Nighttime Team Member (Shifts after 4pm)

Potbelly Sandwich Works; Noblesville (IN); On-site; USD 21,000 - 22,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Medical Insurance

Dental Insurance

Vision Insurance

Domestic Partnership

Parental Leave

FSA/HSA

Commuter Benefit

401(k) match

Employee Assistance Program

Paid Time Off

Discount Program

Flexible Schedule

Career growth

Job summary

Potbelly Sandwich Works in Noblesville, IN is seeking Team Members to work in a fast-paced, customer-focused environment. The role offers evening/night shifts after 4pm, with pay transparency of $15.25–$15.75 per hour plus tips.

Enjoy benefits like medical, dental, vision, paid parental leave, 401(k) with company match, and flexible scheduling. Responsibilities include operating multiple stations, maintaining health standards, restocking, preparing sandwiches and desserts, and handling cash.

Qualifications

• Minimum age 16 years.
• Friendly, customer-first mindset in a fast-paced environment.
• Strong written and verbal communication skills.
• Able to stand/walk 3+ hours and lift up to 50 pounds.
• Ability to manage allergens (peanut, dairy, gluten etc.).
• Illinois applicants must be food safety certified within 30 days of employment.

Responsibilities

• Operate multiple stations as directed by a Shift Leader or Manager.
• Follow health, safety, and cleanliness standards.
• Restock food line, chips, and cooler.
• Prepare sandwiches, salads, soups, cookies, and ice cream.
• Use a slicer if 18 or older.
• Clean and sanitize work areas and equipment.
• Handle cash and balance tills.
• Address customer questions and concerns.
• Take delivery/catering/pickup orders by phone.

Skills

Customer service

Communication skills

Team player

Knife skills

Allergen management

Stamina

Teen eligibility 16+

Tools

Point-of-sale systems

Job description

PAY TRANSPARENCY: earn between $15.25 and $15.75 plus digital tips!*

Do you hunger for more? Potbelly Sandwich Shop is looking for friendly and outgoing people who enjoy working in a fast-paced, friendly environment. We are where good vibes and great careers are a way of life! What started as a small antique store in 1977 has become a nationally recognized neighborhood sandwich shop with over 400 locations across the United States. But toasty sandwiches are only as good as the people behind them. And yeah, we've got the best. Ready to join our growing Potbelly Nation?

What's In It For You**:

• Competitive pay!
• Medical, Dental & Vision Insurance
• Domestic Partnership Benefits
• Paid Parental Leave
• FSA and HSA with Employer Contribution
• Commuter Benefit Program
• Retirement Savings 401(k) with company match
• Employee Assistance Program
• Paid Time Off
• Discount Program
• Flexible Work Schedule
• Career growth opportunities
• If hired, you must meet and maintain all eligibility requirements to qualify**

Schedule

We're hiring Team Members available for evening and night shifts starting after 4pm. Join our team to help close the shop, serve customers, plus keep the energy & good vibes going until the end of the day!

What You Bring To The Table

• you are at least 16 years of age
• A friendly, customer-first mindset with the ability to thrive in a fast-paced, energetic environment
• You have strong written and verbal communication skills
• Comfortable working in a bustling kitchen environment (knife skills are a big plus!)
• You can manage potential allergens: peanut products, egg, dairy, gluten, soy, seafood and shellfish
• You're a team player
• You're able to stand/walk a minimum of 3 hours or as needed
• You're able to lift up to 10 pounds frequently and up to 50 pounds occasionally
• Illinois Applicants - all IL employees are required to become food safety certified within 30 days of employment.

Job Duties And Functions

• Work multiple stations (load, dress, shakes, cash, prep, front) as directed by a Shift Leader or Manager.
• Comply with health and safety standards for food, cleanliness and safety
• Restock food line, chips and cooler
• Prepare quality finished products (sandwiches, salads, soups, cookies, ice cream, etc.) efficiently
• If 18 or older, use of the automatic slicer to prep food items
• Clean tables, counters, floors, bathrooms, kitchen and utensils; take out trash
• Operate cash register: handle, balance and follow all cash handling procedures
• Effectively handle customer complaints/issues
• Takes delivery/catering/pickup orders over the phone
• Other duties as assigned

Disclaimers

• Potbelly cannot make guarantees about tip earnings*

At Potbelly, we are committed to creating a welcoming and respectful environment where individuals are valued for their unique perspectives, backgrounds, and strengths. We believe that inclusion, collaboration, and mutual respect enhance the way we serve our customers and work together as a team. All employment decisions are based on qualifications, merit, and business need.

We're an equal opportunity employer. Each applicant will be considered for employment without regard to race, color, religion, disability, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, veteran status, or any other basis protected by applicable federal, state or local law.

Potbelly Sandwich Works may use artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted tools as part of its hiring and recruitment process. These tools may collect and analyze data including questionnaire and assessment responses, resume content, and professional profile information. AI-assisted tools are used for all position types. All final employment decisions are made by people. Potbelly may also use additional AI-assisted tools from time to time in its hiring process.

If you have questions about how AI is used in connection with your application, or if you would like to request a reasonable accommodation related to the use of AI in the hiring process, please contact [e-mail].

Application Deadline: Applications must be submitted by [10/12/2026] to be considered for this position. The posting may close earlier if a suitable candidate is selected before the deadline.