Controller

Monmouth Trading Cards; Neptune Township (NJ); On-site; USD 80,000 - 100,000; Full time

Job summary

A leading trading card retailer in New Jersey is seeking an experienced Controller to manage financial reporting and accounting functions. You'll be responsible for budgeting, forecasting, and ensuring accurate financial statements in a fast-growing company focused on sports cards and collectibles. This role requires a Bachelor's degree in Accounting or Finance and extensive experience in accounting or finance, preferably in retail or e-commerce.

Benefits

Bonus based on performance

Company parties

Competitive salary

Employee discounts

Opportunity for advancement

Paid time off

Qualifications

• 5-10+ years of experience in accounting or finance.
• At least 2+ years in a Controller or Assistant Controller role.
• Experience in retail or e-commerce is strongly preferred.

Responsibilities

• Own the full accounting function including GL and monthly closes.
• Prepare accurate financial statements including P&L and cash flow.
• Lead budgeting and forecasting processes.

Skills

Accounting principles

Financial reporting

Communication skills

Organizational skills

Education

Bachelor’s degree in Accounting or Finance

Tools

QuickBooks Online

Excel

Google Sheets

Job description

Overview

Location: Neptune, NJ   |   Company: Monmouth Cards  |   Type: Full-Time | Senior Finance

About Monmouth Cards

Monmouth Cards is one of the fastest-growing trading card retailers in the U.S., with multiple retail stores across New Jersey, a thriving e-commerce operation, and in-stadium kiosks across the Northeast. We specialize in sports cards, Pokémon, and TCGs—driven by passionate collectors, strong operational systems, and an obsession with customer experience. As we scale, we’re looking for a financial leader to help guide our next phase of growth.

Position Overview

We’re seeking an experienced and detail-driven Controller to oversee all aspects of financial reporting, accounting operations, cash management, and internal controls. This role will lead the accounting function and work closely with leadership on budgeting, analysis, and financial strategy.

Responsibilities

• Own the full accounting function, including GL, AP/AR, bank recons, and monthly closes
• Prepare accurate and timely financial statements (P&L, balance sheet, cash flow)
• Maintain and improve internal controls, financial processes, and cost tracking
• Lead budgeting and forecasting processes across retail, e-commerce, and buying teams
• Reconcile and manage inventory across retail stores, warehouse, and marketplaces
• Manage sales tax compliance across multiple states and platforms
• Oversee payroll coordination and benefits reporting in collaboration with HR
• Assist in strategic planning, margin optimization, and financial modeling
• Evaluate accounting software, POS, and ERP integrations for future scalability
• Work closely with ownership to provide insights and financial recommendations

Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree in Accounting or Finance (CPA preferred but not required)
• 5–10+ years of experience in accounting or finance, with at least 2+ years in a Controller or Assistant Controller role
• Experience in retail, e-commerce, or multi-entity businesses is strongly preferred
• Proficiency in QuickBooks Online, Excel/Google Sheets, and financial reporting tools
• Strong knowledge of inventory accounting, COGS, and reconciliations
• Detail-oriented, hands-on leader with strong organizational and communication skills
• Comfortable in a fast-paced, growth-focused environment

Benefits

• Bonus based on performance
• Company parties
• Competitive salary
• Employee discounts
• Opportunity for advancement
• Paid time off