Store Shift Supervisor

Pet Supplies Plus; Town of Oconomowoc (WI); On-site; USD 37,000 - 48,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Neighborly team

Career growth

Competitive pay

Pet-first environment

Employee discounts

Flexible schedule

Training & development

Job summary

Pet Supplies Plus in Wisconsin is seeking a Store Shift Supervisor who leads the team on your shift, delivering neighborly service and smooth daily operations while ensuring every neighbor has a great in-store experience.

The role requires at least 2 years of retail experience, strong customer service and sales skills, and the ability to stand for long periods; you’ll mentor staff, help customers, and maintain a clean, organized store.

Qualifications

• 2+ years of retail experience.
• Strong customer service and sales skills.
• Basic proficiency with Microsoft Office or similar tools.

Responsibilities

• Lead the team during shift to deliver neighborly service.
• Assist customers with product selection and recommendations.
• Process transactions, support the register, and handle returns.
• Support daily operations to ensure a smooth shift.
• Maintain a clean, safe, and organized store environment.
• Step in to support the team during busy periods.

Skills

Retail supervision

Customer service

Team leadership

Communication

Tools

POS system

Microsoft Office

Job description

• Be part of a neighborly, community-focused team
• Competitive Pay

Benefits

• Be part of a neighborly, community-focused team
• Career Growth & Advancement Opportunities
• Competitive Pay
• Pet-First, People-First Environment
• Employee discounts
• Flexible schedule
• Training & development

Do 4-pawed friends make you smile? Do you enjoy cool pet products that make tails wag? So do we! If you are a paws-on leader of the pack who believes any dog can learn new tricks, then come work in our neighborhood.

As a Store Shift Supervisor, you are pawsitively passionate about people and their pets. You will help lead the team during your shift, ensuring every neighbor has an exceptional, neighborly experience while keeping daily operations running smoothly.

What You’ll Do

• Deliver pawsitively exceptional, neighborly service by helping a pet parent pick the perfect toy for a lab who loves to fetch
• Show a fourth grader how to test their fish tank water, all while creating a fun, welcoming experience
• Support daily operations and help ensure a smooth, efficient shift
• Assign tasks and help team members manage priorities and time
• Assist customers with product selection and provide recommendations
• Process transactions, support the register, and handle returns or issues
• Place and manage special orders and online order fulfillment
• Reconcile cash drawers and complete end-of-day procedures
• Maintain a clean, safe, and organized store environment
• Step in to support the team wherever needed during busy periods

You May Be a Great Fit If You

• Are a reliable, hands-on leader who leads by example
• Have strong customer service and communication skills
• Are organized and able to manage multiple tasks at once
• Thrive in a fast-paced, team-oriented environment
• Enjoy working with pets and people

Requirements and Responsibilities

• 2+ years of retail experience
• Strong customer service and sales skills
• Basic proficiency with Microsoft Office or similar tools
• Ability to stand, bend, stoop, twist, and move for extended periods of time
• Ability to lift up to 65 lbs
• Ability to climb ladders and perform physical store tasks
• Reliable transportation and ability to work flexible schedules (evenings, weekends, holidays)
• Must be 18+ years old and able to meet hiring requirements set by the local franchise owner

This location is independently owned and operated by a franchise owner. Your application will go directly to the franchise owner hiring team. Each PSP franchised business is solely and exclusively responsible for determining local hiring decisions, compensation, benefits, and other terms of employment. You acknowledge that if you are offered employment at a PSP franchised business, your sole and exclusive employer is the local franchise business that hired you, not PSP Franchise Operations. PSP Franchise Operations does not participate in any local employment decisions or practices within its franchised businesses. All inquiries about employment should be made directly to the franchise location.