Insurance Inside Sales Manager - Hybrid - Richmond, VA

Virginia Farm Bureau

Virginia

Hybrid

USD 80,000 - 100,000

Full time

10 days ago

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Virginia Farm Bureau is seeking an Inside Sales Manager to lead a new high-growth inside sales division in the online insurance space. The role is hybrid, based out of Richmond, VA, with a Monday–Friday schedule and flexible hours.

A Property & Casualty license is required to manage and quote insurance products. The successful candidate will recruit, train, and coach a high-performing team, develop playbooks, and drive substantial pipeline results across multiple channels.

Qualifications

  • Must-Haves: Active Property and Casualty insurance license (required).
  • Proven inside sales management experience with a track record of building winning teams.
  • Strong knowledge of insurance products, policy contracts, and underwriting guidelines.
  • Exceptional leadership, coaching, and team development skills.

Responsibilities

  • Recruit and develop your own inside sales team focused on Property & Casualty insurance.
  • Create the playbook — develop sales strategies, scripts, and workflows that drive results.
  • Coach to excellence — mentor your team to exceed targets and deliver exceptional customer experiences.
  • Manage the complete sales pipeline from initial lead to closed sale (post-sale servicing handled by our support teams).
  • Engage prospects across multiple channels: inbound/outbound phone, email, chat, and text.
  • Meet and exceed aggressive monthly sales targets for both personal and team performance.
  • Monitor KPIs and deliver actionable insights to leadership.
  • Partner with marketing and operations to maximize lead generation campaigns.
  • Navigate multiple systems seamlessly to ensure smooth customer interactions.
  • Ensure full compliance with underwriting guidelines, policy contracts, and state regulations.
  • Leverage CRM and sales tools to optimize team performance and efficiency.

Skills

Inside sales mgmt
Leadership
Coaching
Team development
Communication

Tools

HubSpot CRM
Microsoft Outlook
Slack/Teams
Applied Rater

Job description

JOB TITLE: Inside Sales Manager
STATUS: Exempt
COMPENSATION RANGE: $80,000 - $100,000 annual salary plus bonus
LOCATION: Hybrid work arrangement, based out of Richmond, VA
SCHEDULE: Monday - Friday, Flexible hours required

License Requirement: Active Property and Casualty insurance license required

Build Something Big From the Ground Up

Virginia Farm Bureau is experiencing explosive growth in our online insurance division, and we need an exceptional leader to capitalize on this momentum. This isn't just another management role—this is your opportunity to build and lead an entire inside sales team in the fastest growing sector of our organization.

The demand is already there. High-volume quote requests are pouring in from online seekers ready to buy. Now we need YOU to build the team and run this exciting new division.

Why This Role is Different
  • Brand New Position - Shape this division your way from day one
  • Proven Demand - High volume of qualified prospects already seeking quotes
  • Growth Trajectory - Join our fastest expanding business sector
  • Leadership Opportunity - Build your own high-performing team
  • Career Path - Ground floor opportunity in a rapidly scaling division
What You Will Do
Build & Lead
  • Recruit and develop your own inside sales team focused on Property & Casualty insurance
  • Create the playbook - develop sales strategies, scripts, and workflows that drive results
  • Coach to excellence - mentor your team to exceed targets and deliver exceptional customer experiences
Drive Results
  • Manage the complete sales pipeline from initial lead to closed sale (post-sale servicing handled by our support teams)
  • Engage prospects across multiple channels: inbound/outbound phone, email, chat, and text
  • Meet and exceed aggressive monthly sales targets for both personal and team performance
  • Monitor KPIs and deliver actionable insights to leadership
Strategize & Optimize
  • Partner with marketing and operations to maximize lead generation campaigns
  • Navigate multiple systems seamlessly to ensure smooth customer interactions
  • Ensure full compliance with underwriting guidelines, policy contracts, and state regulations
  • Leverage CRM and sales tools to optimize team performance and efficiency
What You Bring
Must-Haves
  • Active Property and Casualty insurance license (required)
  • Proven inside sales management experience with a track record of building winning teams
  • Strong knowledge of insurance products, policy contracts, and underwriting guidelines
  • Exceptional leadership, coaching, and team development skills
Your Superpowers
  • Outstanding communication, negotiation, and interpersonal abilities
  • Thrives in fast-paced, goal-oriented environments
  • Tech-savvy: proficient with HubSpot CRM, Microsoft Outlook, collaboration tools (Slack/Teams), and quoting platforms including Applied Rater
  • Ability to juggle multiple systems and applications while maintaining excellent customer interactions
Ready to Build Something Extraordinary?

If you're an ambitious sales leader looking for more than just a job—if you want to create a legacy, build a team, and ride the wave of our fastest growing division,we want to hear from you.

Join Virginia Farm Bureau and help secure the future of our clients while building your own.

Virginia Farm Bureau is committed to helping our clients protect what matters most. Now we're looking for someone who can help us scale that mission to meet unprecedented demand.

At VA Farm Bureau, we provide an exceptional benefits package, including ongoing job development and support in all roles, paid training and continuing education reimbursement, medical and dental insurance available on your first day, generous employee 401K contribution, excellent Paid Time off (PTO) plan and more!

Virginia Farm Bureau Companies provide equal employment opportunity in all aspects of employment without regard to race, color, national origin, religion, gender, pregnancy, age, disability, orientation or veteran status.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Insurance Inside Sales Manager
Insurance Inside Sales Manager

Virginia Farm Bureau Family of Companies • Richmond (VA)

Hybrid
USD 80,000 - 100,000
Medical and dental insurance on first/
401(k) with employer contribution
Paid time off
+2
Insurance Inside Sales Manager
Insurance Inside Sales Manager

Virginia Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance • Richmond (VA)

Hybrid
USD 80,000 - 100,000
Medical and dental insurance on first/
Bonus potential
Paid training
Inside Sales Manager: Build & Lead P&C Team (Hybrid)
Inside Sales Manager: Build & Lead P&C Team (Hybrid)

Virginia Farm Bureau • Virginia

Hybrid
USD 80,000 - 100,000
Insurance Sales Agent - Mechanicsville
Insurance Sales Agent - Mechanicsville

Virginia Farm Bureau Family of Companies • Mechanicsville (VA)

On-site
USD 40,000 - 70,000
Medical, vision and dental insurance from day one
Generous 401K program
Paid training and education reimbursement
+3
Insurance Sales Agent - King George County - King George, VA
Insurance Sales Agent - King George County - King George, VA

Virginia Farm Bureau Family of Companies • King George (VA)

On-site
USD 37,000 - 52,000
Comprehensive benefits
Generous paid time off
Sign-on bonus
Inside Insurance Sales Leader — Build & Scale Team (Hybrid)
Inside Insurance Sales Leader — Build & Scale Team (Hybrid)

Virginia Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance • Richmond (VA)

Hybrid
USD 80,000 - 100,000
Medical and dental insurance on first/
Bonus potential
Paid training
Insurance Sales Agent - Bedford, VA
Insurance Sales Agent - Bedford, VA

Virginia Farm Bureau Family of Companies • Bedford (VA)

On-site
USD 40,000 - 60,000
Comprehensive benefits including medical, vision, and dental insurance
Generous paid time off
Exclusive sign-on bonus
Insurance Sales Agent- Mechanicsville, VA
Insurance Sales Agent- Mechanicsville, VA

Virginia Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance • Mechanicsville (VA)

On-site
USD 52,000 - 125,000
Medical, Vision and Dental Insurance
401(k) with employer contribution
3 weeks of Paid Time Off
+3
Insurance Sales Agent - Westmoreland County - Montross, VA
Insurance Sales Agent - Westmoreland County - Montross, VA

Virginia Farm Bureau Family of Companies • Montross (VA)

On-site
USD 37,000 - 125,000
Comprehensive Benefits
Paid Time Off
Sign-On Bonus
Insurance Sales Agent: Unlimited Earnings & Training
Insurance Sales Agent: Unlimited Earnings & Training

Countryway Insurance Co. • Virginia

Hybrid
USD 37,000 - 125,000
Comprehensive Benefits
Paid Time Off
Sign-On Bonus
+1