Outlet Warehouse Key Holder

Goodwill NYNJ; South Hackensack (NJ); On-site; USD 42,000 - 54,000; Full time

Benefits offered by this job

Generous Time off policy

Health, wellness and financial support

Robust health benefits

Retirement matching

Transit and commuter benefits

Job summary

Goodwill NYNJ is seeking a Key Holder to assist the Store Manager in daily operations and elevate the customer experience at the South Hackensack location. You will model CARE service standards, train associates, and execute Brand standards in the Store Manager's absence.

Responsibilities include leading a customer-first team, coaching to deliver excellent service, and collaborating with sales specialists. The role requires adaptability to shift schedules and a commitment to Goodwill's mission.

Qualifications

• Minimum 1+ year experience in retail store supervisory.
• High School Diploma, equivalent, or combination of education and relevant experience.
• Proven ability to drive and exceed store results.
• Proven ability to build lasting relationships with customers and colleagues.
• Ability to work a flexible schedule including evenings, weekends and holidays.

Responsibilities

• Lead a high performing, customer-first oriented team and coach associates.
• Train and coach staff to achieve all set expectations and Brand standards.
• Execute operations in the absence of the Store Manager.
• Drive partnership on the selling floor between sales specialists and store staff.
• Resolve customer issues quickly and respectfully to ensure a positive experience.
• Communicate product needs to stock team to keep floor replenished.
• Maintain neat, clean, organized selling floor and current visual displays.
• Enforce company policies and procedures and support leadership.
• Encourage customers to participate in Goodwill Rewards and learn the Mission.

Skills

Retail supervisory

Team leadership

Customer service

Strong communication

Flexible schedule

Education

High School Diploma

Job description

Posted Friday, August 21, 2026 at 4:00 AM

The Awesome Things You’ll Do

Location: Warehouse South Hackensack

Role: Key Holder

The Key Holder is responsible for supporting the Store Manager in the daily operation of the store and overall customer experience. He/she demonstrates leadership by modelling Goodwill NYNJ CARE service standards to elevate sales performance. This individual will help to train and coach associates to achieve all set expectations. The Key Holder has the ability to execute all operational functions to Brand standards and drive positive customer experiences in the absence of the Store Manager.

• Lead a high performing customer first orientated team. Coach and provide feedback to the team as necessary to ensure all customers and donors serviced in the store are given the full CARE experience in line with brand strategies. Manage customer flow to ensure the best possible experience and that every customer is engaged.
• Lead by example by setting the standard to deliver excellent service to customers.
• Drive partnership on the selling floor between sales specialists and store associates.
• Develop and retain talented employees, by coaching in the moment and providing feedback to the Store manager to support training and development.
• Resolve all customer complaints and issues quickly, efficiently and with respect resulting in an overall positive experience. Partner with the Store Manager where necessary.
• In absence of the Store manager, responsible for executing all operations.
• Possess a strong understanding of the business and effectively communicate needs and ideas to elevate the business.
• Assist Store Manager in driving Goodwill brand loyalty through coaching sales team to share knowledge of Goodwill Rewards program and Mission, consistently educating customers of the benefits of participation.
• Possess a thorough understanding of company policies and procedures and consistently follow and enforce company guidelines on operations.
• Communicate product needs to the stock team ensuring that flow of product to the floor is quick and efficient.
• Ensure the selling floor is neat, clean, organized and reflects the correct visual image at all times.
• Ensure presentation of all windows, displays, fixtures and all visual areas are reflective of current visual direction.
• Enforce and support Store Manager in holding team accountable to Company policies and procedures.
• Additional duties as required.

Activities are subject to change / be added to meet business needs with management approval.

Customer Service:

• Verbally great customer and offer assistance within 30 seconds.
• Inform all customers of weekly sale color and newly produced color, make announcement every 15 minutes.
• Offer customer a shopping cart or basket while in the store.
• Keep sales floor and fitting rooms clean and free of clutter, hangers and clothes off the floor.
• Answer the phone in a professional manner.

If stationed on the register:

• Greet all customers with a warm greeting, a smile, eye contact, positive attitude ask each customer if they are a Goodwill Rewards Member, if not, discuss benefits and offer to enroll the customer ask each customer to Round Up their purchase and discuss our Mission.
• Thank each customer for their purchase, hand them the receipt, invite them back to the store
• Keep register area clean and free of clutter.
• Round Up goal = 43%

If requested to work production, the benchmarks are as follows:

• Empty Z rack = 15 min (85 pieces)
• Empty grey cart of wares = 15 min (35 pieces)
• Empty grey cart of shoes = 15 min (35 pieces)
• Sort: 1 blue bin = 1 hour Hang: 2 racks = 1 hr (170 pieces)
• Wares: 1 hour = 2 grey cart of wares (70 pieces/hr)
• Shoes: 1 hour = 2 grey cart of shoes (70 pieces/hr)
• Textiles: 2 hours = 1 complete rack of textiles
• Benchmarks are subject to change to meet business needs with management approval.

Our Must Haves

• Minimum 1+ year experience in retail store supervisory required.
• High School Diploma, equivalent, or combination of education and relevant experience required.
• Skills Required: Describe the minimum skills required or preferred
• Proven ability to drive and exceed individual and store results.
• Proven ability to build lasting relationships with customers and colleagues.
• Ability to adapt to and engage with different customers.
• Strong interpersonal and communication skills (verbal and written) with customers, sales leadership team and colleagues.
• Demonstrated collaborative skills and ability to work well within a team.
• Ability to receive feedback and take action when appropriate.
• Accuracy and attention to detail required.
• Ability to work a flexible schedule based on business needs which includes, evenings, weekends and holidays.
• Ability to handle multiple tasks while working in a fast ‑ paced and deadline ‑ oriented environment.
• Special Working Conditions: Describe unusual working conditions or environmental factors.
• See Attached Physical Demand Analysis

Special Working Conditions

• Report all employee relation issues in a timely and effective manner, partnering with the Store Manager and HR when necessary.
• Assist the Store Manager to recruit, train, and develop team ensuring all positions are filled in a timely manner with qualified candidates.
• Continually provide feedback to the Store Manager on employee level of proficiency in their role and support with training and development.
• Assist in ensuring the integrity of staff’s time and attendance.
• Ensure Dress Codes and Uniforms are always professional, reflective of Brand image and always adhered to.
• Enforce of all company policies and procedures, standards of operations and support leadership team.

What We Offer

• Generous Time off policy to use when you need it
• Health, wellness and financial resources to help you achieve our personal goals
• Robust health benefits including medical, dental, vision, parental leaves and company sponsored life insurance
• Retirement matching programs and contributions
• Transit and commuter benefits

We believe in creating space for everyone to do their best work and have individual and collective impact. We believe that challenging the status quo and setting ambitious goals in the name of doing more good. We believe that being your best self and helping others do the same is how we bring our mission alive. Even if you don’t think you meet all the qualifications listed for the job, we would love to hear from you!

If you require a reasonable accommodation at any point in the application or interview process, or if you are unable to apply through our recruitment portal, please contact us at [e-mail] . We are happy to assist and ensure you have an equal opportunity to apply.