Manager I, Trust & Safety - Incident Operations

Thumbtack

United States

Remote

USD 74,000 - 112,000

Full time

4 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Thumbtack is seeking a Trust and Safety Incident Operations Manager to lead a team of 6-10 specialists resolving escalated incidents between customers and pros, including billing disputes, safety concerns, and Thumbtack Guarantee payouts.

You will coach for fairness, uphold quality and speed, and model AI-driven workflows while owning outcomes. This role emphasizes hiring, process improvements, and cross-functional alignment.

Qualifications

  • 2+ years of experience in customer experience, trust and safety, risk, claims, or customer support operations, preferably at a marketplace or high-volume consumer platform.
  • 4+ years of direct people management with coaching and 1:1s.
  • Experience with escalated disputes, mediation, claims, or complex case management.
  • Ability to read data for trends, root causes, and act on findings beyond reporting.
  • Experience leading process improvements with cross-functional partners (Product, Operations, Policy, Engineering).
  • Clear, empathetic communication and resilience under pressure.
  • Hands-on use of AI tools and advocating responsible adoption.

Responsibilities

  • Lead and develop your team through regular 1:1s and development plans.
  • Hold team accountable for SLA, quality, and CSAT; coach on gaps.
  • Set direction, distribute work, and manage workload norms.
  • Mitigate risk on escalated incidents with financial/legal implications.
  • Lead your team's use of AI and ensure ownership of decisions and payouts.
  • Collaborate with Program Managers, Business Applications, and senior leadership on improvements.
  • Participate in hiring and onboarding and maintain a safe, inclusive team.

Skills

People management
Customer experience
Dispute handling
Data-driven decision making
AI tooling usage
Quality & process improvement
Cross-functional collaboration

Job description

Thumbtack helps millions of people confidently care for their homes.

Thumbtack is the one app you need to take care of and improve your home — from personalized guidance to AI tools and a best-in-class hiring experience. Every day in every county of the U.S., people turn to Thumbtack to complete urgent repairs, seasonal maintenance and bigger improvements. We help homeowners know which projects to do, when to do them and who to hire from our growing community of 300,000 local service businesses. If making an impact inspires you, join us. Imagine what we'll build together.

About the Trust & Safety Incident Operations Team

We're a high-performing, thoughtful team that resolves escalated incidents between customers and pros with care, while safeguarding the Thumbtack brand. Our mission is to deliver a safe, seamless, and high-quality experience for everyone involved. We partner closely with cross-functional teams to improve the customer journey and drive Trust and Safety forward on Thumbtack.

About the role

As a Trust and Safety Incident Operations Manager, you'll lead a team of 6-10 specialists who resolve escalated incidents between customers and pros, including billing and payment disputes, property damage, theft, mild safety concerns, and Thumbtack Guarantee claims. You'll coach your team to fair, defensible outcomes, hold a high bar on quality and speed, and be the escalation point for their hardest cases. AI is a core part of how this work gets done, and you'll model it, coach it, and own the judgment behind it. Your team's success is your success.

What you'll do
  • Lead and develop your team through regular 1:1s, direct and timely feedback, and up-to-date development plans that support each person’s career goals.

  • Hold your team accountable for SLA, quality, and CSAT, catching gaps and outliers early and coaching to them.

  • Set clear direction, distribute work that challenges people, set workload norms, and remove obstacles.

  • Mitigate risk on escalated incidents, including matters with financial and legal implications and Thumbtack Guarantee payouts.

  • Lead your team’s use of AI: coach each specialist to the expectations for their level, build buy-in, watch for emerging risks, and make sure a person owns every decision, payout, and message.

  • Lead process improvements with Program Managers, Business Applications, and senior leadership.

  • Take part in hiring and onboarding, build a safe and inclusive team, and stay calibrated with peer managers and cross-functional partners.

In order to be successful, you must bring
  • 2+ years of experience in customer experience, trust and safety, risk, claims, or customer support operations, preferably at a marketplace or high-volume consumer platform.

  • 4+ years of direct people management. That means giving clear, timely feedback, coaching people through performance gaps, running productive 1:1s, and helping team members grow into their next role.

  • Hands-on experience with escalated disputes, mediation, claims, or complex case management. You've handled financially or legally sensitive matters, can sort out conflicting accounts, make fair decisions with incomplete information, and know when to bring in Legal, Finance, or leadership.

  • Comfort running a team on metrics like SLA, QA, CSAT, and productivity. You can read the data to find trends, root causes, and early warning signs, and turn what you find into action instead of just reporting it.

  • A track record of leading process improvements with cross-functional partners such as Product, Operations, Policy, and Engineering, from finding the problem through rollout and measuring the impact.

  • Clear, empathetic communication that fits the audience, whether that’s an upset customer, a frontline agent, or a senior stakeholder. You also bring resilience under pressure, a sense of urgency, and full ownership of outcomes.

  • Hands-on use of AI tools in your daily work, along with real interest in helping your team adopt tools responsibly to improve quality, consistency, and efficiency.

  • Sound judgment and discretion with confidential information, sensitive customer data, and high-stakes decisions.

Expected salary ranges
  • For candidates living in San Francisco / Bay Area, San Jose, New York City, or Seattle metros, the expected total cash compensation (base salary + variable pay, if applicable) range for the role is currently $86,700 - $112,200

  • For candidates living in Austin, TX or Washington DC metros or in California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, or Washington states, the expected total cash compensation (base salary + variable pay, if applicable) range for the role is currently $78,200 - $101,200

  • For candidates living in all other US locations, the expected total cash compensation (base salary + variable pay, if applicable) range for this role is currently $74,000 - $95,700

Actual offered salaries will vary and will be based on various factors, such as calibrated job level, qualifications, skills, competencies, and proficiency for the role.

Thumbtack embraces diversity. We are proud to be an equal opportunity workplace and do not discriminate on the basis of sex, race, color, age, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, religion, national origin, ancestry, citizenship, marital status, military or veteran status, genetic information, disability status, or any other characteristic protected by federal, provincial, state, or local law. We also will consider for employment qualified applicants with arrest and conviction records, consistent with applicable law.

Thumbtack is committed to working with and providing reasonable accommodation to individuals with disabilities. If you would like to request a reasonable accommodation for a medical condition or disability during any part of the application process, please contact: recruitingops@thumbtack.com.

For information about how Thumbtack collects, uses, and shares personal information about job applicants, please see our Job Applicant Privacy Policy.

We put as much craftsmanship into candidate safety as we do into the hiring experience itself. While scammers may try to impersonate our team, we'll never ask you for money, banking info, or SSNs during hiring. Check out our blueprint on how to spot the fakes.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Manager, Data Engineering
Manager, Data Engineering

Thumbtack • San Francisco (CA)

On-site
USD 235,000 - 304,000
Manager, Operational Foundations
Manager, Operational Foundations

Thumbtack • San Francisco (CA)

On-site
USD 153,000 - 198,000
Manager I, Trust & Safety - Incident Operations Virtual, United States Trust and Safety
Manager I, Trust & Safety - Incident Operations Virtual, United States Trust and Safety

Thumbtack • United States

Remote
USD 74,000 - 96,000
Remote work stipend
Parental leave
Thumbtack Bucks
Director, Sales Strategy & Operations
Director, Sales Strategy & Operations

Thumbtack • United States

Hybrid
USD 194,000 - 251,000
Full-Stack Engineer, AI Platform
Full-Stack Engineer, AI Platform

Devconnectplatform • United States

Remote
USD 151,000 - 196,000
Remote work
Competitive pay
Sr. Manager, Success Operations
Sr. Manager, Success Operations

Thumbtack • United States

On-site
USD 161,500 - 209,000
Product Manager, Pro Integrations & Foundations
Product Manager, Pro Integrations & Foundations

Thumbtack • San Francisco (CA)

Hybrid
USD 201,000 - 260,000
Sr. Manager, Success Operations
Sr. Manager, Success Operations

Thumbtack • San Francisco (CA)

On-site
USD 190,000 - 246,000
Senior Software Engineer, Developer Experience
Senior Software Engineer, Developer Experience

Software • United States

Remote
USD 179,000 - 232,000
Senior Software Engineer, Developer Experience
Senior Software Engineer, Developer Experience

Thumbtack • United States

Remote
USD 179,000 - 273,000