Controller

Selby Jennings; Orlando (FL); On-site; USD 120,000 - 180,000; Full time

Job summary

Selby Jennings is seeking an accomplished accounting leader to manage the close process, financial reporting, and regulatory filings for a Property & Casualty organization in Florida.

The role emphasizes oversight of corporate and premium accounting, interaction with senior leadership, and driving process improvements while ensuring compliance with GAAP and insurance regulations.

Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree in Accounting or related field is required.
• CPA license is preferred or in process.
• MBA or master's in Accounting is preferred.
• 7+ years of accounting experience, 5+ years in insurance accounting, 4+ years in supervision or management.
• Strong GAAP knowledge and regulatory accounting understanding.

Responsibilities

• Lead monthly, quarterly, and annual close with GAAP and statutory reporting.
• Oversee consolidated financial statements, regulatory filings, and disclosures.
• Manage Corporate and Premium Accounting functions for accuracy and efficiency.
• Partner with executives on strategic initiatives, FP&A, and budgeting.
• Direct budgeting, forecasting, and variance reporting; monitor cash flow.

Skills

GAAP knowledge

Insurance accounting

Leadership

Excel

Financial reporting

FP&A

Tax knowledge

Regulatory compliance

Communication skills

Problem solving

Education

Bachelor's degree in Accounting or related field

CPA preferred

MBA or Master's in Accounting preferred

Tools

ERP systems experience

Financial reporting systems

Job description

Company Overview

An established and growing Property & Casualty insurance organization providing specialized insurance solutions across multiple markets. The company is creating opportunities for accounting and finance professionals to gain broad exposure across financial reporting, regulatory compliance, FP&A, treasury, and strategic initiatives. This role offers high visibility with senior leadership and the opportunity to make a direct impact by enhancing processes, strengthening controls, and helping scale the finance function as the organization continues to expand.

Location

Sarasota, FL or Orlando, FL (on-site)

Job Responsibilities

• Lead the monthly, quarterly, and annual close process, ensuring accurate GAAP and statutory financial reporting
• Oversee the preparation and review of consolidated financial statements, regulatory filings, and related disclosures
• Manage Corporate Accounting and Premium Accounting functions, driving accuracy and efficiency across financial operations
• Partner with executive leadership to support strategic initiatives, financial planning, and business decision-making
• Direct budgeting, forecasting, and financial analysis activities, including budget-to-actual and variance reporting
• Maintain oversight of cash management, treasury operations, and cash flow forecasting processes
• Ensure compliance with insurance regulatory requirements, accounting standards, and internal control frameworks
• Oversee the accounting and reporting of reinsurance contracts, recoverables, and related analyses
• Serve as the primary point of contact for external auditors and coordinate annual audits and examinations
• Collaborate with internal audit teams to strengthen controls and address audit recommendations
• Review quarterly and annual income tax provisions and ensure compliance with federal and state tax regulations
• Develop and monitor department budgets, forecasts, and cost center performance metrics
• Evaluate financial systems, reporting processes, and operational controls to ensure data integrity
• Identify opportunities to improve processes, reduce costs, and enhance operational effectiveness
• Prepare executive-level financial reports, analyses, and presentations to support organizational goals
• Provide leadership, mentorship, and professional development opportunities for accounting team members
• Support special projects and ad hoc financial initiatives as directed by senior management

Qualifications

• 7+ years ofaccounting experience
• 5+ years of insurance accountingexperience
• 4+ years in a supervisory or management role
• Strong knowledge of statutory accounting and insurance industry regulations
• Understanding of GAAP and regulatory accounting principles
• Experience with financial reporting, FP&A, treasury management, tax, investments, and general ledger accounting
• Advanced proficiency in Microsoft Excel
• Strong analytical, problem-solving, organizational, and leadership skills
• Experience with financial systems and reporting tools
• Ability to manage multiple priorities and perform effectively in a fast-paced environment
• Excellent verbal, written, and interpersonal communication skills
• Strong attention to detail with a proactive and results-driven approach
• Bachelor's degree in Accounting or related field
• Licensed Certified Public Accountant (CPA) preferred
• MBA and/or Master's degree in Accounting is preferred