Casualty Claims Director

gaig; Cincinnati (OH); Hybrid; USD 150,000 - 210,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Medical coverage

Dental coverage

Vision coverage

Wellness plans

Parental leave

Tuition reimbursement

PTO + holidays

401(k) with match

Employee stock purchase plan

Commuter benefits

Job summary

Great American Insurance Group, headquartered in Cincinnati, is seeking an experienced Claims Director to lead a high-performing team of claims professionals. This senior leadership role balances strategic oversight with hands-on involvement in complex claims across multiple lines, shaping service quality and talent development.

The ideal candidate brings a minimum of 10 years in property and casualty claims handling, at least 8 years in leadership, and a track record of mentoring staff,

Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree in business administration, Risk Management and Insurance, Finance, or related field.
• Minimum 10 years of experience in property and casualty claims handling.
• Minimum 8 years leadership experience.
• Professional designation (AIC or CPCU) preferred.

Responsibilities

• Plan, develop, direct, and administer strategic claims programs.
• Provide insights to business leaders to drive performance.
• Oversee investigations to confirm coverage, liability, and damages.
• Coach and develop team members; manage settlements.

Skills

Leadership

Claims handling

Strategic oversight

Decision making

Education

Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration or related field

Job description

Be Here. Be Great. Working for a leader in the insurance industry means opportunity for you. Great American Insurance Group's member companies are subsidiaries of American Financial Group. We combine a \"small company\" culture where your ideas will be heard with \"big company\" expertise to help you succeed. With over 30 specialty and property and casualty operations, there are always opportunities here to learn and grow.

At Great American, we value and recognize the benefits derived when people with different backgrounds and experiences work together to achieve business results. Our goal is to create a workplace where all employees feel included, empowered, and enabled to perform at their best.

This position is not eligible for employment visa sponsorship. Applicants must be authorized to work in the United States without the need for current or future sponsorship.

Great American's Corporate Claims Resolution Services (CRS) team receives a variety of claims from numerous Great American Insurance Company divisions involving property, general liability, professional liability, ocean marine, commercial auto, employer’s liability, aviation, and employment practices liability. In addition, CRS handles Great American’s legacy claims.

The demand for CRS’ services currently exceeds the capacity of the senior management team. As such, CRS is creating a new senior management position to increase its capacity to take on new business and to help build with its succession planning talent pool.

CRS is seeking an experienced Claims Director to lead and inspire a high-performing team of claims professionals, including claims managers. This leadership role offers significant autonomy and influence, balancing strategic oversight with hands‑on involvement in complex, high‑impact claims matters. The successful candidate will bring strong technical expertise, sound judgment, and a proven ability to make critical decisions in a fast‑paced environment. Working collaboratively across the enterprise, the Claims Director will play a key role in maintaining relationships, developing talent, and fostering a culture of continuous learning, accountability, and outstanding service. This position is responsible for the performance, coaching, and professional development of team members, ensuring they are equipped to achieve both individual and organizational success.

Great American’s culture is built on connection, shared learning, and strong relationships. To support this, employees in this role are expected to be on‑site four days a week, with the flexibility to work one day remotely. Core in‑office days are Tuesday-Thursday, with the fourth day determined by business needs. This position is based at Great American’s headquarters in Cincinnati.

Essential Job Functions and Responsibilities

• Responsible for the overall planning, development, direction, and administration of the strategic Claims programs.
• Accountable for providing specialized insights with business leaders to implement strategies that support business goals and drive organizational performance.
• Oversees the strategic oversight of claims investigations to confirm coverage and determine liability, compensability, and damages.
• Offers expert advice to team members on complex claim file management and extends settlement authority following comprehensive reviews.
• Performs other duties as assigned.

Job Requirements

• Bachelor’s degree in business administration, Risk Management and Insurance, Finance, or a related field or equivalent experience.
• Generally, a minimum of 10 years of experience in property and casualty claims handling with a strong preference for casualty claims experience.
• Must have a minimum of 8 years leadership experience.
• Completion of or continuing progress toward a professional designation preferred, such as Associate in Claims (AIC) or the Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU).

Scope of Job/Qualifications

Typically manages 3 or more direct reports, including managing supervisors / managers. Implements policies, procedures, and strategies under the direction of management. Leads and mentors claims professionals, ensuring they achieve excellence in their roles. Serves as a resource on insurance policy and claims handling procedures. Responsible for identifying opportunities for process improvements and implementing best practices to enhance efficiency and service quality. Responsible for performance and coaching of staff and decisions regarding talent selection, development, and performance management. Ensures new members of the team receive proper training.

Business Unit

Corporate Claims

Benefits

We offer competitive benefits packages for full-time and part-time employees* Full-time employees have access to medical, dental, and vision coverage, wellness plans, parental leave, adoption assistance, and tuition reimbursement. Full-time and eligible part‑time employees also enjoy Paid Time Off and paid holidays, a 401(k) plan with company match, an employee stock purchase plan, and commuter benefits.

• Medical, dental, and vision coverage
• Wellness plans
• Parental leave
• Adoption assistance
• Tuition reimbursement
• Paid Time Off and paid holidays
• 401(k) plan with company match
• Employee stock purchase plan
• Commuter benefits

Compensation varies by role, level, and location and is influenced by skills, experience, and business needs.

Learn more at http://www.gaig.com/careers.

*Excludes seasonal employees and interns.