Senior Subrogation Attorney (Remote, New Jersey)

Allstate Insurance Company; Clark (NJ); Hybrid; USD 91,000 - 154,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Connectivity stipend

Job summary

Allstate Insurance Company in the United States is seeking a Senior Subrogation Attorney to lead complex auto and property subrogation matters from investigation through resolution.

You will collaborate with claims partners and business stakeholders, provide strategic litigation guidance, and represent Allstate in court, arbitration, mediation, and trial proceedings, while managing a high-volume caseload in a remote-friendly environment.

Qualifications

• Juris Doctorate required and active New Jersey State Bar membership.
• 4+ years of litigation experience including insurance defense or subrogation.
• Proficiency in negotiation, deposition, and trial practice; strong legal research skills.

Responsibilities

• Manage complex auto and property subrogation litigation from investigation through resolution.
• Lead negotiations with carriers, attorneys, and third parties to maximize recovery.
• Prepare and present witnesses; conduct depositions and represent Allstate in hearings, arbitrations, and trials.
• Monitor legal developments and advise on impacts to subrogation strategy.
• Collaborate with claims teams to ensure alignment with business objectives.

Skills

Case Management

Insurance Defense

Litigation

Stakeholder Management

Subrogation Claims

Education

Juris Doctorate

Active New Jersey State Bar

Tools

Microsoft Office

LexisNexis

Legal research platforms

Job description

At Allstate, great things happen when our people work together to protect families and their belongings from life’s uncertainties. And for more than 90 years, our innovative drive has kept us a step ahead of our customers’ evolving needs. From advocating for seat belts, air bags and graduated driving laws, to being an industry leader in pricing sophistication, telematics, and, more recently, device and identity protection.

Job Description

Join Allstate's legal frontline and play a critical role in recovering losses and advancing strategic litigation outcomes. As a Senior Subrogation Attorney, you will lead complex auto and property subrogation matters from investigation through resolution, while providing legal guidance to claims partners and business stakeholders.

This role offers the opportunity to independently manage sophisticated litigation, develop recovery strategies, conduct negotiations, and represent Allstate in court, arbitration, mediation, and trial proceedings. You will collaborate closely with legal and claims teams, provide thought leadership on subrogation matters, and contribute to meaningful financial and operational impact through successful recovery efforts.

This remote‑based position requires occasional in‑person attendance for court appearances throughout New Jersey, as needed, and participation in monthly or quarterly team events at our Clark, NJ office.

Key Responsibilities

• Manage all aspects of complex auto and property subrogation litigation from investigation through resolution, including discovery, depositions, motion practice, negotiations, arbitrations, trials, and post‑trial motions.
• Investigate and evaluate subrogation opportunities, determine liability and damages, and develop recovery strategies to maximize results.
• Lead negotiations with carriers, attorneys, and third parties to achieve favorable recovery outcomes and efficient dispute resolution.
• Review new file assignments, develop litigation strategies, and provide legal guidance aligned with business objectives.
• Partner with claims professionals and business stakeholders to provide legal counsel on litigation risks, recovery opportunities, and case strategy.
• Prepare and present witnesses, conduct depositions, and represent the Company in hearings, mediations, arbitrations, and trials.
• Analyze claims files, expert reports, legal authorities, and other case materials to support litigation strategy and recovery recommendations.
• Prepare and argue pre‑trial and post‑trial motions, settlement proceedings, and other complex legal matters.
• Monitor developments in applicable laws, regulations, and case law, providing proactive guidance on potential impacts to subrogation recoveries and litigation strategy.
• Manage a high‑volume caseload and legal projects effectively while collaborating with attorneys, claims teams, and support staff to drive successful outcomes.

Education

• Juris Doctorate required.
• Active membership in good standing with the New Jersey State Bar required.

Minimum Requirements

• 4+ years of litigation experience, including insurance defense, subrogation, personal injury, property damage litigation, or related practice areas.
• Demonstrated ability to independently manage a substantial litigation caseload from inception through resolution.
• Experience conducting depositions, mediations, arbitrations, hearings, and other litigation proceedings.
• Strong knowledge of civil litigation procedures, legal strategy development, negotiation, and dispute resolution.
• Proficiency in Microsoft Office, LexisNexis (preferred), and legal research platforms.
• Ability to collaborate effectively with attorneys, paralegals, claims professionals, and support staff.
• Comfortable working in a remote environment and willing to travel throughout New Jersey for court appearances, depositions, mediations, and other litigation proceedings.

Skills

Case Management, Insurance Defense, Litigation, Stakeholder Management, Subrogation Claims

Compensation

Compensation offered for this role is 90,700.00 - 153,925.00 annually and is based on experience and qualifications.

The candidate(s) offered this position will be required to submit to a background investigation.

Joining our team isn’t just a job — it’s an opportunity. One that takes your skills and pushes them to the next level. One that encourages you to challenge the status quo. One where you can shape the future of protection while supporting causes that mean the most to you. Joining our team means being part of something bigger – a winning team making a meaningful impact.

Allstate generally does not sponsor individuals for employment‑based visas for this position.

Effective July 1, 2014, under Indiana House Enrolled Act (HEA) 1242, it is against public policy of the State of Indiana and a discriminatory practice for an employer to discriminate against a prospective employee on the basis of status as a veteran by refusing to employ an applicant on the basis that they are a veteran of the armed forces of the United States, a member of the Indiana National Guard or a member of a reserve component.

For jobs in San Francisco, please click “here” for information regarding the San Francisco Fair Chance Ordinance.

For jobs in Los Angeles, please click “here” for information regarding the Los Angeles Fair Chance Initiative for Hiring Ordinance.

To view the “EEO Know Your Rights” poster click “here”. This poster provides information concerning the laws and procedures for filing complaints of violations of the laws with the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs.

To view the FMLA poster, click “here”. This poster summarizing the major provisions of the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and telling employees how to file a complaint.

It is the Company’s policy to employ the best qualified individuals available for all jobs. Therefore, any discriminatory action taken on account of an employee’s ancestry, age, color, disability, genetic information, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual and reproductive health decision, marital status, medical condition, military or veteran status, national origin, race (include traits historically associated with race, including, but not limited to, hair texture and protective hairstyles), religion (including religious dress), sex, or sexual orientation that adversely affects an employee's terms or conditions of employment is prohibited. This policy applies to all aspects of the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, hiring, training, salary administration, promotion, job assignment, benefits, discipline, and separation of employment.

Allstate provides a comprehensive technology setup, including a laptop, monitors, headset, keyboard, and mouse. Employees eligible to work from home also receive a monthly connectivity reimbursement to help offset internet costs.

When working from home, you must have a dedicated, private workspace free from distractions, along with appropriate desk and seating. Reliable internet is required, with minimum speeds of 50 MB download and 5 MB upload.

To help create a more personal and engaging experience, we ask that you join with your camera on if your interview is virtual. Please also have a Valid Photo Identification available at the start of your interview. If you require any accommodations or have questions ahead of your interview please reach out to your recruiter.

Note: Internal candidates are only asked to join on video; a Valid Photo Identification is not needed for the interview.