Claims Examiner- Property Claims

USLI; Oak Brook (IL); On-site; USD 65,000 - 95,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Performance-based triannual bonuses

100% paid medical benefits for full-time employees

Profit-sharing program

Free lunch every day onsite

450+ personal and professional development courses

Job summary

A leading insurance company in Oak Brook, IL is seeking a Claims Examiner or Associate Claims Examiner to evaluate claims and negotiate settlements. The ideal candidate will have necessary experience in property claims and strong analytical and communication skills. This position offers a competitive salary range of $65K - $115K depending on the role, and a supportive work environment focused on diversity and inclusion.

Qualifications

• 2+ years of relevant experience for Associate Claims Examiner.
• 7+ years of relevant experience for Claims Examiner.
• Experience handling first party property claims as an examiner, adjuster, paralegal, or attorney.

Responsibilities

• Review coverage and prepare necessary disclaimers.
• Conduct detailed investigations into claims.
• Manage independent adjusters during the investigation.
• Evaluate liability exposure based on statutory and case law.
• Maintain accurate reserves for claims.
• Negotiate settlements with claimants or attorneys.
• Prepare comprehensive reports for reserves and claims.
• Collaborate with underwriting and compliance teams.

Skills

Analytical problem-solving

Communication skills

Negotiation expertise

Organizational skills

Technical insurance knowledge

Job description

This range is provided by USLI. Your actual pay will be based on your skills and experience — talk with your recruiter to learn more.

Job Title: Claims Examiner or Associate Examiner- Property

Location: Oak Brook, IL

About Us: At USLI, we’re not just about insurance — we are committed to making a difference, both internally and externally. Our community is built upon five values: Caring, Attitude, Respect, Empathy and Energy. Our commitment to these values leads us to make better decisions and furthers our true sense of community. By joining our team, you'll be part of a vibrant organization that values innovation, collaboration and growth. Here, you’ll have the opportunity to shape the future of insurance and make a meaningful impact.

Your Role: You’ll play a critical role in evaluating coverage, liability and damages for each unique claim. You’ll collaborate across teams and with external stakeholders to effectively investigate, negotiate and resolve claims.

Position affords five days per month to work remotely.

Key Responsibilities:

• Coverage review: Confirm coverage by reviewing the first notice of loss and policy details; prepare DISCLAIMERS and reservation of rights letters as necessary
• Thorough investigation: Conduct detailed investigations into claims, including liability and damages assessment, witness interviews, scene inspections and evidence collection
• Independent adjusters: Retain and provide directions to independent adjusters while managing all aspects of the investigation process
• Liability analysis: Apply statutory and case law to evaluate liability exposure and ensure joint tortfeasors contribute their fair share
• Reserve maintenance: Maintain accurate reserves reflecting liability and damages as claims develop
• File management: Proactively manage claim files, negotiate settlements directly with claimants or attorneys, oversee defense counsel and ensure effective litigation management
• Reporting: Prepare comprehensive reserve authority requests, reinsurance reports, serious loss reports and coverage position letters
• Cross-team collaboration: Provide updates and collaborate with underwriting, compliance and actuarial teams to maintain healthy products

What You’ll Bring:

• Problem-solving skills: Analytical and creative problem-solving capabilities with a focus on liability and damage evaluation
• Communication: Strong oral and written communication skills to effectively interact with all stakeholders
• Negotiation expertise: Assertive decision-making with effective negotiation and conflict management skills
• Organization: Strong organizational and time management skills to manage multiple priorities efficiently
• Technical knowledge: Familiarity with insurance coverage, negligence law and claim evaluation processes

Qualifications:

• 2+ years of relevant experience for Associate Claims Examiner
• 7+ years of relevant experience for Claims Examiner
• Previous experience handling first party property claims as an examiner, adjuster, paralegal, attorney or in other transferable roles
• Excess liability experience: Experience with excess liability claims is preferred
• Jurisdiction Knowledge: Multi-jurisdictional knowledge, advanced degrees and/or JD are a plus

Passion and drive can be just as important as experience. If you’re excited about this opportunity, we’d love to hear from you!

Salary range: Associate Claims Examiner: $65K - $95K; Claims Examiner: $85K - $115K

What We Offer: One of the advantages of working at USLI is the competitive salary and benefits program we offer full-time and eligible part-time employees. Benefits include performance-based triannual bonuses, medical benefits paid at 100% for full-time employees and 80% for eligible part-time employees, a profit-sharing program, free lunch every day while onsite and more than 450 annual personal and professional development courses. Explore more company benefits.

Why USLI? At USLI, we are committed to fostering a vibrant and inclusive community that celebrates the rich diversity of all ethnicities, nationalities, abilities, genders, gender identities, sexual orientations, ages, religions, socioeconomic backgrounds and life experiences. We understand the importance of continuous learning, self-reflection, acknowledging our biases and expanding our perspectives beyond our own. We actively encourage open dialogue on diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging to support a workplace where every individual feels valued, respected and empowered to contribute at their fullest potential. Join us in building a diverse and inclusive environment where our shared values drive us toward excellence.