Insurance Service Agent - Genstone

Genstone Companies

Tampa (FL)

Hybrid

USD 45,000 - 55,000

Full time

14 days+

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
Pet Insurance
401k with Employer Matching
Paid Holidays
Wellness Initiatives
Employee Assistance Program
Hybrid Work Schedule with Remote Flex

Job summary

Genstone is seeking an Insurance Sales Manager to lead and meet sales targets while maintaining policyholder coverage and retention. Reporting to the AVP, Insurance Sales Manager, you will drive customer service excellence across calls, emails, and in-person interactions.

The role requires a valid General Lines License and experience in commercial insurance sales, with a track record in agency relationships and utilization of Agency Raters/ACORD forms.

Qualifications

  • Active General Lines License with ability to sell Commercial policies and acquire additional state licenses as needed.
  • 2+ years’ experience servicing commercial insurance policies.
  • 2+ years’ experience in sales with a proven track record of success.
  • 2+ years’ experience with Agency Management Software Agency Raters, ACORD forms, and related insurance technology.
  • 1+ years’ experience in a call center environment, preferably in the Insurance Marketplace.
  • Knowledge of independent agency insurance principles and processes for customer service, needs assessments, and policy retention.
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills.

Responsibilities

  • Meet individual sales targets and agency retention requirements.
  • Provide exceptional customer service via phone, email, or in person.
  • Maintain existing policyholders’ coverage while promoting additional coverage/services.

Skills

General Lines License
Commercial insurance
Sales experience
Agency Management Software
ACORD forms
Call center experience
Communication skills
Interpersonal skills
Agile / learning agility
Data analysis

Education

Bachelor’s degree in business or related field
Equivalent experience with HS diploma / GED

Tools

Agency Raters
ACORD forms

Job description

Genstone is the holding company within The Fay Group, providing a broad suite of property services solutions to homeowners and real estate investment services to institutional clients nationwide.

Built on a foundation of integration and execution, Genstone delivers turnkey support for property acquisition, improvement, and performance optimization. Its services are aligned to serve the full lifecycle of a real estate investment – whether for individual investors or large-scale portfolios – ensuring efficiency, transparency, and long-term value creation. By leveraging shared resources across The Fay Group, including legal, compliance, and technology infrastructure, Genstone provides scalable solutions that adapt to dynamic market conditions and help maximize asset returns for both homeowners and clients.

Reporting to the AVP, Insurance Sales Manager, this position is responsible for meeting individual sales targets and agency retention requirements. This role will ensure exceptional customer service is provided to all clients through any interaction via phone, email, or in person. The role is responsible for maintaining existing policy holder’s coverage while also looking to promote additional coverage/services where necessary.

Qualifications Include:

  • Bachelor’s degree in business or related field (or equivalent combination of years of experience with High School diploma/GED)
  • Must possess an active General Lines License with the ability to sell Commercial policies and be willing to acquire additional state licenses as needed
  • 2+ years’ experience in servicing commercial insurance policies
  • 2+ years’ experience in sales with a proven track record of success
  • 2+ years’ experience with Agency Management Software Agency Raters, ACORD forms, and related insurance technology
  • 1+ years’ experience in a call center environment, preferably in the Insurance Marketplace
  • Commercial new Business and renewal experience preferred
  • Knowledge of independent agency insurance principles and processes for providing customer and personal services including customer needs assessments, meeting quality standards for service, customer satisfaction, and policy retention
  • Knowledge of principles and methods for processing insurance policy endorsements, renewals, and addendums
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills
  • Strong interpersonal skills
  • Collaborative work style; high team-orientation
  • Open to change; agile; high learning agility
  • Strong analytical skills coupled with sound judgement
  • Strong problem solving abilities
  • Ability to analyze and interpret data to identify opportunities and propose solutions
  • Strong attention to detail; strong compliance orientation; high quality of work product
  • Ability to prioritize; effective time management
  • Self-directed; ability to proactively ask questions and surface issues/ concerns
  • Professional maturity, integrity, ability to maintain confidential data and information
  • Strong business acumen; strong fiscal and technical aptitude
  • Strong skills in MS Word, Excel, and PowerPoint

Featured Benefits

  • Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
  • Company Paid Life Insurance
  • Disability Insurance
  • Pet Insurance
  • 401k Program with Employer Matching
  • Paid Holidays
  • Wellness Initiatives
  • Employee Assistance Program
  • Eligible for Hybrid Work Schedule with Remote Flex Days

Compensation

  • The hiring rate for this position is $50.000.00 annually
  • This position is eligible for an additional monthly incentive

Fay Cares!

The Fay-Genstone Foundation was established to fulfill the philanthropic mission of The Fay Group employees to serve the communities in which they live and work. Our employees make voluntary contributions to the Foundation. Each quarter, their contributions are donated to organizations focused on improving education opportunities, combating poverty, and supporting military service members and first responders.

At Fay, we believe that the best ideas come from having a team that is diverse in backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives. We strive to ensure each of our employees feels valued, respected and included, and is presented with equal opportunities to be successful. Fay is an equal-opportunity workplace. The Fay Group and affiliated companies participate in E-Verify. For more information go to www.dhs.gov/E-Verify .

Equal Opportunity Employer This employer is required to notify all applicants of their rights pursuant to federal employment laws.For further information, please review the Know Your Rights notice from the Department of Labor.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Insurance Service Agent - Genstone
Insurance Service Agent - Genstone

Genstone Management, LLC • United States

On-site
USD 45,000 - 55,000
Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5
Insurance Agent - Genstone
Insurance Agent - Genstone

Genstone Companies • United States

Remote
USD 43,000 - 53,000
Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5
Insurance Agent - Genstone
Insurance Agent - Genstone

Genstone Companies • Tampa (FL)

Hybrid
USD 43,000 - 53,000
Medical Insurance
Dental Insurance
Vision Insurance
+8
Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent

Genstone Insurance • Farmers Branch (TX)

On-site
USD 41,000 - 55,000
Medical, Dental, and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5
Insurance Agent
Insurance Agent

Genstone Insurance • United States

Hybrid
USD 43,000 - 53,000
Medical, Dental, Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5
Insurance Service Agent
Insurance Service Agent

Genstone Insurance • Tampa (FL)

On-site
USD 52,000 - 90,000
Medical, Dental, and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5
BPL Account Executive Inside Sales
BPL Account Executive Inside Sales

Fay Group • United States

Remote
USD 22,000 - 31,000
Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5
BPL Account Executive Inside Sales
BPL Account Executive Inside Sales

Genstone Companies • Tampa (FL)

On-site
USD 22,000 - 31,000
Medical/Dental/Vision
Company-paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+6
Property Preservation Specialist
Property Preservation Specialist

Genstone Management, LLC • Canal Fulton (OH)

On-site
USD 23,000 - 30,000
Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
401k with Employer Matching
Paid Holidays
+2
BPL Account Executive Inside Sales
BPL Account Executive Inside Sales

FAY Financial, LLC • Tampa (FL)

Hybrid
USD 22,000 - 31,000
Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance
Company Paid Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
+5