Area Supervisor Milwaukee, WI Market

Papa John's International; West Allis (WI); On-site; USD 63,000 - 77,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Base salary

Monthly performance bonuses

401(k)

Medical/dental/vision insurance

Paid time off

Flexible scheduling

Job summary

Papa John’s International is seeking an Area Supervisor to oversee multiple locations and restore operational standards across the market. This role focuses on building high‑performing teams, driving consistent performance, and delivering turnaround results with support from a multi‑unit leadership team.

The position emphasizes leadership in challenging environments, sequence of improvements, and a pathway for long‑term career growth within the organization.

Qualifications

• Proven experience leading multiple stores or units in fast-paced environments.
• Strong coaching and people development skills.
• Ability to drive performance improvements and manage change.
• Willingness and ability to travel daily across the Milwaukee area.

Responsibilities

• Lead and oversee operations across multiple Papa John’s locations.
• Recruit, train, and mentor store leaders and teams.
• Improve labor, food cost, inventory, speed of service and customer satisfaction.
• Reset expectations and reinforce company values to build a performance-driven culture.
• Ensure compliance with brand policies, procedures, and regulations.
• Visit assigned stores daily to lead, support, and supervise.

Skills

Multi-unit leadership

Coaching & development

Turnaround leadership

Travel readiness

Operational leadership

Job description

Area Supervisor – Papa Johns

Compensation: base salary + monthly performance bonuses

Benefits: 401(k), medical/dental/vision insurance, paid time off, flexible scheduling

Schedule: Full-time, daily travel between assigned locations

Requirements: Valid driver’s license

About the Role

Papa Johns is seeking a high‑caliber Area Supervisor to oversee multiple locations. This is a pivotal leadership role focused on rebuilding operational standards, strengthening teams, and driving consistent performance across a market that has experienced recent turnover and is in need of structured leadership.

This position is ideal for a leader who thrives in challenging environments and sees operational turnaround work as a meaningful step toward long‑term career growth. You will have the opportunity to make a measurable impact while being supported by a multi‑unit leadership team committed to developing you as you develop your market.

Key Responsibilities

• Operational Leadership: Ensure all stores meet Papa Johns’ standards for product quality, service, cleanliness, and safety.
• Team Development: Recruit, train, coach, and mentor store‑level leaders and team members to build capability and accountability.
• Performance Management: Drive improvements in labor management, food cost, inventory control, speed of service, and customer satisfaction.
• Culture Building: Reset expectations, reinforce company values, and establish a positive, performance‑driven environment.
• Compliance & Standards: Maintain adherence to brand policies, operational procedures, and regulatory requirements.
• Daily Travel: Visit assigned stores regularly to provide hands‑on leadership, support, and oversight.

Qualifications

• Proven experience in multi‑unit or store‑level leadership within quick‑service, retail, or hospitality environments
• Strong coaching, communication, and people‑development skills
• Ability to lead through change and motivate teams in challenging conditions
• Solid understanding of operational systems, financial controls, and performance metrics
• Valid driver’s license and ability to travel daily within the Milwaukee area

What We Offer

• Competitive base salary of $70,000
• Monthly performance bonuses based on goal achievement
• Comprehensive benefits package including 401(k), insurance, PTO, and flexible scheduling
• A leadership team committed to supporting your development and long‑term career growth
• The opportunity to lead a meaningful turnaround and build a strong professional track record

Position Summary

This role is designed for a leader who wants to build something lasting — someone who sees the challenge of revitalizing underdeveloped stores as an opportunity to showcase their capability, elevate teams, and accelerate their career trajectory.

Company Introduction

Papa John's is an American pizza restaurant franchise. It is the fourth largest pizza delivery restaurant chain in the United States, with headquarters in Jeffersontown, Kentucky, a suburb of Louisville. Our pizza family is as hungry for perfection today as we were when we first opened our doors more than 30 years ago. And we're driven to be the best at making innovative new products and recipes.

It is the policy of Papa John’s to provide equal employment opportunities for all applicants and team members without regard to race, color, religion, sex, age, marital status or civil partnership, national or ethnic origin, pregnancy or maternity, veteran status, uniformed service (as defined by 10 U.S.C. §101 (a)(5)), protected disability status, genetic information, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender reassignment, or gender expression, or any other characteristic protected by statute or law.