Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving

Mount Saint Mary College

Varick Homes (NY)

On-site

USD 85,000 - 100,000

Full time

44 hours ago
Be an early applicant

A complete application in a minute

Tailored resume and cover letter, ready to send.

Get past ATS filters

Benefits offered by this job

403(b) Retirement Plan
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
Tuition Remission – Self and Dependets
Tuition Exchange Program

Job summary

Mount Saint Mary College seeks a Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving to lead strategic initiatives across alumni relations and fundraising. Reporting to the Vice President for Advancement, you will build an integrated engagement-to-giving program, supervise two directors, and elevate annual giving revenue through multi-channel campaigns and strong donor stewardship.

The role requires 5–7 years in higher education advancement, a track record of successful campaigns, and proficiency

Qualifications

  • Bachelor's degree required; Master's preferred.
  • 5–7 years in higher education advancement or related nonprofit leadership.
  • Proven success in designing and executing annual giving campaigns.

Responsibilities

  • Develop and oversee a unified, data-driven alumni engagement and annual giving strategy.
  • Supervise the Assistant Director for Alumni Engagement and the Assistant Director of Annual Giving.
  • Direct the planning and execution of multi-channel annual giving campaigns and events.
  • Oversee donor stewardship, pipeline management, and engagement metrics.
  • Collaborate with Marketing for cohesive messaging and donor communications.

Skills

Strategic leadership
Team supervision
Cross-functional collaboration

Education

Bachelor's degree required
Master's degree preferred

Tools

Raiser's Edge NXT
Salesforce
Banner
GiveSmart

Job description

If you are unable to complete this application due to a disability, contact this employer to ask for an accommodation or an alternative application process.

Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving

Regular Full-Time Professional Newburgh, NY, US

Salary: $90,000.00 Annually

Job Title:Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving

Reports To:Vice President for Advancement

Status:Full-Time, Exempt

Department:Advancement

Summary/Objective

The Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving provides strategic leadership and operational oversight for Mount Saint Mary College’s alumni relations and annual giving initiatives. Reporting directly to the Vice President for Advancement, this position is responsible for designing and executing a unified, data-driven strategy that bridges constituent engagement with philanthropic support. By supervising the Assistant Director for Alumni Engagement and the Assistant Director of Annual Giving, the Director establishes an integrated engagement-to-giving pipeline, increases alumni participation, elevates annual campaign revenue ($25 to $5,000+), and builds a robust pipeline for future leadership and major gift donors.

Essential Functions

Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform these essential functions.

  • Strategic Leadership & Departmental Integration:Develop, implement, and evaluate a comprehensive, integrated multi-year strategy for alumni engagement and annual giving that drives constituent participation, donor retention, and philanthropic revenue.
  • Team Supervision & Development:Directly supervise, mentor, and evaluate the Assistant Director for Alumni Engagement and the Assistant Director of Annual Giving, establishing performance metrics, managing project timelines, and ensuring cross-functional alignment.
  • Annual Giving & Pipeline Strategy:Direct the strategic planning, messaging, and execution of multi-channel annual giving appeals (e.g., Go Blue for MSMC, Challenge of the Decades, Giving Tuesday, and targeted direct mail/digital campaigns).
  • Alumni Board & Constituent Governance:Oversee the strategic direction and work plan for the Alumni Association Board, partnering with board leadership and staff to align board initiatives with college priorities.
  • Marquee Events & Gala/Golf Participation:Strategically support and champion the College’s marquee fundraising events, specifically driving initiatives to expand alumni attendance, committee involvement, sponsorships, and overall philanthropic participation in the Annual Gala Reception and Annual Golf/Tennis Tournament.
  • Alumni Reunion Weekend Alignment:In collaboration with the Assistant Director for Alumni Engagement, provide strategic oversight for major alumni events—including Alumni Reunion Weekend, 50th Reunion celebrations, and regional gatherings—ensuring event strategies directly support constituent engagement and annual giving goals.
  • Data Analytics & Donor Upgrades:In partnership with Advancement Services, analyze donor behavior, participation trends, and engagement metrics to refine solicitation strategies, identify upgrade opportunities, and build a smooth pipeline into major gift portfolios.
  • Platform & Operations Oversight:Oversee the administrative and strategic use of event and fundraising platforms (such as GiveSmart), ensuring seamless donor experiences, registration tracking, and online giving execution.
  • Cross-Departmental Collaboration:Work closely with the Marketing and Communications team to ensure cohesive, compelling messaging across all alumni and annual giving collateral, including the annual Donor Impact Report and college magazine updates.
  • Donor & Volunteer Stewardship:Maintain a personal portfolio of leadership annual donors and key alumni volunteers, encouraging sustained engagement and growing philanthropic investment in institutional priorities.
Supervisory Responsibilities

This position directlysupervises:

  • Assistant Director for Alumni Engagement
  • Assistant Director of Annual Giving
  • Office Setting:Cubicles, open desks, or private offices with access to necessary tools like computers, phones, and office supplies.
  • Remote Setting:Working from home or another location with access to virtual communication platforms and necessary technology.
Physical Demands
  • Sitting:Prolonged periods of sitting at a desk or workstation.
  • Typing/Computer Use:Frequent use of a computer keyboard and mouse.
  • Vision Requirements:Ability to read and view screens for extended periods.
  • Speaking/Hearing:Regular communication with coworkers and alumni/friends in person, over the phone, or via video calls.
  • Lifting/Carrying:Occasionally lifting or moving items up to 10–15 pounds, such as office supplies, laptops, or documents.
  • Reaching/Bending:Periodic reaching for or bending to access files, supplies, or equipment.
  • Mobility:Walking short distances within the office or to meeting rooms.
Travel Required
  • Local and regional travel required to attend alumni meetings, events, and perform job-related duties.
Required Education and Experience
  • Minimum of a Bachelor's degree required; Master's degree preferred.
  • 5–7 years of progressive experience in higher education advancement, alumni relations, annual giving, or related non-profit leadership roles.
  • Demonstrated success in designing and executing successful annual giving campaigns and constituent engagement programs.
  • Proven experience in supervisory management and staff leadership.
  • Strong organizational, time management, and project management skills.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills across multiple channels.
  • Proficiency with fundraising CRMs (e.g., Raiser's Edge NXT, Salesforce, Banner) and event management platforms (e.g., GiveSmart).
  • Candidate must be imaginative, entrepreneurial, collaborative, display a strong sense of ownership, and possess strategic business acumen.
  • Ability to work evening and weekend hours as required for events and board meetings.
  • Medical
  • Vision
  • 403(b) Retirement Plan (Pre-Tax & Roth Options)
  • 403(b) Employer Match
  • Generous Paid Time Off
  • Paid Holidays
  • EAP
  • Voluntary Life
  • Voluntary AD&DD
  • Voluntary Hospital Insurance
  • Voluntary Critical Illness Insurance
  • Flexible Spending Accounts – Health, Dependent Care
  • College Paid Life Insurance
  • College Paid Long Term Disability
  • Tuition Remission – Self and Dependents
  • Tuition Exchange Program
Work Authorization

Must be authorized to work in the United States. MSMC does not sponsor employment visas at this time.

EEO Statement

Mount Saint Mary College is an Equal Opportunity Employer committed to creating an inclusive and diverse workplace. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, disability, veteran status, or any other legally protected characteristic. We actively encourage applications from individuals of all backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives.

Other Duties

Please note this job description is not designed to cover or contain a comprehensive listing of activities, duties or responsibilities that are required of the employee for this job. Duties, responsibilities and activities may change at any time with or without notice.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving
Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving

Mount Saint Mary College • City of Newburgh (NY)

On-site
USD 81,000 - 99,000
403(b) Retirement Plan
403(b) Employer Match
Generous Paid Time Off
+7
Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving
Director of Alumni Engagement and Annual Giving

ADP, Inc. • City of Newburgh (NY)

On-site
USD 81,000 - 99,000
403(b) Retirement Plan
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+1
Director of Annual Giving & Alumni Relations
Director of Annual Giving & Alumni Relations

Mount Aloysius College • Cresson

On-site
USD 85,000 - 120,000
Associate Director, Annual Giving
Associate Director, Annual Giving

Le Moyne College • City of Syracuse (NY)

On-site
USD 63,000 - 74,000
Health insurance
403(b) Retirement contribution
Generous time off package
+1
Assistant Executive Director of Annual Giving
Assistant Executive Director of Annual Giving

St. Mary's University of San Antonio • San Antonio (TX)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 120,000
Equal Opportunity Employer
Assistant Executive Director of Annual Giving
Assistant Executive Director of Annual Giving

ST. MARY'S UNIVERSITY • San Antonio (TX)

On-site
USD 90,000 - 120,000
Alumni Engagement & Annual Giving Director
Alumni Engagement & Annual Giving Director

Mount Saint Mary College • City of Newburgh (NY)

On-site
USD 81,000 - 99,000
403(b) Retirement Plan
403(b) Employer Match
Generous Paid Time Off
+7
Alumni Engagement & Annual Giving Growth Director
Alumni Engagement & Annual Giving Growth Director

ADP, Inc. • City of Newburgh (NY)

On-site
USD 81,000 - 99,000
403(b) Retirement Plan
Paid Time Off
Paid Holidays
+1
Alum Experience Director
Alum Experience Director

Mount Holyoke College • South Hadley (MA)

On-site
USD 98,000 - 111,000
403(b) Retirement Plan
Medical, dental, vision insurance
Flexible Spending Account (FSA)
+6
Associate Director of Development
Associate Director of Development

Saint Joseph's College • Standish (ME)

On-site
USD 83,000 - 85,000