Chief Claims Officer, Argo Group

Clearbrook Group Services Inc.; New York (NY); On-site; USD 270,000 - 350,000; Full time

Job summary

Argo Group is seeking a Chief Claims Officer to lead the claims function across Casualty, Property, Reinsurance, and other lines. The role reports to the Chief Claims Officer of Clearbrook in New York City and oversees a large team with broad operational scope, shaping profitability and growth through strategic direction and collaboration with underwriting, actuarial, finance, risk, and legal.

The ideal candidate will drive best practices, manage complex claims, and ensure compliance with

Qualifications

• Senior-level experience in commercial property and casualty claims across a full-scale domestic organization, with operations in US and Bermuda.
• Deep understanding of property and casualty finance, actuarial concepts, claims reserving, and financial outcomes.
• Experience designing and implementing claims technology solutions.
• Analytical, metrics-driven with strong strategy development and execution skills.
• Excellent communication, consensus-building, and client-focus skills.
• Demonstrated leadership ability to build teams and develop succession plans.

Responsibilities

• Partner with executive leadership to develop strategic and operational plans to meet growth and profitability targets.
• Collaborate with actuarial teams to align claims objectives with financial expectations.
• Manage teams led by People Managers to provide strong claims service and settlements.
• Establish and monitor performance objectives and metrics at all levels.
• Drive continuous improvement in people, processes, and technology.
• Oversee regulatory compliance and vendor contracts to maximize value.

Skills

Senior leadership

Commercial P&C claims

Regulatory compliance

Claims technology

Strategic planning

Vendor management

Litigation management

Communication

Team development

Education

J.D. from an accredited law school

CPCU or related designation desirable

Tools

Claims technology platforms

Job description

Company: Argo Group. As an underwriter of specialty insurance products, Argo delivers a full line of property and casualty solutions designed to meet the coverage and claims-handling needs of businesses.

Business Title(s)

• Chief Claims Officer, Argo Group

Employment Details

• Type: Full‑Time
• FLSA Status: Exempt
• Location: In‑Office (Chicago, IL; Los Angeles, CA; New York City, NY; Omaha, NE; Richmond, VA)

Summary

The Chief Claims Officer, Argo Group reports directly to the Chief Claims Officer of Clearbrook located in New York City. The role oversees the entire Claims function across Casualty, Operations, Property, Reinsurance, Surety, and Workers’ Compensation Claims. Five direct reports and approximately 150 indirect reports report to the Chief Claims Officer. The position drives strategic direction, executive leadership, and management of all claims operations and works closely with Underwriting, Actuarial, Finance, Risk, and Legal to formulate plans that support profitability and growth.

Essential Responsibilities

• Partner with executive leadership to develop strategic and operational plans that meet growth and profitability targets.
• Collaborate with the corporate actuarial team to align claims objectives with financial expectations.
• Manage teams led by People Managers to provide strong claims service, technical expertise, dispute resolution, and settlements.
• Establish and maintain performance objectives and metrics at all organizational levels.
• Drive continuous improvement initiatives involving people, processes, and technology.
• Implement best practices for claims performance and ensure compliance with OFAC, Medicare Reporting, Adjuster Licensing, SOX, and other regulations.
• Maximize cost effectiveness through claims resolution and process improvement while educating business leaders on claims drivers and trends.
• Negotiate vendor contracts to maximize financial benefit to Argo Group and its customers.
• Oversee litigation management and establish an enterprise-wide specialized litigation unit.
• Provide guidance and direction to claims managers through ongoing management involvement.
• Support the selection and retention of claims professionals with required technical expertise.

Qualifications

• Proven senior‑level experience in commercial property and casualty claims within a full‑scale domestic organization, with operations across the United States and Bermuda.
• Deep understanding of property and casualty finance, actuarial concepts, claims reserving, and financial outcomes.
• Experience designing and implementing claims technology solutions.
• Analytical, metrics‑driven focus and strong strategy development and execution skills.
• Excellent communication, consensus‑building, and client‑focus skills.
• Demonstrated leadership ability to build teams, attract talent, develop succession plans, and create a high‑performance culture.
• Strong knowledge of Argo Group’s business, return on capital, expense, risk, and effective capital usage.
• Proficiency in complex claims situations, litigation management, and regulatory compliance.

Educational Requirements

J.D. from an accredited law school. CPCU or other relevant professional designation desirable.

Compensation

• Base salary range for Chicago, Los Angeles, New York City, and Richmond: $270,000 – $350,000.
• Eligible for an annual bonus and long‑term incentives based on company and individual performance.
• Comprehensive benefits package including health, dental, vision, 401(k) with company match, paid time off, and professional development opportunities.

Legal and Equal Employment Opportunity Statements

Applicants must be legally authorized to work in the United States. At this time, the company is not able to sponsor or assume sponsorship of employment visas.

Disability accommodations may be discussed with the Benefits Department at 210‑321‑8400.