Litigation Supervisor

Amtex Insurance & Constitution General Agency; Town of Texas (WI); On-site; USD 90,000 - 110,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

401(k) matching

Dental insurance

Health insurance

Paid time off

Vision insurance

Job summary

Amtex Insurance & Constitution General Agency seeks a Litigation Supervisor to oversee litigated claims, lead Examiners, and coordinate defense counsel with a focus on timely, accurate, and compliant resolution.

The role requires active Texas adjuster license or ability to obtain one, and a minimum of five years in bodily injury or litigated auto claims. Strong communication and leadership are essential.

Qualifications

• Active Texas Adjuster License or ability to obtain one.
• At least 5 years of claims experience, preferably in bodily injury and/or litigated auto claims.
• Strong knowledge of liability, damages, negotiations, litigation, and reserving.
• Strong communication, organization, analytical, and decision-making skills.
• Ability to manage multiple deadlines in a high-volume environment.

Responsibilities

• Oversee the litigation inventory and ensure timely suit referrals, deadlines, hearings, mediations, and trials.
• Monitor complex, aging, and high-exposure claims and escalate significant issues to Claims Management.
• Review liability, damages, coverage, reserves, evaluations, and settlement strategies.
• Guide examiners on litigation strategy, negotiations, and claim resolution.
• Manage relationships and performance of defense counsel.
• Conduct file reviews to ensure accurate documentation, compliance, and proper claim handling.
• Monitor reserves and exposure and ensure updates after significant claim developments.
• Ensure files are prepared for mediations and trials.
• Provide daily leadership, coaching, training, and performance management to Litigation Examiners.
• Monitor inventory, deadlines, settlement opportunities, counsel reporting, and examiner activities.
• Promote accountability, productivity, professional communication, and timely claim resolution.

Skills

Texas Adjuster License

Claims experience

Liability knowledge

Negotiation skills

Communication skills

Job description

Benefits:

• 401(k) matching
• Dental insurance
• Health insurance
• Paid time off
• Vision insurance

Position Summary

The Litigation Supervisor oversees the daily management of litigated claims, providing leadership and technical guidance to Litigation Examiners. This role ensures claims are handled timely, accurately, strategically, and in compliance with company guidelines and applicable regulations. The Supervisor also manages defense counsel, litigation expenses, reserves, evaluations, settlements, mediations, trials, and high-exposure matters.

Essential Duties & Responsibilities

• Oversee the litigation inventory and ensure timely suit referrals, deadlines, hearings, mediations, and trials.
• Monitor complex, aging, and high-exposure claims and escalated significant issues to Claims Management.
• Review liability, damages, coverage, reserves, evaluations, and settlement strategies.
• Guide examiners on litigation strategy, negotiations, and claim resolution.
• Manage relationships and performance of defense counsel.
• Conduct file reviews to ensure accurate documentation, compliance, and proper claim handling.
• Monitor reserves and exposure and ensure updates are made following significant claim developments.
• Ensure files are prepared for mediations and trials.
• Provide daily leadership, coaching, training, and performance management to Litigation Examiners.
• Monitor inventory, deadlines, settlement opportunities, counsel reporting, and examiner activities.
• Promote accountability, productivity, professional communication, and timely claim resolution.

Qualifications

Required:

• Active Texas Adjuster License or ability to obtain one.
• At least 5 years of claims experience, preferably in bodily injury and/or litigated auto claims.
• Strong knowledge of liability, damages, negotiations, litigation, and reserving.
• Strong communication, organization, analytical, and decision-making skills.
• Ability to manage multiple deadlines in a high-volume environment.

Preferred:

• Prior supervisory or claims leadership experience.
• Texas nonstandard personal auto experience.
• Experience managing defense counsel, mediations, depositions, trials, and high-exposure claims.

Core Competencies

• Leadership and accountability
• Litigation knowledge and strategy
• Analytical and sound decision-making
• Communication and organization
• Risk awareness and escalation
• Strategic claim management

The Litigation Supervisor should understand the exposure, defense strategy, claim value, barriers to resolution, and next steps for every litigated claim.

Compensation: $90,000.00 - $110,000.00 per year

At Amtex Insurance, we’ve provided affordable auto, renters, commercial, and Mexico insurance across Texas for over 25 years. Founded in 1999 as a small family business, we’ve grown into a statewide name with more than 85 locations. We’re known for our competitive rates, exceptional service, and strong community involvement, making us a trusted choice for reliable coverage. To file a claim, get a quote, or learn more about us, visit our website or call our customer service team.