Executive Pastor at First Alliance Church

The Christian and Missionary Alliance

Erie (Erie County)

On-site

USD 90,000 - 130,000

Full time

7 hours ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

Health insurance
Dental insurance
Vision benefits
403b Retirement Plan

Job summary

First Alliance Church in Erie, PA seeks an Executive Pastor to lead strategy, staff development, and operational excellence for a growing congregation of 600+ weekend attendees.

The XP will oversee budgets, HR, facilities and events, while building a culture of trust, collaboration, and gospel-centered leadership within FAC’s leadership teams.

Qualifications

  • Bachelor’s degree in Theology or closely related field from an accredited institution.
  • Proven leadership experience in a multi-staff church setting.
  • Experience in business and HR administration, budgeting and vendor relations.
  • Strong communication, management and organizational skills.
  • Passionate about reaching the lost and building healthy ministry teams.
  • Licensed or willing to be licensed with The Christian and Missionary Alliance; CMA licensing steps may apply.

Responsibilities

  • Provide strategic leadership to implement ministry strategies aligned with FAC’s mission.
  • Develop and mentor ministry staff, empowering pastors, directors, and coordinators.
  • Oversee ministry operations including budgets, HR, facilities, and events.
  • Maintain a strong relational presence with staff, volunteers, and congregants.
  • Contribute to a culture of excellence, accountability, and gospel-centered leadership.

Skills

Leadership experience
Communication skills
Management skills
Organizational skills
Church leadership
Strategic thinking

Education

Bachelor’s degree in Theology

Job description

Executive Pastor at First Alliance Church

We are seeking a high-capacity, spiritually mature leader to serve as the Executive Pastor (XP) at First Alliance Church in Erie, PA, (FAC) with an in-person weekend attendance of 600+ and growing.

The Executive Pastor will strengthen the health and effectiveness of the ministry through staff development, operational leadership, and ministry strategy implementation. Responsibilities include overseeing and developing church staff; creating systems; and implementing strategies for budgeting, administration and human resources (HR), buildings and grounds operations, and facility usage and events.

About First Alliance Church

For more than 125 years (1899) FAC has been a part of the Erie, PA community living out the mission and vision of the Christian and Missionary Alliance. With a commitment to the deeper life and missions endeavors, FAC has had a rich history of church growth, community impact, and sending workers into pastoral and missionary ministry. We have a high regard for our responsibility to steward our call in this community to be a church where people can BEGIN, BELONG, & BELIEVE.

Key Responsibilities
Strategic Leadership

You’re a strategic thinker who turns ideas into action. As the Executive Pastor (XP) you will help implement ministry strategies that align with FAC’s mission and vision. You will bring clarity, create alignment, and help FAC flourish in its next season of growth.

Ministry Staff Development & Oversight

You’re a leader of leaders who knows how to empower, coach, and hold staff accountable. As the XP, you will invest in the ministry team—pastors, directors, and coordinators—cultivating a culture marked by trust, collaboration, and gospel-centered purpose.

Ministry Operations & Systems

As the XP, you will build and maintain operations and systems that support sustainable and scalable ministry. This includes oversight of budgets, workplace administration/HR, general operations and events, weekend services, and facilities—ensuring that all operations support the overall mission and vision of the church without compromising spiritual depth.

Relational Presence & Leadership

You’re a visible, highly relational leader who builds strong connections with staff, volunteers, and congregants. The XP leads through influence, fosters unity, and will be a collaborative voice in the broader FAC leadership culture.

Culture Fit & Contribution

You thrive in a fast-paced, high-accountability, and Christ-centered church culture. As the XP, you value excellence, clear communication, measurable goals, and grace-filled leadership—while staying mission-focused and kingdom-minded.

  • Maintain an active and growing relationship with Jesus.
  • Serve as the primary support person and confidant to the Lead Pastor (Exodus 17:11-13; Exodus 18).
  • Be an active member of FAC Ministry Leadership Team (MLT).
  • Assist the Lead Pastor in the effective and timely implementation of FAC ' s overall ministry vision, ministry philosophy and FAC’s Christian values.
  • Assume responsibility for day-to-day operational and ministry tasks that do not require the Lead Pastor’s direct involvement. In doing so, preserve his connection to the staff’s personal and ministry journeys.
  • Represent the Lead Pastor, the staff, and FAC as needed/requested.
  • Pursue special projects under the direction of the Lead Pastor and serve as the champion and implementer of his agenda and objectives.
  • Provide staff development, pastoral care, counseling, and discipleship, to the ministry staff.
  • Serve as an Elder ex officio on the FAC governing Board of Elders, and will facilitate appropriate and adequate communication and connection between Elders and Staff.
  • Preach or teach as needed.
  • Officiate weddings, funerals, and other pastoral functions, as needed.
  • Engage FAC and the greater Erie community relationally and missionally.
  • Engage in and support the C&MA in local, district, and national endeavors.
  • Exhibit a humble, servant-hearted presence.
  • Be energetic, quick-paced, and highly organized.
General Operational Expectations
  • Develop, implement, and administer FAC's operating, capital and missions’ budgets.
  • Oversight of FAC business office, facilities, and grounds (and related equipment).
  • Provide strategic input to FAC's overall ministry environment as well as specific ministries as assigned.
  • Oversee and provide leadership and mentoring for all staff departments, ensuring effiective alignment with FAC's overall vision while cultivating a healthy environment.
  • Serve on the Finance Team, and the Facilities and Grounds Team.
  • Oversee staffing decisions throughout the employment life cycle: recruitment, personnel selection, and formal job offers; decisions concerning employee job performance and corrective measures; and employee separations.
  • Oversight of wage, salary and employee benefits administration.
  • Assist the Lead Pastor in developing the Annual Business Meeting including all financial reporting.
Qualifications (Required)
  • Bachelor’s degree (or higher) in Theology or a closely related field from an accredited institution.
  • Demonstrate proven leadership experience in a multi-staff or multi-site church setting.
  • Experience in both Business and HR administration is required. Business administration experience includes interacting with outside vendors, drafting executing contracts and legal documents, and budgeting. HR administration experience includes knowledge of health and other group insurance benefits, accounting system using Intuit Quickbooks, payroll systems, workplace requirements including applicable federal, state and local regulations, and related responsibilities.
  • Strong communication, management, and organizational skills.
  • Passionate about reaching the lost, developing leaders, and building healthy ministry teams.
  • .Licensed or willing to be licensed with The Christian and Missionary Alliance
    • To learn more about The Christian and Missionary Alliance and requirements for licensing, please visit https://cmalliance.org/
  • PA Acts 31, 33, 34 and 114 child abuse clearances will be required prior to commencing employment.
Reports to:

The Executive Pastor position directly reports to and is accountable to the Lead Pastor.

Compensation and Benefits
  • Compensation is commensurate with credentials and experience.
  • Full-time employees are eligible to participate in FAC’s generous benefit package which includes Group Health, Dental, Vision plans, C&MA 403b Retirement Plan with employer discretionary match, Flexible Spending Account, Group Life and AD&D, Short and Long term disability benefits and paid leave as outlined in the FAC Employee Handbook
  • First round interviews are not expected to begin until mid-January 2027.
  • Please do not contact FAC directly.
  • First Alliance Church is a suburban church located in Millcreek Township of Erie County, PA, on the shores of Lake Erie, featuring Presque Isle State Park, and an easy drive to Cleveland, Buffalo, and Pittsburgh. Erie County is home to some of the best public and private schools in the state and features four Universities.

To be considered for this position, please complete the application to include your testimony, resume and other background information related to the position.

If the district office has reviewed your application and they think you may be a potential match for the position, that the hiring manager will reach out to you for next steps.

This position may require licensing with The Christian & Missionary Alliance. To learn more about The Alliance and requirements for licensing, please visit our website

Please do not contact the church directly.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Executive Pastor at First Alliance Church
Executive Pastor at First Alliance Church

The Christian and Missionary Alliance - U.S. Church Ministries • Erie

On-site
USD 90,000 - 140,000
Group Health
Dental & Vision
403b retirement plan
+3
Executive Pastor: Strategic Ministry Leader & Operations
Executive Pastor: Strategic Ministry Leader & Operations

The Christian and Missionary Alliance - U.S. Church Ministries • Erie

On-site
USD 90,000 - 140,000
Group Health
Dental & Vision
403b retirement plan
+3
Executive Pastor - Christian Fellowship Church
Executive Pastor - Christian Fellowship Church

Christian Career • Ashburn (VA)

On-site
USD 110,000 - 150,000
Senior Pastor - Fellowship Alliance Chapel
Senior Pastor - Fellowship Alliance Chapel

Christian Career Center • Medford Township (NJ)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 200,000
Parsonage housing
Retirement plan contributions
Lead Pastor First Christian Church
Lead Pastor First Christian Church

Kentucky Christian University • Somerset

On-site
USD 45,000 - 70,000
Housing allowance
Mileage reimbursement
Vacation and holidays
+1
Lead Pastor
Lead Pastor

First Christian Church of Montoursville • Montoursville

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Housing allowance
Mileage reimbursement
Vacation and holiday time
+1
Lead Pastor - Orrville, OH
Lead Pastor - Orrville, OH

The Christian and Missionary Alliance • Orrville (OH)

On-site
USD 70,000 - 90,000
Health Coverage
Lead Pastor - Orrville, OH
Lead Pastor - Orrville, OH

The Christian and Missionary Alliance - U.S. Church Ministries • Orrville (OH)

On-site
USD 70,000 - 90,000
Health Coverage
Senior Pastor
Senior Pastor

The Christian and Missionary Alliance • Medford Township (NJ)

On-site
USD 100,000 - 150,000
Parsonage housing option
Retirement contributions
Benefits package
Executive Pastor
Executive Pastor

Buffalo Cov • Buffalo (MN)

On-site
USD 70,000 - 90,000
Health insurance
Retirement contributions
Professional development allowance