Customer Success Manager

Outmarket AI

United States

Remote

USD 90,000 - 140,000

Full time

3 days ago
Be an early applicant

Get a reply from this employer

Your resume and cover letter, tailored to exactly what they’re hiring for.

Get past ATS filters

Job summary

Outmarket is seeking a Customer Success Manager to own the post-sale journey for a portfolio of agency, broker, and carrier accounts. You’ll report to the Head of Customer Success and work closely with the Chief Revenue Officer, partnering with customers from onboarding through renewal and expansion.

This is a high-impact role for someone who understands how commercial insurance agencies operate and enjoys building in a fast-moving environment.

Qualifications

  • 4+ years in Customer Success, Account Management, or Implementation.
  • AI fluency is required; familiarity with Claude or similar tools is a plus.
  • Hands-on experience in commercial insurance or insurtech is highly desirable.
  • Track record of owning a book of accounts and driving adoption, retention, and expansion.

Responsibilities

  • Own onboarding and activation for agencies, brokers, and carriers on the Outmarket platform.
  • Build and maintain trusted relationships with agency principals, department leaders, producers, and account managers.
  • Be the main post-sale contact for implementation, training, ongoing engagement, retention, and health of accounts.
  • Identify expansion opportunities within existing accounts and new use cases.
  • Turn customer feedback into product insights to inform roadmaps.

Skills

Customer Success
Account Management
Implementation
AI fluency
B2B SaaS

Tools

Applied Epic
AMS360

Job description

About Outmarket

Outmarket is an AI-powered platform purpose-built for commercial insurance agencies. We help brokers, MGAs, and carriers extract insights, automate workflows, and move faster by turning unstructured data into action.

Our customer base is growing quickly, and we're looking for a Customer Success Manager with commercial insurance experience to help us scale. This person will be a strategic partner to our customers and an important internal voice as we keep building our product and go-to-market approach.

About the Role

We're hiring a Customer Success Manager to own the post-sale customer journey for a portfolio of agency, broker, and carrier accounts. You'll report to the Head of Customer Success and work closely with the Chief Revenue Officer, partnering with customers from onboarding through renewal and expansion.

This is a high-impact role for someone who understands how commercial insurance agencies operate and enjoys building in a fast-moving environment. You'll work directly with agency leaders, producers, and account teams to drive adoption, deepen relationships, and help shape how we scale customer success as the business grows. If you're energized by ownership, close customer partnership, and helping define the playbook as a company grows, you'll likely thrive here.

Why This Role
  • Join a company with strong customer momentum and a lot of opportunity ahead.

  • Work closely with the Head of Customer Success and CRO on customer growth, retention, and expansion strategy.

  • Own the customer experience end to end, from onboarding and activation through renewal and upsell.

  • Help shape the product roadmap by being a direct voice of the customer.

  • Join a high-caliber team built from Meta, IBM, Adobe, Salesforce, DocuSign, and Uber, with real ownership, strong trust, and meaningful equity.

What You'll Do
  • Own onboarding and activation for agencies, brokers, and carriers using the Outmarket platform, so customers see value fast and adopt the product widely.

  • Build and maintain trusted relationships with agency principals, department leaders, producers, and account managers.

  • Be the main post-sale contact for implementation, training, ongoing engagement, retention, and account health.

  • Find expansion opportunities in existing accounts, whether that's new teams, new lines of business, or new use cases.

  • Turn customer feedback into product insights that help set roadmap priorities.

  • Use AI tools like Claude every day to prep for customer conversations, analyze account health, build content, and scale yourself across a growing book of accounts.

  • Build and improve onboarding materials, training content, and Customer Success processes that can scale with the business.

What We're Looking For
  • 4+ years in Customer Success, Account Management, or Implementation, ideally at a B2B SaaS company.

  • AI fluency is a must. We're an AI company, and our best CSMs use AI tools like Claude every day to work smarter. You either already do this, or you're eager to learn everything you can and put it to work right away.

  • Hands-on experience in commercial insurance, whether at an agency, brokerage, MGA, carrier, or an insurtech selling to them. You know how agencies are structured, how account teams work day to day, and what drives renewals.

  • A track record of owning a book of accounts and moving the numbers that matter: adoption, retention, and expansion.

  • Comfort leading onboarding and training for users ranging from agency principals to day-to-day account managers.

  • Strong communication skills. You can run an executive business review in the morning and a hands-on training in the afternoon.

  • The ability to spot patterns across customers and turn them into clear, useful feedback for Product.

  • A builder's mindset. You like creating playbooks, templates, and processes where none exist yet.

  • Comfort with ambiguity and a fast pace. You take ownership without waiting for direction.

Nice to have

  • Experience across multiple lines of business (P&C, Employee Benefits, specialty).

  • Familiarity with agency management systems (e.g. Applied Epic, Vertafore AMS360) or other tools agencies rely on.

  • Experience at an early-stage or high-growth startup.

Get your free, confidential resume review.

or drag and drop your file here.

Similar jobs

Similar jobs worth comparing

Senior Account Executive
Senior Account Executive

Outmarket.AI • United States

Remote
USD 70,000 - 120,000
Competitive salary
Uncapped commission
Equity in the company
+2
Strategic CSM for AI-Powered Commercial Insurance
Strategic CSM for AI-Powered Commercial Insurance

Outmarket AI • United States

Remote
USD 90,000 - 140,000
Staff Customer Success Manager
Staff Customer Success Manager

Checkr • San Francisco (CA)

Hybrid
USD 140,000 - 210,000
Parental leave
Stock options
Work from home opportunities
+6
Senior Account Executive
Senior Account Executive

Outmarket • Friendly (MD)

Remote
USD 100,000 - 150,000
Competitive salary
Uncapped commission
Equity in a fast-growing company
+2
Head of Growth
Head of Growth

Outmarket AI • United States

Remote
USD 180,000 - 260,000
Customer Success Manager
Customer Success Manager

Magnitude Consulting • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 80,000 - 120,000
Equity participation
Opportunity to make a meaningful impact in a fast-scaling company
Customer Success Manager
Customer Success Manager

Leadbeam • New York (NY)

On-site
USD 85,000 - 120,000
Competitive salary
Meaningful equity
Direct access to founders
+1
Customer Success Manager
Customer Success Manager

Supio • Seattle (WA)

On-site
USD 120,000 - 150,000
Head of Product Marketing
Head of Product Marketing

Outmarket AI • United States

Remote
USD 180,000 - 240,000
Customer Success Manager - Enterprise
Customer Success Manager - Enterprise

Searchable • Salt Lake City (UT)

Hybrid
USD 100,000 - 130,000
Health insurance
Equity
Parental leave
+1