hear from you!

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Property Claims Examiner (Lloyds experienced)
Property Claims Examiner (Lloyds experienced)

Vanguard Claims Administration • Woodbury (NJ)

Remote
USD 65,000 - 95,000
Liability Claims Examiner
Liability Claims Examiner

Vanguard Claims Administration • Woodbury (NJ)

Remote
USD 65,000 - 90,000
Liability Supervisor
Liability Supervisor

Vanguard Claims Administration • Woodbury (NJ)

Remote
USD 95,000 - 125,000
Property Claims Examiner: Investigate, Evaluate & Settle
Property Claims Examiner: Investigate, Evaluate & Settle

Vanguard Claims Administration • Woodbury (NJ)

On-site
USD 65,000 - 90,000
Independent Property Field Adjuster (1099 Contractor) ? Daily & CAT Claims | Massachusetts
Independent Property Field Adjuster (1099 Contractor) ? Daily & CAT Claims | Massachusetts

Vanguard Claims Administration • Plymouth (MA)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Senior Claims Specialist, Property Claims
Senior Claims Specialist, Property Claims

Vantage Risk Companies • Chicago (IL)

Hybrid
USD 115,000 - 140,000
Independent Property Field Adjuster ? Daily & CAT Claims |Nebraska
Independent Property Field Adjuster ? Daily & CAT Claims |Nebraska

Vanguard Claims Administration • Lexington (NE)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 85,000
Property Adjuster (remote)
Property Adjuster (remote)

Vault Risk Management Services, LLC • New York (NY)

Remote
USD 90,000 - 135,000
FSA & HSA
Life & Disability
401(k) plan
+2
Senior Claims Specialist, Property Claims
Senior Claims Specialist, Property Claims

Vantage Risk Ltd. • Chicago (IL)

Hybrid
USD 115,000 - 140,000
Bonus potential
Health benefits
Retirement plan with company match
+1
Liability Claims Investigator
Liability Claims Investigator

Vanguard-Claims-Administration • Woodbury (NJ)

Remote
USD 65,000 - 90,000