Donor Engagement Manager (47573)

Northwest Arkansas Children's Shelter

Bentonville (AR)

On-site

USD 50,000 - 65,000

Full time

3 days ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Northwest Arkansas Children's Shelter is seeking a Donor Engagement Manager to lead EverHope’s annual giving program and donor relations. You will manage direct mail, digital fundraising, monthly giving, and stewardship, collaborating with the CDO and Marketing to grow revenue and retention.

The ideal candidate writes compelling donor communications, analyzes donor data, and coordinates cross-functional teams to deliver impactful campaigns that deepen philanthropic involvement.

Qualifications

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent in nonprofit management, marketing, communications, or a related field.
  • Two or more years of nonprofit fundraising, annual giving, donor relations, or a related field.
  • Must pass criminal history and child maltreatment background checks.
  • Must submit to pre-employment and random drug screens when directed.

Responsibilities

  • Partner with the CDO to establish annual giving goals, priorities, and strategies.
  • Develop and manage the annual calendar of donor cultivation, stewardship, solicitations, and campaigns.
  • Plan and execute direct mail, email, digital appeals, giving days, and seasonal campaigns.
  • Write donor-centered fundraising appeals, stewardship messages, and campaign communications.
  • Collaborate with Marketing & Communications and internal teams to coordinate campaign development and execution.
  • Support fundraising events and donor engagement activities for successful outcomes.
  • Manage donor acquisition, renewal, retention, reactivation, and upgrade initiatives.
  • Develop donor journeys to convert first-time donors into ongoing supporters.
  • Create CRM reports, segmented donor lists, and analyze donor trends to improve results.
  • Maintain accurate donor records and provide performance reports to the CDO.

Skills

Donor relations
Fundraising campaigns
Annual giving
Written fundraising communications
CRM data analysis
Project management
Cross-department collaboration
Attention to detail

Education

Bachelor’s degree in nonprofit management or related field
Two years nonprofit fundraising experience

Tools

CRM software
Microsoft Office / Google Workspace

Job description

Job Details: Job Location: 12R22 - Bentonville, AR 72713, Position Type: Full Time, Education Level: 4 Year Degree, Salary Range: $50,000.00 - $65,000.00 Salary/year, Travel Percentage: Negligible, Job Category: Professional Services

THE POSITION:

The Donor Engagement Manager leads the execution of EverHope’s annual giving program, building meaningful donor relationships that grow revenue, strengthen retention, and inspire continued support. This position manages direct mail, digital fundraising, monthly giving, donor stewardship, and targeted engagement strategies for new, current, and lapsed donors.

Working closely with the Chief Development Officer (CDO), the Donor Engagement Manager coordinates fundraising campaigns, develops compelling donor communications, and uses donor insights, segmentation, and testing to improve results. This position collaborates with Marketing & Communications and other internal teams to create a consistent, meaningful donor experience.

The ideal candidate is a team player with a donor centered mindset, a talent for writing compelling fundraising communications, and a genuine love for building relationships. They’re someone who can juggle multiple projects, pivot with ease when priorities shift, isn’t afraid to pick up the phone, and is always willing to jump in wherever needed to help the team succeed.

Key Responsibilities (may include, but not limited to):
Annual Giving & Fundraising Campaigns
  • Partner with the CDO to establish annual giving goals, priorities, and strategies.
  • Develop and manage the annual calendar of donor cultivation, stewardship, solicitations, and fundraising campaigns.
  • Plan and execute direct mail, email, digital appeals, giving days, and seasonal campaigns.
  • Write compelling, donor centered fundraising appeals, stewardship messages, and campaign communications.
  • Collaborate with Marketing & Communications, internal teams, and volunteers to coordinate campaign development, production, and execution.
  • Support fundraising events and donor engagement activities as needed, collaborating with the Development team to ensure successful execution.
Donor Engagement & Retention
  • Manage donor acquisition, renewal, retention, reactivation, and upgrade initiatives.
  • Develop and execute donor journeys that encourage first time donors to make a second gift and build lasting relationships.
  • Manage EverHope’s Stitched Family monthly giving program, including recruitment, stewardship, retention, and growth.
  • Identify and personally cultivate lapsed donors, including those who have not given in 18 months or longer, through targeted communications and solicitations.
  • Coordinate meaningful donor stewardship, recognition, and appreciation activities.
  • Identify opportunities
Donor Data & Performance
  • Create CRM reports, custom queries, and segmented donor lists to support fundraising and stewardship efforts.
  • Analyze donor trends and campaign results to track performance, identify opportunities, and improve fundraising effectiveness.
  • Maintain accurate donor records and provide regular performance reports and recommendations to the CDO.
Essential Knowledge, Skills, and Abilities
  • Passion for EverHope’s mission and commitment to serving children and families impacted by trauma.
  • Excellent writing and communication skills with the ability to create compelling, donor centered fundraising communications.
  • Knowledge of annual giving, donor stewardship, retention, and fundraising campaigns.
  • Strong analytical skills with the ability to use donor data to inform decisions and improve fundraising results.
  • Experience with CRM systems, donor segmentation, and digital fundraising tools.
  • Strong organizational and project management skills with the ability to manage multiple campaigns and deadlines.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office or Google Workspace and related fundraising technology.
  • Ability to build donor relationships and collaborate effectively across departments.
  • Creativity, initiative, and the ability to independently manage projects from planning through execution.
  • Ability to work evenings and weekends as needed for organizational activities.
Qualifications: Minimum Qualifications:
  • Bachelor’s degree in nonprofit management, hospitality, marketing, communications, business, or a related field or two years of nonprofit management, hospitality, marketing, communications, business experience in lieu of a degree
  • Two or more years of experience in nonprofit fundraising, annual giving, donor relations, communications, or a related field.
  • Must pass all criminal history and child maltreatment background checks.
  • Must submit to pre-employment a drug screen as well as random drug screens when directed.
  • Valid driver's license, proof of personal automobile insurance, and acceptable driving record required to drive shelter vehicles for shelter business.
Working Conditions and Environment/Physical Demands

The demands described are representative of those that must be met by an individual to successfully perform the essential functions of this position.

The demands described are representative of those that must be met by an individual to successfully perform the essential functions of this position.

  • Tasks may involve walking, standing, climbing, bending, kneeling, crouching, and lifting for extended periods.
  • Ability to lift up to 50 pounds.
  • Must pass all criminal history and child maltreatment background checks.
  • Must submit to a pre employment drug screen as well as random drug screens when directed.
  • Valid driver’s license, proof of personal automobile insurance, and acceptable driving record required.
  • Must maintain confidentiality regarding all EverHope client information in accordance with organizational policy and applicable federal and state regulations.
  • Attend and participate in required meetings, training, and organizational events.
  • Maintain appropriate professional boundaries.
  • Complete required documentation in a timely manner.
Primary Outcome

Grow annual giving revenue and build lasting donor relationships through effective fundraising campaigns, personalized stewardship, and data informed engagement. The Donor Engagement Manager increases donor retention, recurring support, and lapsed donor reactivation while creating meaningful pathways for deeper philanthropic involvement.

This position description is intended to describe the general nature and level of the work to be performed. This is not an exhaustive list of all duties and responsibilities associated with it.

EverHope reserves the right to amend and change responsibilities to meet organizational needs.

EverHope is an Equal Opportunity Employer and all qualified candidates are encouraged to apply.

EverHope offers excellent benefits and a competitive salary based on experience.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Donor Engagement Manager
Donor Engagement Manager

Northwest Arkansas Children's Shelter • Bentonville (AR)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Donor Engagement Lead for Annual Giving
Donor Engagement Lead for Annual Giving

Northwest Arkansas Children's Shelter • Bentonville (AR)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Grant Manager (47565)
Grant Manager (47565)

EverHope • Bentonville (AR)

On-site
USD 58,000 - 65,000
Grant Manager
Grant Manager

Northwest Arkansas Children's Shelter • Bentonville (AR)

On-site
USD 60,000 - 90,000
Excellent benefits
Regional Development and Donor Engagement Manager
Regional Development and Donor Engagement Manager

Every Child's Hope • St. Louis (MO)

On-site
USD 65,000 - 95,000
Annual Giving & Donor Engagement Lead
Annual Giving & Donor Engagement Lead

Northwest Arkansas Children's Shelter • Bentonville (AR)

On-site
USD 50,000 - 65,000
DONOR RELATIONS MANAGER
DONOR RELATIONS MANAGER

Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Rochester • City of Rochester (NY)

On-site
USD 64,000 - 66,000
Competitive salary and 403b retirement
Generous time off
Comprehensive benefits package
+3
Donor Engagement Coordinator Project 2 Restore
Donor Engagement Coordinator Project 2 Restore

Manhattan Christian College • Topeka (KS)

Hybrid
USD 20,664 - 34,440
Professional Development
Participation in Fundraising Masterminds
DONOR RELATIONS MANAGER
DONOR RELATIONS MANAGER

Ccdor • City of Rochester (NY)

On-site
USD 64,000 - 66,000
403b retirement plan
Generous time off package
Comprehensive benefits package
+3
Donor Database Manager | Full-Time, Nonexempt
Donor Database Manager | Full-Time, Nonexempt

Door of Hope • Pasadena (CA)

Hybrid
USD 70,000 - 100,000
Paid PTO
Health Insurance
Dependent premium coverage
+2