Individual Membership Manager

Stagetime Inc.

New York (NY)

Hybrid

USD 63,000 - 67,000

Full time

10 days ago

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Health and dental coverage
Pension
Paid time off
Remote work days

Job summary

OPERA America, the national nonprofit service organization for opera, seeks a mid-level fundraiser to manage its $250,000 portfolio of 2,500+ individual members and mid-range donors. The Individual Membership Manager oversees direct mail, gift entry/acknowledgment, member stewardship, frontline service, and select special events, including 6–8 per year at the National Opera Center.

The role reports to the Director of Development and Membership and requires strong project management, data

Qualifications

  • Experience in membership, annual giving, and related fundraising areas.
  • Strong project management, organizational, and deadline-driven abilities.
  • Proficient in donor databases and data-driven stewardship.
  • Excellent communication skills for phone, email, and in-person interactions.

Responsibilities

  • Direct Mail: oversee renewal, cultivation, acquisition, acknowledgment, and stewardship programs.
  • Gift Entry/Acknowledgment: manage gift processing and acknowledgments with a shared coordinator support.
  • Member Stewardship: run programs like Report from the Field and National Opera Trustee Recognition Awards.
  • Frontline Service: provide member/donor support via phone, email, and in person at events.
  • Special Events: plan and support 6–8 events yearly at the National Opera Center and more during the annual conference.

Skills

Project management
Data analysis
Fundraising
Membership management

Tools

DonorPerfect
Tessitura
Raiser’s Edge

Job description

OPERA America, the national nonprofit service organization for opera, headquartered at the National Opera Center in midtown New York City, seeks a mid-level fundraiser to manage the organization’s $250,000 portfolio of 2,500+ individual members and mid-range donors.

The Individual Membership Manager is responsible for managing OPERA America’s development efforts, including:

  • 1. Direct Mail – They oversee and execute the organization’s systems for renewal, cultivation, acquisition, acknowledgment, and stewardship through a comprehensive direct mail program.
  • 2. Gift Entry/Acknowledgment – They manage and process gift entry, generate acknowledgments, and oversee other renewal systems, with support from a shared coordinator.
  • 3. Member Stewardship – They manage and execute a variety of member programs, including the Report from the Field, New Work Catalog, National Opera Trustee Recognition Awards, and others.
  • 4. Frontline Service – They provide frontline customer service to members and mid-range donors over the phone, by email, and in‑person at events.
  • 5. Special Events – They plan, support, and/or run select special events for members, donors, and guests, including those alongside public programs at the National Opera Center (6‒8 per year); and additional multiday events at the annual conference and in New York City.

The Manager works with and reports to the Director of Development and Membership, who manages donors of $500+; and a shared Member Services Coordinator.

The successful candidate will:

  • Be an organized, process‑oriented, and goal‑driven project manager, able to lead a project from start to finish.
  • Be self‑motivated and resourceful, especially in looking for ways to grow and add value to the membership.
  • Have experience in mail merge, Microsoft Excel, and database software (e.g. DonorPerfect, Tessitura, Raisers Edge, etc.)
  • Be collaborative in working with colleagues across the organization.
  • Demonstrate professional communications with a variety of audiences over the phone, by email, and in person, as well as in written appeals and promotions.
  • Be data‑fluent, metrics‑oriented, and efficiency‑minded.
  • Demonstrate accomplishments in membership, annual giving, and/or related areas of fundraising or sales either through prior job experience and/or educational degrees.

The Manager position is based in‑person at OPERA America’s New York City offices, with the flexibility of 90 work‑from‑home days to use throughout the year with occasional limitations. The Manager will participate in occasional evening/weekend duties for events (approx. 10‑15 per year) and may need to travel to attend the annual Opera Conference (week‑long travel).

SALARY RANGE: $62,500 - $67,000

Benefits package including health and dental coverage, pension, paid time off, life insurance, an allocation of remote work days, access to rehearsal/performance venue, and opportunities to network with opera leaders nationwide.

Desired Start Date: April 14, 2025

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Hybrid Membership & Donor Relations Manager
Hybrid Membership & Donor Relations Manager

Stagetime Inc. • New York (NY)

Hybrid
USD 63,000 - 67,000
Health and dental coverage
Pension
Paid time off
+1
Director of Development (Part-Time leading to Full-Time, Remote)
Director of Development (Part-Time leading to Full-Time, Remote)

Opera Verace Foundation • United States

Remote
USD 60,000 - 65,000
Paid time off
Director of Development (Part-Time growing to Full-Time, Remote)
Director of Development (Part-Time growing to Full-Time, Remote)

OPERA America, Inc. • San Francisco (CA)

Hybrid
USD 60,000 - 65,000
Paid time off: 60 hours/year
Remote work
Associate Director of Individual Giving: Opera Philadelphia
Associate Director of Individual Giving: Opera Philadelphia

Bryn Mawr College • Bryn Mawr (PA)

On-site
USD 70,000 - 105,000
Philanthropy Officer
Philanthropy Officer

OPERA America, Inc. • San Francisco (CA)

On-site
USD 80,000 - 85,000
Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+1
Manager of Individual Giving
Manager of Individual Giving

Washington National Opera • Washington

On-site
USD 70,000 - 110,000
Leadership Philanthropy Officer (Producers Circle)
Leadership Philanthropy Officer (Producers Circle)

OPERA America, Inc. • San Francisco (CA)

On-site
USD 125,000 - 130,000
Medical insurance
Dental insurance
Vision insurance
+1
Philanthropy Officer
Philanthropy Officer

San Francisco Opera • San Francisco (CA)

On-site
USD 85,000 - 125,000
Donor Relation & Corporate Partnership Manager: Opera Philadelphia
Donor Relation & Corporate Partnership Manager: Opera Philadelphia

Bryn Mawr College • Bryn Mawr (PA)

On-site
USD 50,000 - 70,000
Director of Development
Director of Development

Stagetime Inc. • Portland (OR)

On-site
USD 99,000 - 121,000